Someday I hope to see this on the front page:

The government of India has finally taken notice. The Home Ministry will soon table a Bill that is bound to create controversy. Many observers believe that this Bill assumes that India is a racist country.   Shishi Rudra, an eminent sociologist, says
The government of India has finally taken notice. The Home Ministry will soon table a Bill that is bound to create controversy. Many observers believe that this Bill assumes that India is a racist country. Shishi Rudra, an eminent sociologist, says

Last summer, I went to Delhi to work with a law firm. In order to save money, I stayed with an old friend of my father who had just come back after spending thirty years in London.

When I arrived, I didn’t see an Indian really. He was a fair man with a British Accent sometimes twinning with his Irish accent, fairly inherited by his marriage of twenty years to an Irish woman. After surviving for nearly ten years with little company in the one of the costliest cities in the world, he decided to return home. It took us a few days to break the ice and before we knew it, we were getting along fabulously. We would spend hours talking about his life in London and how he went there.. I guess it was liberating for him to speak to someone about a life he once had.

Of all our conversations, I will always cherish one the most. When I told him about how I thought my skin colour affected my self-image, he told me the most beautiful thing – without this tone of your skin, you’d never be half the man you are right now. You are who you are because of your skin colour.

I had never thought of it like that. I had accepted the fact that we Indians loved white skin. We wanted to date fair girls and liked helping white people. I got through school hanging out with a group of boys who were far too nerdy to make friends based on colour. However, the reason I became their friend was because I didn’t understand how we were so shallow. Only the fair boys and girls dated, and the darker kids were participants in a play they had no role.

No matter where I went, racism was systematic and imbibed. I seldom see Indian companies celebrating our dark skin. The only time we even possibly see a dark person on television is when it’s a fairness cream advertisement. And we keep quiet.

Law firms in India clearly lack a non-discrimination policy. Having worked at some of the top law firms across the country, they all seem to lack a diversity policy. No wonder I don’t see many north-east Indians around. Are they really not smart enough to get into these law firms or is the reason something that goes into the Indian Psyche?

There was a movie that Salman Khan acted in some time ago. A cheap copy of Bruce Almighty. In the movie, Salman’s sister doesn’t get any marriage proposals because she is dark. However, when he gets the same powers as God, he makes her fair. Proposals start pouring in from every place on earth. I was disturbed because I knew how this would affect the young minds who would watch this.

Everyday we’re bring conditioned to white skin. And I don’t know how or when we’re going to change. Racism is so imbibed in me that it takes me a moment to judge people of different skin colours objectively. I’m still waiting for a day when we start seeing the pattern in which racism in India functions. Maybe then we’ll have our Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka.

See John2010’s other blogs:

8 disturbing signs that our elected representatives have forgotten us.

My Facebook Feed

How comrade whistle blower lost his ethical virginity

The PM on legal education: What he said and did not say.

Dear Prudence: … Litigation is really interesting but …?

The 26/11 Judgement fails the maturity test and how we can still salvage justice.

Confessions of a chronic cheater…

How not to be inspired.

When things go wrong…

Comments

Anonymous guest 22 Jun 2010, 19:25
+0 -0
I would request you to be very careful when using the word racist or racism. I have been out of India for a few years and now i undersdtand that this word has a very different meaning and context here than what we indians belive it to mean. Call us by any name you like, regionalist etc but please understand that the word racist used by Indians for themselves will be understood in a very different light by a western reader.
Racism has a bloody and sad history in the western world and it just does not fit in with the perceived tastes of some Indians to prefer fair skin for dating/ marriage etc.

yes we are regionalists (but less than many advanced cultures!) and are casteists (but far more tolerant than, you will be surprised by many other so called liberal cultures).

Lets try and have some self respect for ourselves and with a clear conscious aim to better our society rather than simply talking negative about it.
napster 22 Jun 2010, 19:34
+0 -0
Brilliant post. Well written. You have inspired me to write a post now. :)

Discrimination on the basis of skin color is rampant. Something which needs to be taken care of.
john2010 22 Jun 2010, 19:49
+1 -0
Self-respect comes from within. This is how Indian society has formed me. I have lived all my life in India and this is how I feel about my society. My observations are based on my life experiences and how I have come to perceive them. As far as racism abroad is concerned, the reason why we are able to see it better abroad is because there is a lot more discussion and debate on the topic. Allowing that to happen in India will probably allow us to see a clearer pattern of racism whose form might be very different!
john2010 22 Jun 2010, 19:50
+0 -0
I'm glad you were able to connect with this. It'd be great to see more debate on this topic. I look forward to reading your take on the topic.
Anonymous guest 22 Jun 2010, 23:53
+0 -0
John , I understand that your views are based on what you have seen growing up. i did not expect anything else either. My point was to understand the word racism, the way it is understood globally. All Indians (and most Pakistanis and Bangladeshis/ Sri lankans) are South Asians by race. The variations in skin tone is intra-racial aspect. It is akin to North Chinese saying that they have sharper features and pinkish skin than south chinese.

As an aside this remonds me of a programme on NDTV where Barkha Dutt kept screaming (for more than an Hour!) how Indians are closet racist. My Western friend watching this programme just could not make out what the relationship is between use of Fair and Lovely creams in india and Indians becoming racist!
john2010 23 Jun 2010, 00:11
+0 -0
I'm not sure if the West would be able to understand the racism we're facing in India today. They have been through a different form of racism; much easier to identify. Indian society is much more complicated than that.

Racism can be based on any human trait, even skin colour ( "racial discrimination" shall mean any distinction, exclusion, restriction or preference based on race, colour, descent, or national or ethnic origin - http://www2.ohchr.org/english/law/cerd.htm )
Anonymous guest 23 Jun 2010, 00:49
+0 -0
I am north Indian and even though I was top of my class... I ciud not make it to a 1st tier firm. Still do not know why!!!
Anonymous guest 23 Jun 2010, 00:55
+0 -0
Good work John. You surely represent the true Indian willing to debate till the end and not listening to the other perspective. Now each time you use the word racist, please footnote it with the fancy definition given by the UN! I thought your post was more on fair vs. darker skin tones and what is probably considered as a scale of beauty by some Indians. BTW what is beautiful is a personal choice and you cannot claim that someone is racist because he thinks black is beauthiful or not..
sss 23 Jun 2010, 03:18
+0 -0
John,
With due respect to the great writing, I think you have missed the fine line between being stereotyped and being racist. In India, stereotypical images are more prevalent. For instance, a south Indian studying in the north is automatically presumed to not know Hindi and is thus, ostracised from the majority. I think this is what the situation is and this is what should be looked into more seriously.
Fresher NALSARite 23 Jun 2010, 04:45
+0 -0
very well written........
Anonymous guest 23 Jun 2010, 18:21
+0 -0
You argue that there is racism in India against people of dark colour. You also say there are not too many north Indians in law firms. If people of fairer skin were favoured, wouldnt the Aryans have a better shot at everything than the Dravidians do? SO i see a contradiction
john2010 23 Jun 2010, 20:42
+0 -0
While I respect your opinion, the truth remains that we do not hold dark skin in high regard. If we see fairness being a pre-condition to beauty, that to me is racism. I think it'd fair if you could elucidate further. I cited the UN definition only because (i) it is internationally accepted and (ii) racism includes being discriminated on the basis of skin colour.
Anonymous guest 23 Jun 2010, 20:44
+0 -0
@8 When personal choice becomes a choice of the majority, then they become a class of people consisting of a considerable number of citizens. It becomes a choice of the masses, and that is what has happened in India, especially northern and eastern India. Discrimination on the basis of colour is rampant to the extent that it has pervaded the minds of generations who passed it on to their next.You may choose to ignore that we do view the fair ones favorably, somewhat more aesthetically pleasing or for whatever reason.
john2010 23 Jun 2010, 20:48
+0 -0
SSS,
Thanks for the encouragement. I'm trying to look into skin colour irrespective of region. So while I'm from the North, I'm dark skinned. Similarly, there are people from, say Mangalore, who are very fair. I agree this is stereotyped but isn't it racist too? We have a duty to erase these stereotypes and hopefully the future generations will see our own people objectively.
Anonymous guest 23 Jun 2010, 20:48
+0 -0
john u havent answered 11 yet
Anonymous guest 23 Jun 2010, 20:59
+0 -0
Dont you think John Abraham is being a hypocrite by advertising a fairness cream and dating Bipasha Basu simultaneously?
john2010 23 Jun 2010, 21:01
+0 -0
Hey,

Thanks for pointing out an error. I meant to state North-East Indians. You're looking at my arguments from a narrow perspective. In fact, I would agree that if there was an Aryan and Dravidian, equally well-educated and talented, the Aryan would be picked. Its a general opinion but it holds good.

Anyway, here is an article that talk about racism in India: http://www.outlookindia.com/article.aspx?250317
john2010 23 Jun 2010, 21:10
+0 -0
First of all, I think anyone would be crazy to not consider dating her. My mother was once telling someone about the daughter of a family friend. For a majority of the period when they were talking about her, they agreed that even though she was dark, her personality made up for it. Dark people can't be dark and just beautiful. You have to have a lot more than that in terms of personality or fame. And BB has all of that. Think about it.
Anonymous guest 23 Jun 2010, 22:00
+0 -0
John, why does your pic avataar have a white painted face?

Just want to understand what the thinking there is...
Anonymous guest 23 Jun 2010, 22:20
+0 -0
@19 all mime actors in acts/plays have traditionally used the while mask or a layer of white paint in contrast with the tight black body suit which they wear. This has got nothing do with racism!!!
john2010 23 Jun 2010, 22:31
+0 -0
Thank you 20 =)
Anonymous guest 24 Jun 2010, 04:35
+0 -0
you are talking about the fair/dark divide..which i admit is racist...but imagine what north east indians go through..they are not even considered indian..most other indians would easily mistake them for chinese..most indians cannot even name all the states in that region...
and the racism is even more stark there..i have a few friends from that region and walking down the street is harder for them than for other girls..they fear being harassed because of the way they look
i read a book by chetan bhagat called two states (horrible writing,would not recommend it)..and it was strangely true about how many north indians would be suprised at the mere existence of a "gori madrasin"...
the most racist thing in india is the caste system..

i remember a lecturer once asking us..
"have you ever seen a muslim or a christian in your every day tv serial"..no.."what about a lower caste?"..no.."at least one or two dark skinned or north eastern people?"..no....i have never looked at tv serials the same way again
john2010 24 Jun 2010, 17:35
+0 -0
You're right. This is exactly why I've put in a paragraph - "Law firms in India clearly lack a non-discrimination policy. Having worked at some of the top law firms across the country, they all seem to lack a diversity policy. No wonder I don’t see many north-east Indians around. Are they really not smart enough to get into these law firms or is the reason something that goes into the Indian Psyche?"
john2010 24 Jun 2010, 17:41
+0 -0
Also, while the caste system remains, caste no longer (in ever case) determines your colour. There are SCs and STs from the south who are really fair and similarly people from the north belonging to the "upper castes" who are dark.
Anonymous guest 24 Jun 2010, 19:12
+0 -0
i agree with you...

i said caste-ism is like racism not because it has anything to do with skin color...more because the kind of discrimination that african americans and lower castes went through and are going through is similar..and that is scary
john2010 24 Jun 2010, 19:30
+0 -0
And the worst thing is we still can't seem to see the pattern. That just makes it worse.
Anonymous guest 25 Jun 2010, 02:21
+0 -0
you know i think that if we just had the courage to face up to it..we could easily see what is really happening...but we lack the courage to see what we do for what it is..we are a hypocritical society.a cowardly one.

mind it i said "we"
john2010 25 Jun 2010, 03:06
+0 -0
I agree with you. We're people who don't stand up for our rights.
Anonymous guest 1 Jul 2010, 22:51
+0 -0
Ever heard of Punjabi Aryans talking about the "Dark" Darvidian South Indians? Or someone talking about "Chinky" Indians of the North East?

That's pure racism Sir/Madam. The brand of racism here is different from what we see in the west, but it is racism nonetheless!!
john2010 11 Jul 2010, 13:49
+0 -0
@1: no rebuttal to 29?