NLSIU Bangalore has re-opened sexual harassment investigations barely 10 days after it closed a December 2016 investigation, following a photo allegedly mocking the incident that had kicked off the original inestigation was shared on a WhatsApp group of male students of the law school, reported The Bangalore Mirror.
The Sexual Harassment Investigation Committee (SHIC) had cleared charges against two students accused of sexual harassment on 17 January 2018, on the ground that there was not sufficient evidence against them.
On 26 January, one NLSIU student shared a photo picturing one of the two accused students carrying two oranges, in an apparent reference to the harassment charges that they just been cleared of.
According to a Facebook post by a student on 24 January:
In December 24, 2016, two NLSIU students, then in their second-year, had anonymously sent a parcel with two oranges and a note to a female batch mate. The note read: “You know what I mean!!! Use it, feel it #FeelBig #BigDreamDiaries from- BigPlanet.Com.”
According to a Facebook post by a student on 24 January, the parcel sent with oranges to the female student was “making a clear reference to her breasts” and that “when confronted by her and a couple of her friends, they confessed to having done it, but insisted that it was only a prank”.
After the picture with the oranges was shared on the private WhatsApp group - which apparently consisted only of boys - the other accused allegedly sent messages aggressively defending the photo against reactions by other group members’, who had called out the photo as offensive, according to screenshots of conversations posted on Facebook.
One of the WhatsApp group members asked the group, according to those screenshots, how those messages had even “reach[ed] to girls”, with another member of the group replying: “I don't see why that is a problem. If you're saying stupid shit, people will call you out for it... It's shameful that you guys don't learn.
"The point isn't that it reached women, the point is that what you did and said was wrong.”
According to the Facebook post, the 17 January order had the proviso that the SHIC would re-open investigation against the two accused students if any additional evidence against them surfaced.
However, NLSIU faculty member Yahsomathi Ghosh told the Mirror that “the incident that happened on the WhatsApp group is different for what happened on the Christmas Eve and it was a difficult case”.
“NLSIU is very cognizant of this issue and we have absolutely taken care of it. An elaborate report is given to the Vice-Chancellor and the registrar regarding the WhatsApp picture. Sensitivity and gender issues are carefully handled at NLSIU,” Ghosh told the Mirror.
The SHIC has taken cognizance of the WhatsApp group incident and submitted “an elaborate report” to the vice chancellor Venkat Rao, who confirmed investigation had been re-started, and the registrar.
One NLSIU student commented through a Facebook post that the “brazen display of shamelessness” in sharing the picture of the perpetrator holding oranges and then being aggressively defended demonstrates that “not only are they unashamed of their actions, but consider it something to be proud of and celebrated. The impunity with which sexual harassers roam on campus is unacceptable and reflective of a culture where violence against women is tolerated”.
threads most popular
thread most upvoted
comment newest
first oldest
first
1. "Harvard of the East" is a term first used by Bill Clinton used to describe Peking (Beijing) University in 1998.
www.indiatoday.in/magazine/guest-column/story/19980713-indians-continue-to-be-treated-with-contempt-in-most-of-first-world-826708-1998-07-13
2. Today, Peking university is ranked in the top 20 in the world.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peking_University
3. The BBC has used the term "Harvard of the East" to describe Peking's rival, Tsinghua University, which is also highly ranked in world rankings.
www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-39422190
4. Meanwhile, Hong Kong University, also ranked highly in world rankings, has been described as the "Harvard of the East" by the media in Hong Kong:
www.scmp.com/article/1512709/theres-good-reason-hku-harvard-east
5. Many have similarly described NUS Singapore as the "Harvard of the East", as it features highly in world rankings.
6. Many years ago, India Today used this term to describe NLSIU in its first Indian law school rankings, where NLSIU was ranked 1. Since then, an impression has been created that NLSIU is universally regarded as the "Harvard of the East", solely on the basis of one comment by an India Today reporter.
7. Kian Ganz and Legally India have perpetuated this belief by hyping NLSIU.
8. NLSIU does not feature even in the rankings of the world's top 200 law schools: www.topuniversities.com/university-rankings-articles/university-subject-rankings/top-law-schools-2016
These rankings look into faculty publications, infrastructure, foreign students etc, where NLSIU fares poorly
Thus, please stop referring to NLSIU as the "Harvard of the East".
But...
1) I don't really give a single crap whether someone is from NLS, Nalsar, GLC or Bangalore University. I really don't have a horse in that race, or any loyalties to defend.
2) I don't really give a crap about offending NLS grads about their college, whether they are friends or not, and to prove it, I'll say it here once and for all, so I don't get accused of bias or wanting to kiss ass of NLS grads: NLSIU sucks.
3) Within 5-10 years of graduation, I don't think that a single law school alum would in any case get offended by a negative story about their college or feel fondly towards someone else who praises their college.
4) In my experience, NLS grads will be the first to admit that NLS has a lot of problems, and they would be the first to want to solve them and see them written about.
We've said it before and will say it again- there's not much difference between the top NLUs, though all things being equal, everyone still happily chooses and recommends NLS first. Unless coaching institutes all agree to change their recommendation together, very few parents will take the first step of letting their kid choose Nalsar rather than NLS as a first choice.
The comparison will look at:
1) Placements and average salaries, foreign firm hires: 30% weightage
2) How many LLM acceptances at good universities abroad, how many got top scholarships: 10% weightage
3) Moots: 5%
4) Quality of faculty: 20 %
5) Infrastructure: 15%
6) Campus location: 5%
7) Safety for women outside campus: 5%
8) Quality of admin, absence of dictatorship: 5%
9) Social life inside campus: 5%
I am convinced that NLSIU will NOT be #1 in a fair ranking contest.
Hope to do some more in-depth reporting though when there's time.
Once I caught one joker zooming his eyes through my salwar. Later an older lady colleague told me that its a part of betting that those men did on what colour girls in office were wearing under their formals. It was a one off incident so I ignored. Anyways what cud I do?
- Criminal behaviour by students and ragging
- Unqualified teachers, much inferior to many other NLUs
- Nepotism in faculty recruitment
- Corruption
threads most popular
thread most upvoted
comment newest
first oldest
first