Spare us please, say Bombay HC judges to Adarsh PIL petitioners

Bombay high court judges SA Bobde and RG Ketkar suddenly, and mysteriously, recuse themselves from hearing the Adarsh housing society petitions against 13 retired bureaucrats, politicians and defence personnel, for alleged money laundering. They had been hearing the matter for several months now.

“Not before us”, the bench tells senior advocate Amit Desai who was arguing the case for quashing charges against former Maharashtra chief minister Ashok Chavan. The bench offers no explanation for the recusal [The Hindu]

Comments

DBS 29 Aug 2012, 15:41
+0 -0
Bit surprised! Bench of Justice Bobde & Justice Mridula Bhatkar were hearing these PIL's since past many months. But last week the assignment changed & Justice Bhatkar was replaced by Justice Ketkar.
There hardly used to be any place to stand in the court whenever this matter was heard as the courtroom was always jam-packed.
Been Around 31 Aug 2012, 05:29
+0 -0
Does any one have Any hope on this at all??

The rajahs and princes have been replaced by IAS/IPS/Mantris/Big Bizmen, most of whom earnestly believe they are the "rulers" post-independence.

Theories of democracy and trusteeship etc are only for textbooks and students.

The so-called 'independent' judiciary (as indeed every constitutional and democratic institution) is effectively being maneuvered by this bunch of low-lives. The Congis have had over 50 years in power to master this game.. the BJP top-brass' behaviour evokes little or no confidence.

I will be shocked if even a single one of these "rulers" get convicted in this or for that matter, Any other significant scam presently under judicial scrutiny (2G, CWG, Coal, Oil-exploration etc).. whistle-blower protection is unlikely to ever happen when such 'protection' is reserved for big Netas - who usually get effectively redeemed through death, no less.

What keeps the world from recognizing and admitting the dismal state of India's 'democracy'? Global corporate greed? The mess that is the EU and rest of the financial world? The Church and the Muslim World vis-a-vis the largest and most visible 'Hindu' nation?

While this blah sounds fantastic/jingoistic, I really see no other rationale or logic behind recent events..
Sunil Pandhare 5 Nov 2012, 11:12
+0 -0
This does not make sense for a common man, as to why would two judges of the Bombay High Court not listen to the argument put forward by by such a senior lawyer as Amit Desai. This matter should be looked into by the government.