[CORRECTION - II]: NUJS, GLC, Symbi outperform (not just come close to) superpower NLSIU in law firm partnership promotions 2015-16

Screenshot 2016-05-30 13.05.29
Screenshot 2016-05-30 13.05.29
NUJS Kolkata, GLC Mumbai and Symbiosis Pune trumped NLSIU Bangalore which was formerly Indian law firms’ favourite law school from which to internally promote partners.

NUJS>GLC>Symbi>NLS in law firm partnerships
NUJS>GLC>Symbi>NLS in law firm partnerships
In a ranking of Indian law firms’ favourite law school from which to internally promote partners, in the 2015-16 financial year NUJS Kolkata outdid NLSIU Bangalore’s performance.

According to Legally India’s reporting of internal partnership promotions effective this financial year (since 15 June 2015), 92 salaried partners from 27 law schools were promoted across 30 Indian and foreign law firms.

NUJS alumni made up for the highest number of partners promoted across various law firms this year, followed by Symbiosis Pune, GLC Mumbai and NLSIU.

This analysis excludes equity partners made up during the same period in all firms where the salaried partner designation exists. But it includes equity partners made up in firms where there is no salaried partner designation. It also includes associate partner promotions in all firms for which we reported such promotions.

NB: Our list is not comprehensive and there might be errors (full source data at the bottom of this article). If you know any of the alma mater of the last few on the list, please do share in comments and we’ll update.

NB 2: An older version of this story incorrectly stated that Symbiosis Pune led the rankings this year and NLSIU, GLC and NUJS were tied up for the second spot. After adding several missed out entries for which we did not have data earlier, our sample size increased from 75 to 92 and then finally to 98 partners. We also deleted certain equity partners incorrectly added to the sample. Error is regretted.

NUJS Kolkata (founded in 1999) accounted for 13 per cent of the pie this year, rising seven ranks since Legally India’s 2013 analysis of promotions over four years at the six largest law firms. NUJS alumni were made partners at Argus, AZB, CAM, HSA Advocates, Talwar Thakore & Associates, Trilegal and Wadia Ghandy. GLC Mumbai, with partners made at ALMT Legal, AZB, DSK, JSA, Khaitan, Little & Co was at 12 per cent/

Symbiosis Pune (founded in 1977) accounted for 11 per cent, compared to only 5 per cent in 2013 across the six largest Indian law firms. Symbiosis alumni were made partners at Argus Partners, AZB & Partners, DSK Legal, Economic Laws Practice (ELP), J Sagar Associates (JSA), Kanth & Associates, Khaitan & Co, Rajani Singhania & Partners, Trilegal and Wadia Ghandy. Symbiosis also had the most number of the ‘Big Seven’ Indian firms in its alumni-partner net.

NLSIU Bangalore (founded in 1987) – the leader of the 2013 rankings – was the last law school to have a double digit percentage in these rankings. Although, in terms of variety, NLSIU covered the widest net of law firms because it had the only alumni promoted in foreign law firms as well. NUJS and GLC were each spread out across six law firms.

Law firms which promoted alumni from NLSIU: Argus, Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas (CAM), S&R Associates, Samvad Partners, Trilegal, Wadia Ghandy and foreign law firms Nixon Peabody, Kirkland & Ellis and Jones Day.

ILS Pune slipped a rank below its 2013 rank and at number five this year it constituted 8 per cent of the total internal promotions. ARA Law, AZB, DSK, JSA, Khaitan and Trilegal were the ones to promote its alumni.

The takeover from Delhi University

In 2013, Delhi University provided a whopping 17%of all new partners at India’s six largest firms (see graphic below from this story).

2009-2013 partnerships at India's six largest law firms
2009-2013 partnerships at India's six largest law firms

Delhi University followed ILS this year with 7 per cent, its alumni made up at Advaita Legal, Dua Associates, HSA, Khaitan, DMD, DSK and JSA.

NLU Jodhpur and Nalsar Hyderabad were tied up at 5 per cent and NLIU Bhopal, Amity Delhi and RA Shah Law College were tied together at 3 per cent.

These were the law schools in the top 11.

Nuals Kochi with one promotion was the only other national law university to have made it into the rankings.

JSA’s 14 salaried partner promotions this year were the highest among all reported law firms. It promoted equally from Symbiosis, ILS, GLC and Amity but did not promote from NLSIU. NLIU was the only NLU which it promoted from. DSK Legal and Trilegal (8 each) and Khaitan (7) were the other heavy hitters. DSK also did not promote from NLS but it did promote from Symbiosis, and Trilegal – which was co-founded by NLS alumni – promoted one alumni from NLS.

(See table for full breakdown of law firm partnerships, by alma mater)

Law firm partnership promotions: June 2015 – May 2016

Law schoolTotal partners madePercentage Rounded
NUJS1313.2653061213
GLC Mumbai1212.2448979612
Symbiosis Pune 1111.224489811
NLSIU1010.2040816310
ILS Pune88.1632653068
Delhi University77.1428571437
NLU Jodhpur55.1020408165
Nalsar 55.1020408165
Amity Delhi33.061224493
NLIU33.061224493
RA Shah Law College33.061224493
Jitendra Chauhan22.0408163272
KC Law College 22.0408163272
Mumbai University22.0408163272
Bharati Vidyapeeth11.0204081631
Goa University11.0204081631
Karnataka University11.0204081631
King’s College11.0204081631
M Krishna Law College11.0204081631
Rizvi Law College11.0204081631
ULC Bangalore11.0204081631
University of Pune11.0204081631
DD University Gorakhpur11.0204081631
BSR College11.0204081631
Nuals Kochi11.0204081631
Dharwad University11.0204081631
9810098

Full list of promotions from 2015-16 reported on (including missing entries)

Note: The tables in this version of the story are different from the older version. Error is regretted.

Comments

NLIU Troll 24 May 2016, 17:39
+2 -0
Vineet V Srivastav was made partner of Aureus Law Partner from NLIU . The news came up at Bar&Bench.
Prachishrivastava 26 May 2016, 06:01
+0 -3
Hi,

Thank you for your comment.

We would have considered adding his name if that report was on Legally India. Our analysis in this story is restricted to our own reporting.

Best wishes,
Prachi
NEWSROOM 26 May 2016, 07:05
+1 -0
ROFL
:I 31 May 2016, 08:00
+0 -0
Ok but does the title still says "superpower NLSIU". haven't you nailed that college enough already?
kianganz 31 May 2016, 08:41
+0 -0
That's just the URL - it's a bit harder to change the text of the link generally, so we only do unless we have to...
Wow 31 May 2016, 12:02
+1 -0
How is this even acceptable to say? You are undermining the credibility of your hard work. Turning a blind eye and excluding matters of fact is not going to help LI. It's in the interest of LI that I say this. Cheers.
NLIU Troll 6 Jun 2016, 12:01
+1 -0
Prachi . Thats very unfair and a sham in the name of journalism. I don't see any reason why you can't give a correct fair evaluation of NLIU alums.
Guesterator 24 May 2016, 17:53
+8 -4
Quite expected. This sort of analysis never contributes to any worthy new information.... the older the law school the more percentage they have - quite a straight jacket formula no?
Lol 25 May 2016, 03:58
+18 -1
By that logic GLC should've been 90%. "Oldest law college in Asia"
Can you really compare 24 May 2016, 17:53
+9 -7
How much do these numbers matter? Although I applaud your efforts, there are some issues that must be highlighted.

There are 80 students per batch in NLS, 120ish in NUJS, 240 in GLC and 400-500 (if not more) at Symbi, Pune per year. Won't Symbi Pune which, is possibly the largest law school (don't know about JGLS) have more chances than a law school which produces 1/5th the number of graduates? Would it be fair to rank law schools in this regard by such a computation?

How many of them are going to law firms? What is the composition of these law firms?
John Doe 25 May 2016, 01:30
+1 -1
Isn't the intake per batch regulated by the Bar Council of India? If the rules are the same for all law schools, not sure how this would matter.
No 25 May 2016, 06:57
+1 -0
No
BCI only stipulates 60 per class
Some NLUs have 80 per class and only 1 class per batch, some have 240,400, 1000..
John Doe 25 May 2016, 15:58
+0 -1
I understand that BCI allows 320 per batch for all law schools... Kian could you shed some light please?
Pagla 25 May 2016, 02:12
+25 -3
This logic is flawed.

If having more people in one batch Made it more likely to have people doing well, then India should have been coming 2nd in olympics consistently.
gogo 25 May 2016, 05:31
+5 -2
But that simply is a tragedy. Logic (read -probability) is still right.
olympics 26 May 2016, 05:43
+0 -0
Number of athletes representing india is lower than many other countries like us, uk, russia etc.
Guest 11 25 May 2016, 10:01
+9 -0
400-500? Visit Symbi's website for clarity of ideas.

And frankly, majority of these folks do not make it to law firms. So guess we can attribute a bit to hard work and efforts put in.
Symbi grad 27 May 2016, 06:55
+6 -0
Batch of '13 here. We had 160 students in our batch. All senior batches had less than that. Count might have risen, but 400-500 is way off.
Ummm, no... 27 May 2016, 08:57
+1 -0
Batch of 08, 09 had 320 students
Ummm.. 27 May 2016, 13:12
+0 -0
Where are you getting this exactly? Could you kindly tell me the source? Thanks! :)
Alvia 27 May 2016, 12:10
+2 -0
There are 200 students in each batch, not 400-500.
Malana creme 24 May 2016, 18:17
+21 -7
In the brief time I spent at NLIU, the seniors in the 'positive interaction session' told newly admitted kids about how they're the 3rd best law school in the country because they disagreed with the preference list of most kids(yes, they were jobless enough to ask that). Their logic was that NLIU is only second to NLS when it comes to partner designates from the NLUs. Hope this serves as a wake up call for them and ends their delusions of grandeur.

Even NLUJ, a college which they try so hard to belittle, is ahead of them now, if partner designations really matter

Kian, I hope you'll publish this. Those kids need to realise what the situation really is like.
NLIU Troll 24 May 2016, 20:08
+3 -14
Hi Kid

Kian has unfortunately forgot to mention few of our partners who were promoted this year from AMSS and KCo. which I am sure will take us back over NLUJ if not NUJS only for this current academic year.

NLUJ is not ahead of us and we are pretty happy where we are.
Malana creme 24 May 2016, 22:36
+8 -3
Actually, no. Kian seemed to have looked over one big lot of Khaitan designations. NLIU has 1 guy in that. 1.
So, even if that is taken into account, you still remain where you are in terms of the National Laws because Jodhpur also has 1 designation in that.
You just make it above Amity but I'm sure you're really glad that, that happened.

This all based on the assumption that partner designations even matter while determining a National Law and it's position.

Bhopal was one of the best but then somewhere along the line it started fucking up. Bhopal still is a good institution, relatively. You can make it great again if you guys get your shit together as opposed to roaming around with bottles of beer on the campus roads.
Prachishrivastava 26 May 2016, 06:04
+0 -0
Hi,

Thank you for your comment.

We unfortunately missed out on the Khaitan names earlier but have added those now. CAM and SAM we have had all covered right from the first version.

Best wishes,
Prachi
Aukaad 26 May 2016, 09:48
+4 -0
Boss, you seem to be a first year associate who spends most of his/her time keeping a tab over such headcounts, trying really hard to make it a point that such figures matter in the larger scheme of things.

And if you are happy where you are, I pity your clients.
KCO? 24 May 2016, 18:21
+1 -0
What about these?
http://www.legallyindia.com/law-firms/khaitan-promotes-20-to-partner-across-all-4-offices
kianganz 24 May 2016, 18:39
+0 -0
Oops... Thanks for pointing out, the story got mis-categorised and we must have missed it...

Will update the figures soon. It looks like it could give a little bump in the stats to ILS and GLC...
Auditor 26 May 2016, 06:02
+0 -0
Kian - Is it possible to put up the list of all 92 partners? You can put it as a link (in case you don't wanna mess up the article with a long list). This list seems pretty off. Only if you put up the list of all 92, we can point out the names missing.
kianganz 26 May 2016, 06:07
+0 -0
The list is there at the very bottom of the article (hidden behind a click)...
Kabira 26 May 2016, 06:34
+0 -0
Kian - based on the partnership reporting made (through the link), NALSAR has way more than 3 partners - (i) Anchal Dhir and Amita Katragada in CAM, (ii) Saanjh Purohit and Sayantan Dutta at SAM, (iii) Nanditha Gopal in AZB, (iv) Kumar Visalaksh in ELP, and (v) Mayank Singh at Khaitan.

That's a total of 7 promotions for NALSAR against 3 mentioned in your article. Will you please revise this?

Thanks
Prachishrivastava 26 May 2016, 06:05
+0 -0
Hi,

Thank you for your comment.

We have now updated the story with the names and figures from that Khaitan story, and this has given a bump to Symbiosis and GLC.

Best wishes,
Prachi
CLC 24 May 2016, 18:24
+1 -1
CLC has around 1000 students graduating every year.
CLC 24 May 2016, 18:25
+10 -1
There are more than 190 partners from my college.

Very Advocates, lexjuris, lexveritas, abracadabra, udsnchu, woilamama etc.
Alias 24 May 2016, 21:38
+1 -0
What's the sample size? No Khaitan or Indus or other firms?
Prachishrivastava 26 May 2016, 06:07
+0 -0
Hi,

Thank you for your comment.

We unfortunately missed out on a few names earlier but have now updated the story with many more partners. The sample size has increased to 92 (from the 75 in the older version). See story for detailed updates.

Best wishes,
Prachi
Missed 26 May 2016, 19:04
+2 -0
Sayantani Dutta (NUJS) of Wadia & Avik Biswas (NUJS) of Indus have been missed.
Prachishrivastava 27 May 2016, 09:02
+1 -0
Hi,

Thank you for your comment.

Sayantani's promotion was effective from before our period of consideration whereas Avik's was not an internal promotion but a lateral hire.

Best wishes,
Prachi
Logical Indian 25 May 2016, 04:41
+5 -4
What kind of a stupid analysis is this. People are made partners not because of which college they went. But because of their work and capability to bring new clients. Please use your time in doing something more productive.
kianganz 25 May 2016, 04:55
+10 -1
You've got your logic back to front: we're not saying those guys got partnership because of their college, we are just saying that people from these colleges have got partnerships, which strengthens the alumni network and shows that certain colleges have become quite established in the law firm worls, reputationally.
v 25 May 2016, 05:04
+0 -0
Having said that!!
why 25 May 2016, 05:38
+0 -0
Rachit Bahl - amity Delhi - partner - AZB
Sujoy Bhatia - Amity Delhi - partner - JSA

While you are at it, might as well cover judicial services as well as civil services.

+ not sure, if calculating partners of corp law practice, would mean good law school no ?

its implied no ?
Prachishrivastava 26 May 2016, 06:11
+1 -0
Hi,

Thank you for your comment.

Rachit Bahl was made partner way back in 2013(http://www.legallyindia.com/201306033717/Law-firms/azb-promotes-5-delhi-mumbai-2013), whereas we are only considering this financial year for this particular analysis.

Same reason for not including Sujoy (http://www.legallyindia.com/201404014555/Law-firms/jsa-promotes-9-to-salaried-partner-bulk-in-mumbai)

Best wishes,
Prachi
Noojie 25 May 2016, 05:46
+0 -0
I think there are a few more from NUJS who have made partners this year at NUJS and Argus.
Biju-da 25 May 2016, 06:39
+0 -0
Anuj Berry, SAM Delhi, NUJS
Prachishrivastava 26 May 2016, 06:26
+0 -0
Hi,

Thank you for your comment.

Anuj Berry's promotion was actually effective from the year before this financial year. Hence excluded.

Best wishes,
Prachi
Typo? 25 May 2016, 12:17
+0 -0
Partner at NUJS?
Noojie 25 May 2016, 15:09
+0 -0
Sorry for the typo.

Soumitra Majumdar, Vishrov Mukherjee and Prashanth VG were all made partners at JSA.


@Kian http://www.legallyindia.com/law-firms/15-promoted-by-jsa-to-salaried-partner-level
Prachishrivastava 26 May 2016, 06:25
+0 -1
Hi,

Thank you for your comment.

Yes now included a few we had missed out earlier, and that bumps NUJS to rank 2.

Best wishes,
Prachi
NLUJ 25 May 2016, 08:03
+0 -0
Radhika Gaggar CAM
Prachishrivastava 26 May 2016, 06:29
+0 -0
Hi,

Thank you for your comment.

Radhika Gaggar's promotion was actually effective from the year before this financial year. Hence excluded. (http://www.legallyindia.com/Law-firms/cyril-amarchand-finalises-7-new-equity-partners-12-salaried-for-future-home-turf-partnership-as-shardul-still-freezing-list)

Best wishes,
Prachi
NLUJ-2 25 May 2016, 08:07
+0 -0
Abhinav Surana Juris Corp.
Prachishrivastava 26 May 2016, 06:31
+0 -0
Hi,

Thank you for your comment.

Abhinav Surana was a lateral hire actually, whereas this analysis extends to only internally promoted partners. (http://www.legallyindia.com/law-firms/juris-corp-reviving-fortunes-opens-in-bangalore-with-ex-fox-partner-debanjan-bannerjee-and-trilegal-hire-pal)

Best wishes,
Prachi
Alma 25 May 2016, 08:49
+5 -1
i dont understand that why people are fighting over petty issues and giving arguments to prove that my college is better than yours....grow up....how does it matter if your college is good or not.....after graduating from a college the only thing that matter is your own ability and capability....so if u think that your college and faculty is best then fine go and attend the lectures, ask questions, get your concepts right and if faculty is not good than put some extra effort your own and read case laws and build concepts and contribute something in the field.
Any government law col 25 May 2016, 08:50
+4 -0
Well, it doesnt look like i will make partner in any of the big firms.. but considering the number of alumni from my college who have become politicians... the future looks very rosy... :P
Ayyayyo!! 25 May 2016, 09:25
+0 -0
SAM made 2 partners from NALSAR last year

Sayantan Dutta and Saanjh Purohit Both in Delhi office.
Kabira 25 May 2016, 12:15
+0 -0
+ Mayank Singh (Khaitan), Nanditha Gopal (AZB) and Kumar Visalaksh (ELP) - all from NALSAR. Diwakar Maheshwari was elevated to equity partnership in Kahitan also.
Prachishrivastava 26 May 2016, 06:32
+0 -0
Hi,

Thank you for your comment.

Both those partners were made in the previous financial year whereas we were only considering the current financial year for this story.

Best wishes,
Prachi
Kabira 27 May 2016, 09:18
+0 -0
That's weird. I know for sure, fiscal 2016 was the first year of partnership for all of these guys. Firms may announce partnership promotions in February/ March/ April or June, but mostly they are all with effect from April 1. So if this is a round of promotions for fiscal 2016, they should all have been counted as new partners for fiscal 2016. Counting them based on the dates of reporting (some through confirmations and some through 'strong sources') is not the right thing to do.

Anyway, your method of calculation seems skewed and that's telling me not to bother about this story anymore. Not a great work, I must say.
Prachishrivastava 27 May 2016, 09:07
+0 -0
Hi,

Thank you for your comment.

Those promotions were effective from before our period of consideration hence excluded.

Best wishes,
Prachi
Scott 25 May 2016, 12:06
+0 -0
Not sure how true this is. From NALSAR, the following lawyers were made partners in the last year:

1. Saanjh Purohit in SAM
2. Sayantan Dutta in SAM
3. Nanditha Gopal in AZB
4. Mayank Singh in Khaitan
5. Kumar Visalaksh in ELP

That's 5 compared to the number (3) given in this list. Also the period of survey may be a bit weird. Most of the firms make the partnership w.e.f. April 1. Is that why the number is different?
Prachishrivastava 26 May 2016, 06:44
+0 -0
Hi,

Thank you for your comment.

Information on the alma maters of some of these partners was not available earlier, hence they have not been included to the tally, but we've mentioned their names in the full list of partners. We will update the tally soon.

Best wishes,
Prachi
crap 26 May 2016, 16:40
+2 -0
do a study on which law school produces most judges!
Old School 26 May 2016, 18:55
+2 -0
Given how omnipresent the national law schools have become in recent years (indeed, there now appears to be one in every state), and the placement and cachet they have managed, law schools in universities like Delhi, would stand to disadvantage. In that most able or serious candidates would go to these new law schools.

Situation could be reversed if these older law schools within universities (like CLC, GLC), get their act together. But that is a remote possibility -- neither is there a will nor an inclination.
Great! 26 May 2016, 19:40
+3 -3
i'll be joining SLS most probably and this feels great to know!
SLS Senior 30 May 2016, 05:25
+3 -3
Welcome to your biggest mistake
khv 30 May 2016, 11:41
+1 -0
why whats up with sls pune dude?
The wise one 30 May 2016, 12:15
+2 -0
No need to worry in terms of the intellect and drive of your peers. The most serious concern is the administration. the director is very authoritative.Refuses to engage in any discourse that isnt along her line of thought. This is not to say that there isnt good faculty and admin officers. But just take a look at the countless number of qualified and capable faculty that have left on account of disagreements with the director. Ive heard wonderful things about the director of sls,noida though
dudeson 30 May 2016, 11:47
+0 -0
why bro why what



happened to sls pune?
green lantern 27 May 2016, 06:02
+1 -0
what fantastic and time-taking analysis. anything counter-intuitive (with pies!) and relevant is a great read.
i know legal news websites that would charge for this business intelligence.
Update 27 May 2016, 09:30
+0 -0
It seems that there are several more additions even after the corrections. I request you to kindly update the list again.
Alias 30 May 2016, 04:35
+0 -0
Why not do a study of batches 2004-2006 from top law schools who are partners in various national level law firms irrespective of whether they are promoted internally or laterally acquired?
Kalia Tanuj 30 May 2016, 15:29
+3 -1
The great thing about NUJS is that it's a student lead college.

The biggest conference, the biggest moot, national level fests and the entire rigmarole of placements is managed by the students. Multiple committees and societies, some of which do excellent work, are lead entirely by students.

And this is a no mean feat.

In college, I conducted a tiny conference which was attended by 15 participants, and trust me, the whole process is as worthwhile as a mini MBA.

I think it's this quality which makes NUJS graduates go-getters; ones not just have a sound grounding in law but also an 'in the trenches' knowledge of leadership, management and getting things done.

No wonder that NUJS leads in law firm partnership promotions 2015-16.
NLS managing partner 30 May 2016, 17:53
+0 -0
Kian, what's the break up of law firms where the managing or senior partners are from the national law schools. NLS will surely rule in this category - Indus, Trilegal etc. Can hardly think of any law firm where the managing or senior partners are from any of the other national law schools.
Sage 1 Jun 2016, 05:30
+0 -0
W/o taking anything away from the excellence of NLSIU, that's partly because the institution has had such a head start over the others in terms of time. If you consider, say, NUJS, the first batch graduated in 2005. Ten years are hardly enough for anyone to become senior partners in a top tier firm. Unless you count starting your own firm, in which case other NLU-grads have done thus.
Mike Ross 31 May 2016, 06:44
+0 -0
@Kian Its not R A Shah Law College. the correct name is Sir L A Shah Law College