Bar Council of India (BCI) chairman Manan Kumar Mishra in an interview with ThePrint has elaborated on his latest campaign to fight for ‘men’s rights’.
Mishra told ThePrint:
Some Supreme Court judgments have said that the statement of the prosecutrix in rape cases is enough and does not require further corroboration…That is against the spirit of justice, and needs to relooked.
As a result, some women take undue advantage of the law and falsely implicate men, who then do not have any (legal) protection.
All we are saying is that the Evidence Act should be followed in letter and spirit, and charges even in rape and other such cases should be backed with evidence and not just statements,” Mishra told ThePrint.
Even in 498A, we had found there was misuse…50 per cent of the cases filed are false. In that, the Supreme Court has realised that it is dangerous (to have such laws).
He also helpfully clarified his position, adding: “We are not saying that rape is a good thing. Nobody would ever say that, but there ought to be proper safeguards for everyone.”
Earlier this week, Mishra had called for a “men too” march, apparently in support of Chief Justice of India (CJI) Ranjan Gogoi, saying: “We are not in 18th century, that no one can presume that a female will never make such allegations to falsely implicate her enemies. We have great respect for our women. But time has changed, we must keep it mind.”
While there are no doubt false complaints filed against men (as they are against anyone), the reality is that most rape cases are never even reported and that the “spirit of justice” is already stacked against most legitimate complaints, as we had outlined in our article earlier this week.
threads most popular
thread most upvoted
comment newest
first oldest
first
Second, "We are not in 18th century, that no one can presume that a female will never make such allegations to falsely implicate her enemies". The willful ignorance of someone who doesn't understand what rape victims (or for the sake of Mr. Mehta's argument, those who allege it) go through when they come out publicly. We're seeing this in the Gogoi case, we saw this in Kavanaugh - men in power don't like to be questioned.
Third, the man started a "men-too" march - which is a gross mischaracterization of the me-too movement, which was about bringing too the public fray just how many women have been victims of abuse or harassment. Men have not suffered equally making this a false equivalence. Men have been dominating political and social spheres in our society (and most others) since written history - cry me a fucking river.
Fourth, statistically, less than 10% of rape allegations are proven to be false (globally) and even though it's usually due to lack of evidence, circumstantial or otherwise (botched test results, victim being unable to remember specifics because of trauma). This isn't some great impending doom that's facing "man"kind - literally.
I'm a man. And I feel ashamed that my biological gender includes disgusting shit stains like Mr. Mehta.
threads most popular
thread most upvoted
comment newest
first oldest
first