Food terrorism? Gov't hits Maggi with Rs 640 cr claim under Consumer Protection Act for us all

Someone somewhere really doesn't like dehydrated artificially flavoured noodles
Someone somewhere really doesn't like dehydrated artificially flavoured noodles

The Indian government has filed a Rs 640 crore class action on behalf of consumers with the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) against Nestle India under section 12(1D) of the Consumer Protection Act, reported the PTI.

Under section 12(1)d of the Act, “the Central or the State Government, as the case may be, either in its individual capacity or as a representative of interests of the consumers in general”, may make complaints to the commission.

Reuters, quoting a government of India official yesterday, first reported yesterday that India would seek the damages for alleged unfair trade practices, false labelling and misleading advertisements, after a food scare involving reports of excess lead in the company’s popular Maggi noodles forced a nationwide recall.

Nestle would be the first foreign firm to be asked to pay damages on behalf of consumers, according to Reuters. The claim has been made at the National Consumers Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC), which is a national tribunal dealing in consumer dispute matters.

The Government on Tuesday decided to fix the level of damages at Rs 640 crores, the official said.

A Nestle spokesman in New Delhi said the company would only be able to “provide substantive response” after it receives an official notice about the complaint filed to the NCDRC

Maggi was banned in India after the food safety regulator (FSSAI) accused Nestle of not complying with food safety laws.

Nestle has challenged this at the Bombay high court with Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas, saying its products are safe. The Bombay high court has reserved its judgment on the matter.

Maggi has been tested in various national as well as international laboratories, with varied results regarding the amount of lead and mono sodium glutamate (MSG) in the products.

Reports have claimed that the Government of India is suing Nestle for false as well as misleading advertising as they claim to have ‘taste bhi, health bhi’ (tasty as well as healthy) while excessive lead is known to have ill effects on human health.

Photo by sixth6sense

Comments

CAM or SAM? 12 Aug 2015, 11:00
+0 -0
Kian - which Amarchand? Cyril or Shardul?
kianganz 12 Aug 2015, 11:17
+0 -0
Oops, hard to keep up - Shardul, yes, correcting...
maggi maggi maggi 12 Aug 2015, 12:38
+3 -0
Despite the headline, its nice to see a balanced account on LI; It really bothers me how our media keeps reporting news accounts of how maggi has been declared safe in other countries. How does it matter if its been found to be safe in the UK? Unless ofcourse the exact same pack was tested in both countries and the results are startlingly dissimilar. And such repeated reports as if to suggest that somethin suspicious is afoot in our country. Granted, our babus are not above suspicion but it is very annoying when for instance an indian pharma co's (indian made) drugs were banned in the US and our DCGI said something to the effect that indian tests found them to be safe... all i read then was uproar from the media with headlines like 'Drugs Banned in the US OK for indians' says DCGI etc.

Sorry.. somewhere down the line it became a rant! the point is... if a product is found to be unsafe, no doubt the manufacturer will exercise his right to retest the same and argue on merits. It doesnt matter in the least whether another country or even the same lab found another batch to be safe.
Illiterate 13 Aug 2015, 05:44
+0 -1
Why blame media now . All these beloved food and cosmetics products are also creation of media through fraudulent misleading advertisement . Kian , do not worry for this kind of allegation .
To Kian 12 Aug 2015, 15:32
+0 -0
Hi Kian, who is representing Amarchand
To Kian 12 Aug 2015, 15:33
+0 -0
Who is representing Nestle at the NCDRC?
@kian 12 Aug 2015, 17:18
+0 -0
May i ask why my previous comment wasnt published? (under the name maggi maggi,i think).. i dont recall saying something offensive or anything...
kianganz 12 Aug 2015, 17:30
+1 -0
Sorry, slow internet today... Now up...
fyi 13 Aug 2015, 01:58
+1 -0
Kian you are increasingly becoming more opinionated.
kianganz 13 Aug 2015, 03:34
+0 -0
How is that?
cookie monster 13 Aug 2015, 06:18
+1 -0
the ban is now lifted. Also, with the US FDA giving its approval on test samples, and given the observation of the Bombay HC on the violation of natural justice in the entire case, it is to be seen how the arguments in this class action prevail. Another long drawn litigation filling the coffers of SAM maybe :)
Troll 13 Aug 2015, 17:08
+2 -0
The govt has filed the 640cr suit on behalf of the consumers you say. Where's my money, bi**h. :P
Guest 24 Oct 2017, 05:34
+0 -0
this site help us to know who is real or fake.
i am a consumer so i want to know many other reports whic comes arise consumer protection.