Analysis

The fine print in the beef ban judgement

rnziklro
rnziklro
The Bombay high court has upheld the constitutional validity of Maharashtra’s prohibition of the slaughter of cows, bulls and bullocks, the trade of the animals outside the state for slaughter, and their sale or purchase for slaughter.

Questions answered: AIPMT & NEET 2016 and whether the Supreme Court will fix things today?

A last-moment PIL and orders passed by the Supreme Court of India has created a fair bit of confusion, not to mention feelings of unfairness amongst students sitting for the pre-medical exam.

Chandigarh skirt ‘ban’ explained: The story of how the City Beautiful ended up looking so ugly despite best intentions that ‘rights will never be infringed’

Skirting no rules
Skirting no rules
How did the City Beautiful end up looking so bad, despite best intentions that “rights will never be infringed”?

The rapid rehabilitation of powerful men: Of RK Pachauri, AK Ganguly, Swatanter Kumar, Tarun Tejpal and the length of memories…

z1dxoqsy
z1dxoqsy
Pachauri’s gradual rehabilitation is not a new narrative: in fact, the rehabilitation of powerful men, whether in the eyes of the mainstream media, politics or the common man and woman, is par for the course, albeit a massively nuanced matter.

Of Katju, Modi and the NJAC: Politicians’ perfect plan (and a collegiate waste of time)

The National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) was either an example of a perfect campaign by politicians or of massive good luck, argued Kian Ganz in the Mumbai Mirror on Sunday.

20% of you still use Windows XP: Why clients should fear you. Is Linux an option for lawyering?

Blue screen of death
Blue screen of death
According to Legally India’s monthly visitor stats, 19 per cent of readers are still on Windows XP, and they (and their clients) could very well get into serious trouble 10 days from today.

Untangling the Madras HC turmoil: A bar at war, a question of caste, or business as usual?

fp2igb13[20]
fp2igb13[20]
The Supreme Court (SC) on Monday transferred to itself a week-old Madras high court (HC) petition challenging 12 names that were recommended for judgeship at the same HC, after the apex court ordered that judicial review of the list was not permitted and that the HC lacked the “conducive atmosphere” to hear such a petition.

The world according to KIAA: India’s youngest & most commented LLP start-up survives first year

KIAA
KIAA
Knowledge Information Acess Associates (KIAA): Recipe of start-up survival, or too young to succeed?

LI Salary Survey results (pt 2): How much do & will your law firm batchmates make?

Salaries of lawyers - Mint
Salaries of lawyers - Mint

Exclusive: The second part of Legally India’s salary survey analysis is out in print in Mint today, and coupled with personal interviews and additional research, revealed huge discrepancies between salaries even within the same firm at the more senior levels. Click through to read the analysis.

A short history of Indian freedom of speech laws: who should we blame?

LI and Mint, together every fortnight
LI and Mint, together every fortnight
Today’s Legally India page in Mint: The typical citizen could be forgiven for fearing that the world’s largest democracy is hurtling towards George Orwell’s 1984 rather than 2013.

Do you have to pay? Lawyers try to come to terms with service tax saga

LI and Mint, together every fortnight
LI and Mint, together every fortnight
In today’s edition of Mint: The finance ministry’s latest concession on service tax imposed on lawyers that was notified in June has been welcomed by some; others continue to say it wasn’t enough and many remained unaware of the current law and how, or if at all, they had to pay this tax.

The story of the Amarchand-CLB order and why being a lawyer is (perhaps) the world’s fourth-most stressful job

It's not easy being a lawyer
It's not easy being a lawyer
Exclusive: Just behind being a brain surgeon, an air traffic controller, and flying remote control UAVs over civilians in Afghanistan from Nevada, being a lawyer can be one of the most stressful of jobs in the world.

Asking clients: Can small legal start-ups compete with the big boys? And do you have to risk your neck?

David LLP v Goliath & Partners?
David LLP v Goliath & Partners?
In today’s edition of Mint: “Today our biggest problem is not foreign firms, it is people working at one-tenth the price that we work at,” said Cyril Shroff, the Mumbai managing partner of Amarchand & Mangaldas & Suresh A. Shroff & Co., in an interview in early 2012. “You are constantly being pulled down in price.”

Ragging: Cured at law school or a more insidious modern-day menace?

Bullies
Bullies
“If you don’t touch his balls, and it gets out that you didn’t listen to a fifth year, no senior will ever help you do research or anything. In fact, I think we might have a word with the student disciplinary committee. You know what they can make you do, right?”

From the frontlines: Of law school pay packages, the economy and campus recruitment wars

LI and Mint, together every fortnight
LI and Mint, together every fortnight
In today’s edition of Mint: Law firms enjoy unequal bargaining power in a market where the talent pool is deepening every year.

The sobering state of the economy has got India’s law students worried. For many, particularly at the top few schools, getting a high-paying job was the primary aim of their legal education. The higher pay packets also justified the pursuit of an interest in the law, especially when it came to convincing parents who would otherwise prefer their children aspire for admission to an Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) or Indian Institute of Management (IIM).

All-boys clubs and short skirt stereotypes hurt women’s legal careers: SOWL panel

peggy mad men
peggy mad men
Workplaces are structured to lose the women along the career ladder and colleagues’ and bosses’ attitudes do usually not alleviate the loss, was a hot topic of discussion in a room of 80 women at the Society of Women Lawyers’ (SOWL) annual conference in Delhi on Saturday.

LI-Mint in-depth: The Supreme Court’s battle against the backlog - a losing proposition, or out of ideas?

image
image
When Chief Justice of India S.H. Kapadia started his term in May 2010 it was widely reported that he didn’t take the traditional May-June court vacation but worked through it, aiming to look at ways of reducing the time it takes to hear cases and making the Supreme Court administration more efficient.

LI lawyers’ survey, part 1: 15% corp lawyers want to stay 3 years, half want own law firm; Advocates most happy; 75% want foreign firms within 2 years

I can get some satisfaction (graphics by Sandeep Bhatnagar/Mint)
I can get some satisfaction (graphics by Sandeep Bhatnagar/Mint)
”) In today’s edition of Mint: Indian lawyers have it pretty good when compared with the average citizen, of whom only 8% are positive about their jobs—as a Gallup survey revealed last week. Nevertheless, the corporate law profession faces a crisis of confidence.

Malpractice insurance catches on despite near-zero risk: Indian law firms get up to $50m cover

LI and Mint, together every fortnight
LI and Mint, together every fortnight
In today’s edition of Mint: Legally India reveals the conundrum of how legal liability insurance has managed to catch on among India’s bigger law firms, despite no one being able to remember any lawyer ever getting sued for negligent advice.

Chennai writ losers: LPOs, CAs, secondments & logic. Winners: Invisible in-house & pragmatism

1960s Advocates Act: Kaputt?
1960s Advocates Act: Kaputt?
The ruling in the Chennai writ petition was hailed as pragmatic for solving the nearly two-year-old deadlock foreign firms were in. But frankly it is likely to continue exposing the deficiencies of the 1961 Advocates Act in dealing with modern-day India. And it could possibly plunge a number of industries into a world of pain via the Bar Council of India (BCI).