JGLS Sonepat has continued its steady climb up the QS World University Rankings law subject rankings and is now in the top 100 while NLSIU Bengaluru had disappeared, following both having managed to crack the QS’ metrics last year.
In last year’s QS subject rankings, JGLS had been ranked in the broad 101-150th category, while NLS had made it to the 151-200-rank bracket.
This year, JGLS’ parent university, OP Jindal Global University was ranked 76th with a score of 70.5, which is around 2 points higher than last year’s.
We have reached out to an NLSIU spokesperson and vice-chancellor (VC) Prof Sudhir Krishnaswamy for comment, though we understand that its 2020 inclusion had followed a semi-independent initiative to crack global rankings carried out by a faculty member under the previous VC, Prof Venkata Rao.
A QS spokesperson confirmed that for its subject rankings no specific applications were required by universities to be included, and that those rankings were purely based on objective metrics researched by the company (see below for more details).
We have requested further comment from QS about why NLSIU was not in the list this year.
The rankings may be useful for domestic rankings such as the government’s National Institutional Ranking Framework (NIRF) (which JGLS incidentally has refused to take part in but where NLSIU has been ranked first since the start).
Besides domestic bragging rights, another likely driver to perform well in QS may be to encourage overseas students to join your law school (which has been stated to be important for both JGLS and NLSIU).
Recipe for climb: Research
According to a JGLS press release, its improved performance was primarily due to its improvement in the two research metrics:
JGLS’s current global rank of 76 compared to previous rank in the 101-150 bracket is driven by a 45% increase in research citation and a 25% increase in the H-index of research output of JGLS.
As we had reported last year after inquiry with QS in a more in-depth report about its methodology, those two metrics account for only a total of 20% of the total QS score, which are made up of:
- Academic reputation 50%
- Employer reputation 30%
- H Index citations 15%
- Citations per paper 5%
This year QS has not listed a breakdown of individual rankings on its website but only an overall score, though we have requested more details from QS and will update this article when we hear from them.
Last year, JGLS had got an overall score of around 68 according to that methodology, with the following individual scores:
- academic reputation: 67.7
- employer reputation: 83.3
- H-index: 45.5
- Citations per paper: 55.4
The QS rankings, as all rankings, are of course easily hackable, and JGLS has for at least three years now had an department dealing with improving its performance in league tables (dubbed the Office of Rankings, Benchmarking and Institutional Transformation (ORBIT)).
In the global rankings, JGLS is only 0.2 points behind George Washington University, and is ahead of the universities of Bristol and Geneva, tied at 70.5 points (we are not sure what the tie-breaker criteria are).
Amongst all Asia-region law schools included in the rankings, JGLS came 16th (see below).
While NUS Singapore is at the top with 86.3 and a global rank of 10, the lower Asian ranks are clustered much closer together, with a spread from 73.8 to 69.4 between 7th and 20th place.
Besides NUS, the top 10 of the global QS law rankings include four usual university suspects from the UK and five from the US (Harvard, Oxford and Cambridge are in the top three, followed by Yale, Stanford, LSE, Columbia, NYU and Berkeley).
Due disclosure: JGLS is currently an advertiser on Legally India.
Top 20 Asia law rankings by QS
Global Rank | Asian University Name | Overall QS Score | |
10 | National University of Singapore (NUS) | Singapore, Singapore | 86.3 |
21 | The University of Tokyo | Tokyo,Japan | 81.3 |
21 | The University of Hong Kong | Hong Kong,Hong Kong SAR | 81.3 |
27 | Tsinghua University | Beijing,China (Mainland) | 79.6 |
28 | Peking University | Beijing,China (Mainland) | 79.4 |
33 | Seoul National University | Seoul,South Korea | 77 |
48 | The Chinese University of Hong Kong (CUHK) | Hong Kong,Hong Kong SAR | 73.8 |
51 | Renmin (People’s) University of China | Beijing,China (Mainland) | 73.1 |
56 | Kyoto University | Kyoto,Japan | 72.5 |
58 | Korea University | Seoul,South Korea | 72.2 |
67 | Zhejiang University | Hangzhou,China (Mainland) | 71.3 |
70 | City University of Hong Kong | Hong Kong,Hong Kong SAR | 71.1 |
70 | Shanghai Jiao Tong University | Shanghai,China (Mainland) | 71.1 |
70 | Waseda University | Tokyo,Japan | 71.1 |
74 | National Taiwan University (NTU) | Taipei City,Taiwan | 70.9 |
76 | O.P. Jindal Global University | Sonipat,India | 70.5 |
84 | Yonsei University | Seoul,South Korea | 69.7 |
87 | Wuhan University | Wuhan,China (Mainland) | 69.5 |
88 | Fudan University | Shanghai,China (Mainland) | 69.4 |
88 | Keio University | Tokyo,Japan | 69.4 |
threads most popular
thread most upvoted
comment newest
first oldest
first
We need chancellors like Raj in NLUs. JGLS is doing too good and is defying any and all conceptions about it.
Legal skills are really secondary in fresh grads; there are a few thousand kids who can, ceteris paribus, do the job well.
What gives you an edge is poise and polish. If your parents can pay a million INR a year, you'll already have the necessary social capital, and on pure percentages, are far more "presentable" than someone who slogged and clawed their way up into a Tier-1 NLU.
If I'm an employer and want posh rich kids who can interact with equally posh clients, JGLS is an obvious place to start.
Quote:
- JGLS has hired dozens of NLU grads but NLU VCs avoid hiring them (excepting Sudhir Krishnaswamy now).
- Shamnad Basheer was ill-treated by the NUJS VC, who also hired his own PhD students from Mysore instead of NLU alumni. Sidharth Chauhan was sacked by the NLSIU VC. Sudhir Krishnaswamy's appointment was opposed by the then NLSIU VC and admin. SS Singh at NLIU, Sukhpal Singh Yadav at HNLU: all of them refused to hire NLU alumni. In comparison, NLU grads are welcomed at JGLS.
- Certain NLU VCs have opposed hiring NLU alumni as visiting lecturers. At JGLS many NLU alumni practising in Delhi give visiting lectures.
So who deserves criticism: NLU admin or JGLS admin?
Source - pib.gov.in/Pressreleaseshare.aspx?PRID=1541801
But I am pretty sure then these people would be like “NIRF rankings don’t count, look at me I am publishing my personal rankings in the comments section of LI these are credible”
1. NLSIU
2. NALSAR
3. NLUD
4. NUJS
5. GNLU
6. NLUJ
7. NLIU
8. JGLS
9. MNLU-MUM
10.RGNUL
11. NUALS
12. NLUO
13. RMLNLU
14. Symbiosis Pune
15. GLC
16. Symbiosis Noida
17. GGSIP
18. HNLU
19.MNLU-NAG
20. TNNLS
This is a very serious issue about LI's code of conduct, and a layreader could very well suspect that this "news" itself was fed in by Jiggles' PR team (which by itself is not an issue) coupled with an advertising commitment. That is very problematic.
All things considered, particularly since NLS was in the rankings last year and there is a larger element of Indian legal education and whether it is possible for Indian law schools to crack global rankings (and how), this story would certainly qualify, besides the fact that this JGLS press release has been covered very widely elsewhere also in a much less analytical manner.
This story also contains a due disclosure at the bottom that JGLS is currently an advertiser (in case it wasn't obvious from the banner ads), so readers can make up their own mind and take that into account, if required, about whether the story is fair or not. If there are any particular issues with this story, please do let us know.
However, I must also disagree with the QS Asia ranking. Apart from NUS Singapore, I don't think the other colleges are that good. Have you ever heard of a top law professor from China or Japan or South Korea or Taiwan? How can China be ranked high when the country has no free speech and the worst human rights record in the world?
Domestically NLS > NLU D > JGLS
But i must say, international reputation doesn’t matter a lot because Indian bar laws make domestic reputation much more relevant
2009
JGLS - we're here!
Everyone else - you'll never be as good as the NLUs
www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/jindal-global-law-school-launches-llm-dean-responds-to-critics-20100209-478
2010
JGLS ties up with Cambridge, Yale and Queens
Everyone else - you'll never be as good as the NLUs
www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/jindal-starts-police-academy-india-with-cambridge-20100317-587
www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/jindal-global-law-school-starts-student-exchanges-collaboration-with-canadians-20101114-1505
www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/jindal-global-law-school-strengthens-bonds-with-yale-as-second-year-admissions-positive-20101101-1466
2011
JGLS starts its first dual degree LLB - JD
Everyone else - you'll never be as good as the NLUs
www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/jindal-indiana-university-us-to-offer-combined-llb-with-jd-in-6-or-4-years-20120221-2588
2012
JGU tops MPL (albiet briefly)
Everyone else - you'll never be as good as the NLUs
www.legallyindia.com/mooting/jindal-tops-mpl-4-standings-after-5-moots-a-wins-for-nlu-d-nlsiu-nujs-a-rmlnlu-20120930-3151
2017
JGU applies for IoE
Everyone else - you shouldnt be allowed to apply coz NLUs cant. In any case, you'll never be as good as the NLUs
www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/jgu-has-applied-for-institution-of-eminence-status-nlus-possibly-can-t-20171212-8932
2018
SC cites 4 JGLS faculty in Koushal judgment
Everyone else - yes but it was published in the NUJS Law Review. You'll never be as good as the NLUs
www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/how-academia-came-of-age-with-377-sc-relied-on-these-indian-journals-blawgs-in-pro-gay-rights-judgment-20180906-9522
July 2019
JGU gets into world uni rankings
Everyone else - jugaad
www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/jindal-gu-sonepat-hacks-into-lower-reaches-of-qs-world-college-rankings-in-benchmarking-drive-though-methodology-a-bit-hazy-20190619-10646
September 2019
JGU is an IoE
Everyone else - Doesnt count coz NLUs arent nationalised
www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/jgls-iit-kharagpur-du-recommended-as-national-institutions-of-eminence-as-gov-t-says-nlus-won-t-get-central-support-20190803-10772
Three former NLU VCs join JGLS as faculty
Everyone else - HOW DARE THEY! They should teach at NLUs forever!
www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/jgls-scoops-3-former-vice-chancellors-as-profs-baxi-mp-singh-chimni-bb-pande-to-boost-research-teaching-phds-20190906-10831
June 2020
JGLS starts Online LLM
Everyone else - They shouldnt be allowed to do so, coz NLUs cant
www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/jgls-starts-online-llm-aims-for-100-takers-powered-by-ioe-ugc-exemption-nls-looks-to-scale-e-learning-to-100-000-students-20200603-11466
August 2020
Practicing lawyers teach pro bono at JGLS
Everyone else - they should be teaching at NLUs
www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/jgls-preps-for-lucky-1-sep-fresher-start-ropes-in-10-senior-counsel-to-teach-200-final-years-lit-life-courses-20200806-11601
October 2020
JGLR is indexed by SCOPUS
Everyone else - SCOPUS has made a mistake by not including the law reviews by NLUs
www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/jindal-jglr-journal-first-in-india-to-get-into-scopus-database-for-likely-rankings-publications-boost-20201031-11746
February 2021
JGU gets a further contribution from its Chancellor
Everyone else - why isnt he contributing to NLUs?
www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/jgu-jgls-vows-to-double-in-size-by-2030-with-rs-1-000-cr-gift-from-founder-chancellor-naveen-jindal-20210222-11971
March 2021
JGLS moves up the QS Law rankings, no NLU in sight
Everyone else - QS was relevant last year, but no NLUs means only NIRF counts
JGLS - we are here
Everyone else - hows your student placement?
JGLS - faculty, infra, QS, IoE
Everyone else - hows your student placement?
JGLS - pov of uni is to give holistic education
Everyone else - hows your student placement?
www.legallyindia.com/lawschools/bangalore-law-school-takes-on-world-with-good-advice-20090522-022
1. Full placement stats
2. LLM abroad scholarship stats
3. Details of how the Rs 1,900 crore corpus will be used (Naveen Jindal donation + hostel sale to Goldman Sachs). Will campuses in other cities be opened? Will more scholarships be offered?
4. Is JGLS participating in NIRF? When?
Fast forward to today....
1) The title was given to NLSIU much before QS rankings existed.
2) It is questionable if Singapore, Hong Kong and Japan can be called "East" in a socio-economic sense, because they are first world countries with westernised lifestyles. If you use "East" in a geographical sense, even Australia is included! When NLSIU was called Harvard of the East, it was used in the sense of developing countries in Asia and Africa, not in a strict geographical sense including Australia or Singapore. One way to compare is to look at NAM member countries. Around 120 countries out of 180 in the world are members of NAM. I believe NLSIU surpasses each one of them. In this sense, it can be called Harvard of the East.
3) NLSIU itself did not coin the term. It was coined by eminent jurists and the media. Here is some proof:
Dr Rajeev Dhawan in 1985: The quintessence of this development is symbolized in the proposed National Law School, which is to be the 'Harvard of the East'.
www.jstor.org/stable/840238?seq=1
India today in 2000 and 2001:
"Cliches such as the "Harvard of the East" abound for the 14-year-old National Law School of India University (NLSIU), Bangalore."
Called the Harvard of the East, the National Law School of India University (NLSIU) was established by an Act - Karnataka Act 22 of 1986 - under the sponsorship of the Bar Council of India.
www.indiatoday.in/magazine/cover-story/story/20010521-nlsiu-has-emerged-as-the-leading-indian-institution-for-legal-education-776158-2001-05-21
www.indiatoday.in/magazine/cover-story/story/20000619-best-law-colleges-in-india-nlsiu-bangalore-remains-no.-1-779775-2000-06-19
"What are they serving in the mess today?" "Usual gobi manchurian and bhindi masala. Harvard of the East fare".
There is an alternative explanation for your atrocious and false claims, but Kian would censor that if I mention it here.
Could it have been that due to a larger batch your extrapolation may have been skewed? Seriously interested not here to pick up a fight or troll?
I say this because I have attended both JGLS and an NLU, and my peers were a mix of both places. A bunch of them were idiots, some were serious, and some were exceptional and if they were to be put all together in a room, there is no way you could guess who belonged to which institution.
2. Even assuming one needs to apply, if a contestant drops out of a race, and another wins it, the latter is still considered the winner. Not to mention that NLSIU was behind JGLS last year in the QS ranking.
3. I agree that the ad looks bad and incomplete. Like most ads.
threads most popular
thread most upvoted
comment newest
first oldest
first