Analysis

Nalsargate exclusive: The inside story of a secret report and the quest for excellence

Report on Nalsar
Report on Nalsar
Until last Wednesday, an explosive 161-page document prepared by four judges was gathering dust in the office of Nalsar Hyderabad vice chancellor (VC) Veer Singh for nearly four months. Few, if any, had read it and most faculty and students claimed they were unaware even of its existence or any details.

The story of that report is Nalsar’s alone. But this is also a story of academic power struggles, law school management and students caught in between, that will have near-universal parallels in many Indian law schools.

The legal brains behind the Vodafone tax case: Salve, R Nariman, Dutt Menon Dunmorrsett & many more

In Mint today: BCI is not an effective regulator
In Mint today: BCI is not an effective regulator
[The Vodafone tax case will not just be remembered for being one of the biggest in Indian history, but also for cementing the reputations of a raft of lawyers at the top of their game and others who are rapidly getting there.

Click here to read about how lawyers like Harish Salve, Rohinton Nariman, Dutt Menon Dunmorrsett (DMD) and others fought the case, exclusively in today’s Mint.](http://www.livemint.com/2012/02/02222413/How-India8217s-biggest-tax.html)

LI-Mint: US job market remains in dumps; 92% of Indian LLM grads come home empty handed?

Exclusive: A few years ago, Indian lawyers who took a top LLM in the US were inundated with job offers from prestigious US and international law firms. Many accepted. But in 2011 only five out of 60 students got such a ticket. Have $70,000 US LLMs just become a way for colleges to cash in on Indian students? Find out why the Brazilians seem to fare better than the Indians.

Mint: The NLS experiment has not failed but what about the rest?

Madhava Menon’s national law school experiment of 1986 may have failed to pull hundreds of Indian law schools out of mediocrity but it has brought newfound respect to legal education, reports Mint today. Critics complain that the national law schools have mostly benefited corporate law but this may not be their fault. While no NLS grads have so far made it to senior counsel rank, some are making their mark in litigation.

LI-Mint investigation: Stack of cards - How Fox Mandal & Little’s merger unravelled

Exclusive in today’s Mint: Revealing two years of research, over 20 interviews with current and former lawyers, and never-read-before insider details and accounts, read the most definitive and balanced account published so far of Fox Mandal Delhi’s financial woes and how the merger between Fox and Little & Co Mumbai unravelled.

How Indian lawyers get by on only $1.4m of GDP; Mint & LI demystify Indian legal market

Mint: A page for the legal profession every second Friday
Mint: A page for the legal profession every second Friday
Mint - easily India’s best quality business daily - will now feature cutting-edge legal industry news and analysis in its pages every second Friday under an exclusive new content partnership with Legally India.

In today’s Mint edition, Legally India editor Kian Ganz’s colum demystifies India’s legal market: Despite India’s fairly average legal population density every lawyer here has to make do with only $1.4m of GDP. This, it turns out, is the lowest figure in both developed and developing legal markets. Click here to read the column on this, pseudo lawyers and more.

Please comment below or on Mint with suggestions for future topics or stories worth covering.

Also in today’s Mint: all-new research on salary progression at law firms, as well as how and why law firm salaries have risen so much in the last five years.

Exclusive: Law firms pay Rs 8-30 lakh after 6 years, less in Delhi; Starting salaries doubled since 2006

image
image

Law firms pay lawyers with six years of experience up to around Rs 30 lakh per annum in Mumbai, revealed analysis of data collected in Legally India’s associate survey, as first published in Mint today.

Legally India now blogs on The Lawyer; Introduction: The forbidden land of ‘approximately’ 1.2 million lawyers

image
image
Legally India editor Kian Ganz will now blog regularly in The Lawyer magazine’s new blogs section about the Indian legal landscape. Here is the first post.

By far the personal question that I get asked the most by lawyers in India and abroad is: “Why India?” You might want to ask A&O, CC, Links or Freshfields or the rest of the pack the same question.

How to begin doing good in a law firm: 11 Indian firms ponder ‘long overdue’ pro bono start with new UK tech NGO

The head of the Delhi roundtable
The head of the Delhi roundtable
Eleven law firms, including six of India’s largest, Ashoka and the UK’s former attorney general Lord Peter Goldsmith QC have discussed how to develop a pro bono culture in Indian law firms as i-Probono, a UK not-for-profit and online portal seeking to connect lawyers to social sector projects, will launch in India to encourage law firms to do that which is “long overdue”.

Exclusive: BCI Chennai writ affidavit swears it has power to but won’t relax foreign firm restrictions; Next hearing pushed

dead-end-sign_by_Andrew-Mason
dead-end-sign_by_Andrew-Mason
The Bar Council of India’s (BCI) counter-affidavit filed in the AK Balaji Chennai case against 31 foreign law firms said that the BCI has decided not to relax the restrictions prohibiting foreign lawyers from practising and that the issue raised by the writ was “no longer res integra” because it had been settled in the 2009 Lawyers Collective case.

Legally India understands that the BCI’s thinking is that internal disparities at the Indian bar need to be eradicated through reform before making any decision on foreign firms.

How to become a social lawyer (and why not)

image
image
What drives successful lawyers and graduates to forge a career path in civil society despite myriad challenges and the financial hit? And why are there not more of them? We ask them to find out.

Exclusive: Only 6 women became senior counsel in two decades but odds slim for all

image
image
In the last two decades the Delhi and Mumbai High Courts appointed only three female senior counsel each out of a total of 122 and 81 new senior advocate designations awarded by the courts reveals Legally India’s exclusive year-on-year analysis of senior counsel elevations in the country’s top two high courts.

But the senior prospects at the bar are actually bleak for both sexes.

Exclusive: Satyam’s settled US class action had no hope in India?

image
image
Expert academic witnesses Vikramaditya Khanna and Sandeep Parekh locked horns with law firm JSA-instructed and ex-CJI Ahmadi’s testimony in the lead-up to yesterday’s $125m settlement before a New York court, US dockets reveal.

Indo-US research paper: Judicial delays mean 70% of Indian prisoners yet to get hearings; Reform, research and pro bono vital

image
image
The Indian criminal justice system is near to breaking point as 300,000 people or 70 per cent of India’s prison population consists of those awaiting trial facing a morass of judicial delays, according to a research paper discussing the current state of the Indian criminal justice delivery system.

Radia Tapes: Bhushan condemns cosy relationship between media and elite; Time to introspect?

image
image
Exclusive: Activist lawyer Prashanth Bhushan has condemned media ownership and its consequences after secret wiretap tapes that were released as part of the 2G scam case, which contained alleged conversations between well-known publicist Nira Radia and India’s rich, powerful and the Fourth Estate.

Exclusive: State bar councils take over, want regional bar exams: Legal reform’s swansong?

image
image
State bar councils are planning to hold regional bar exams for each state, as the holding of the all India bar exam has turned into a political circus between the Bar Council of India (BCI), its chairman and the state bar councils. Meanwhile, the BCI will meet in Chennai this weekend (20 November), probably without BCI chairman Gopal Subramanium.

A fine mess: Bar exam cases still in limbo as 4 of 6 respondents inactive in apex court

examination-hall_by_comedy-nose
examination-hall_by_comedy-nose
Exclusive: The Supreme Court may have set the stage for the next round of proceedings in the All India Bar Exam challenges after completing the summoning process but certainty has continued to elude thousands of law graduates, as only two out of six anti-exam petitioners are still in active pursuit of the case while the other four have become absentee litigants for most intents and purposes.

11 days of Ayodhya verdict sabre rattling; Hindu party approaches SC to prevent ex-parte order

Hindu political organisation Akhil Bharat Hindu Mahasabha has filed a caveat in the Supreme Court to prevent any party to the dispute from seeking an ex-parte order in appealing against the Allahabad High Court’s 30 September decision on the Ayodhya title dispute matter.

Foreign law firms into India: voices in favour, against and why nothing changes

curvy-road-sign-by-bob
curvy-road-sign-by-bob

Who are the players in the saga around legal market liberalisation? And do those in favour actually care enough to make a difference? Legally India talks to the opposing factions and finds out why no progress has been made - and if any is around the corner.

Amarchand Mangaldas: past, present, future

Amarchand_mumbai_office
Amarchand_mumbai_office
Amarchand-Delhi-office-high
Amarchand-Delhi-office-high
Amarchand & Mangaldas, India’s biggest law firm, has all the trappings of a family-run enterprise including sibling rivalry. The Shroff brothers must quickly set their house in order, argues Forbes India magazine’s Shloka Nath.