Katju killed judgeship of lawyer who lived unmarried with 'lady lawyer' ('If you want to be judge' get married or stay single)

Ex-Supreme Court judge and high court chief justice Markandey Katju wrote on his blog that he had once spiked his own recommendation of a high court lawyer for judgeship, because that “male lawyer was having a live in relationship with a lady lawyer to whom he was not married. They were often seen openly going to parties, functions and restaurants together. Due to this advice I dropped the idea of recommending the name of that lawyer for Judgeship of the High Court.” Satyam Bruyat

When people later criticised his decision afterwards, he wrote:

My reply was that while I myself am fairly modern, Indian society is largely still conservative, and largely still does not approve of live in relationship, though it is not illegal.. While lawyers can have live in relationship, it is as yet not ethically permissible to Judges.

So if you want to be judge, please do not have a live in relationship

In 2010, Katju decided in the Supreme Court that “Indian society is changing, and this change has been reflected and recognized by Parliament by enacting The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005”, accepting that “relationship in the nature of marriage” could potentially also include “live in relationships”. Hat-tip @mohitsingh8

Comments

Fed Up 2 Feb 2015, 06:19
+7 -1
Just when you think this man can't get any worse...
whatta guy 2 Feb 2015, 06:56
+17 -5
To the best of my knowledge, one of Justice Katju's close relatives is in a same sex, live in relationship. And his rant against both! Wow.
Guest 4 Feb 2015, 14:45
+1 -0
who
Miracle Man 2 Feb 2015, 08:34
+8 -1
This is truly disgusting! The man in question may have been a candidate who deserved to be elevated. That he was a in a consensual live-in relationship with a woman of his choice is entirely his prerogative. But Mr. Katju had other ideas! Well, one only hopes Katju stops taking the moral highground any further from here on in.....the moral foundation on which Katju is standing is on the verge of collapse.
Guest 4 Feb 2015, 14:44
+1 -1
kaun hai yeh admi aur kaun hai oh relative