10 most important Supreme Court cases of 2011

Delhi-Supreme-Court
Delhi-Supreme-Court
Mint legal correspondent Nikhil Kanekal has surveyed leading Supreme Court counsel to compile a list of the year’s most impact-heavy cases heard by the apex court. Have your say and share your views.

Delhi-Supreme-Court
Delhi-Supreme-Court
Mint legal correspondent Nikhil Kanekal has compiled a list of the year’s most impact-heavy cases heard by the apex court. Have your say and share your views.

In no particular order (click here for a summary of each case)

1. 2G spectrum case: The court ventured into hitherto little-known territory—the politicocorporate nexus—in the aftermath of the Radia tapes, which escalated attention on the telecom spectrum scandal… (Read more)

2. Vodafone-Hutch deal: Few foreign companies expected India’s tax department to pursue Vodafone’s $11 billion (around Rs. 56,980 crore today) acquisition of Hutchison Whampoa?’s Indian operations… (Read more)

3. CVC: The annulment of P.J. Thomas’ appointment as the chief vigilance commissioner (CVC) was viewed by some quarters as harsh, and they argued that Thomas was a victim of political rivalry in Kerala, his home cadre… (Read more)

4. Bellary mining ban: The clampdown on iron ore mining in Bellary (which later became mining of all kinds) was the first combative step taken by a public entity to curb illegalities in Karnataka for over a decade… (Read more)

5. Meghalaya mining: Multinational cement major Lafarge was allowed to resume limestone mining after 17 months in Meghalaya’s East Khasi Hills… (Read more)

6. Black money SIT: The black money petition simply demanded that the government should recover all the untaxed money stashed away in European bank accounts… (Read more)

7. Salwa Judum: A state-sponsored guerilla army that also allegedly engaged children in combat, was declared illegal and unconstitutional… (Read more)

8. Experiments in the classroom: The Right to Education case dealt with radically changing the composition of children in schools… (Read more)

9. Land acquisition in UP: The Uttar Pradesh land acquisition cases saw a strong statement from the court, which deemed those acquisitions in which the government took land for one purpose and used it for another… (Read more)

10. Right to Food: The decade-old Right to Food case saw the court face off against the government and the Planning Commission multiple times on where to draw the poverty line, and how to divide food subsidies between the Centre and the states… (Read more)

Click here for a summary and background of each case.

Which Supreme Court cases do you think were most important, significant or exciting in the last 12 months?

Comments

GK 9 Dec 2011, 08:41
+9 -3
NO wonder India has dropped 11 places down to 95th (behind China) on Transparency International released the 'Worst Corrupt Nations index'.
Jitterplate 9 Dec 2011, 08:51
+9 -5
nice!
angry 9 Dec 2011, 09:05
+10 -7
Your website did not cover the shameful decision of the SC to acquit the accused in the Uphaar case just because it was not sensational enough. Today there has been a fire in a hospital owned by wealthy industrialists. It is sad that the media has such a short memory. Had the media gone after the Ansals and pressured the courts to imprison them, today's tragedy would not have happened. I hope we can at least now expect LI to criticise the decision to go soft on the Ansals and ask lawyers whether the people who own the hospital can be convicted.
shashank kumar 9 Dec 2011, 11:25
+14 -5
how are these the "MOST" important cases of 2011? they are just high-profile and media hyped cases
abhinav.nujs 11 Dec 2011, 05:35
+8 -2
Certainly, case related to Uphaar Cinema Tragedy has been missed and a few of others. Uphaar Cinema Tragedy case was one of the most important cases it terms of both legal principles and social principles. Also, there are a few other which appear to be significant, but have not been mentioned here e.g. Supreme Court's recommendation to abolish the concept of "Adverse Possession" - Though not much hyped, it was certainly an important decision.
Vijay Purohit 11 Dec 2011, 09:48
+1 -0
The Judgment bringing answer sheets within the ambit of RTI was also a crucial one.