Archived forum thread. This discussion is preserved for posterity from the Legally India Topical forum and is no longer active.

Can an Advocate Invest Money and Buy Shares in Pvt. Companies?

kmalhotra 1 Jun 2013, 10:13

Dear all,

I am an Advocate enrolled at Bar Council of Delhi for last 5 years. I understand that the Bar Council Rules places restrictions on Advocates to engage in business activities.

My question relates to purchasing shares of companies. The questions are that as an Advocate can I:-

1. Purchase shares of a publicly company listed on Bombay Stock Exchange?

2. Purchase shares of a Private Ltd. company in which I am neither a DIRECTOR nor have any dealings with the management of the company?

Attention is drawn to the following restrictions of the Bar Council including Chapter II rules 47 and 48, which says-

Chapter II

47. An advocate shall not personally engage in any business; but he may be a sleeping partner in a firm doing business provided that in the opinion of the appropriate State Bar Council, the nature of the business is not inconsistent with the dignity of the profession.

48. An advocate may be Director or Chairman of the Board of Directors of a Company with or without any ordinarily sitting fee, provided none of his duties are of an executive character. An advocate shall not be a Managing Director or a Secretary of any Company.

My question is simple. As an Advocate, can I invest money and purchase share of a Pvt. company limited by shares in light of the restrictions imposed on the Bar Council to practicing Advocates?

“47. An advocate shall not personally engage in any business”

Of course, in most of the cases, the shares of a Pvt company limited by shares are purchased in return of investment into the company. My question is whether such an activity is in contravention of said rule 47?

Thanks in advance.

Kshitij Malhotra

6 Replies

AnonymousLLB 1 Jun 2013, 21:52

Read your post again (carefully). You’ll get the answer.

AnonymousLLB 21 Jun 2013, 18:41

Yes you can hold the shares of a Private Company limited by shares and any company as a matter of fact. The restriction imposed on Advocates conducting business is intended for ‘proprietorship’ and other businesses where you may be in-charge of its operations.

AnonymousLLB 6 Sept 2014, 15:24

aren’t the shareholders in a private limited company owners of the company, if no, who is??

AnonymousLLB 10 Oct 2014, 21:15

shareholders are owners of the share capital of the Company

AnonymousLLB 29 Sept 2015, 21:27

True. Shareholders are part owners. But, lawyers are allowed to invest in companies they represent. Investing in an company that competes with your clients is called a conflict. You could be sued for it.

No harm in investing in your clients/ clients company though.

Guest 23 Nov 2015, 20:37

Hi,

There is no restriction to Invest in a company. It is to be noted that NO restrictions are placed by company law for being members of the company. Hence the Advocates Act cannot be in contradiction to any other Act / Law.

The restriction on advocate is not to engage in a business or another professional activity. Eg. A Practicing member of ICAI (Chartered accountant) cannot enroll as an advocate in parallel.

Hope you are able to now distinguish the restrictions placed.

Balaji srini FCA., LL.B