Delhi HC chastises police for inaction on DU law campus lawlessnessDelhi HC chastises police for inaction on DU law campus lawlessness

The Delhi University's law faculty's practical immunity to campus violence and vandalism led the Delhi high court to issue stern warnings to the Delhi police yesterday, reported the PTI.

Delhi HC justices Siddharth Mridul and Najmi Waziri reprimanded the police for its inaction on the complaint of law faculty dean Ved Kumari that there were incidents of “unruly behaviour” with the faculty members and staff. The judges reportedly asked the police:

What were you (police) waiting for? Were you waiting for people to come to court and for fact-finding reports? Why did you not carry out an independent probe? Is police outsourcing everything? What have you done in the last eight months apart from transferring the case to another agency

They also told the police:

We don't want you to rely on someone else's report. You are not going to peg your report on someone else's. Your constitutional mandate is to function independently

Kumari had first complained to the commissioner of police, in December 2016, after a law faculty student who is also the president of a political party publicly threatened and insulted her and after a list of detained students had protested against their detention, according to this video coverage by ABP News. She told ABP News that the Delhi police had not taken action on her complaint.

The Delhi HC took up the case, on its own motion, on 23 May 2017, and in its order on 25 May the bench of justices Mridul and Waziri noted that there was “endemic lawlessness” on campus, and said:

We are pained to observe, as widely reported in the press, that the protests have erupted into violence on numerous occasions leading to vandalising of the office of the Dean and her intimidation in every manner possible. We are further saddened at the alleged inaction of the statutory authorities charged with the responsibility of maintaining and enforcing law and order.

The bench also noted in the 25 May order:

There is no manner of doubt that on particular occasion despite their presence at the spot, the police have not taken proper action, in accordance with law, against the violent protestors.

While setting the next hearing date in the case for 9 August, the court has warned the police that if it fails to file a detailed status report within the next two weeks, on the steps taken in the case, it will invite the “displeasure” of the court.

Standing counsel for the commissioner of the Delhi police, central government standing counsel Anil Soni and advocate Mohinder JS Rupal for the DU's vice chancellor and for Kumari are acting on the case.

Order (PDF)

Click to show 5 comments
at your own risk
By reading the comments you agree that they are the (often anonymous) personal views and opinions of readers, which may be biased and unreliable, and for which Legally India therefore has no liability. If you believe a comment is inappropriate, please click 'Report to LI' below the comment and we will review it as soon as practicable.
refresh Filter out low-rated comments. Show all comments. Sort chronologically
Like +9 Object -0 Guest 13 Jul 17, 04:11  interesting
Those who wish to see the video can access it here:

This is the quality of DU students now: uncivilised goondas who cannot speak a word of English and have zero respect for women.DU was once a great law school but now it is completely third rate. Shame on India Today for ranking DU above some top NLUs.

I urge law aspirants to opt for 5-year law schools over DU, as the age limit has now been abolished. Better to lose two years and go to an NLU (or a decent non-NLU) rather than go to DU.
Reply Report to LI
Like +6 Object -1 Deadpool 13 Jul 17, 16:11  interesting
DU is a mess. The government should it it down and instead divert all the funds to NLUD and made the DU law campus a satellite NLUD campus. If NLUD gets a prime spot in the city it will be able to offer executive education courses and draw good visiting faculty. It can also rent the venue for corporate events and raise funds. All this will eventually make NLUD the #1 NLU.

90% of the students at DU are not serious, and the faculty and infra are also bad. Why not hand it over to NLUD?
Reply Report to LI
Like +1 Object -5 Guest 13 Jul 17, 19:50
DU 'educates' (to whatever quality) a couple thousand people every year. About a hundred are goons/politicians etc. The fee is a few thousand.

A law school, like NLU-D, takes in 80. The fee is a few lakh.

Kindly factor these in. Law schools had a specific mandate: Quality, Social engineering (Menon's myth). They have, by and large, failed on the second. Do not abandon mass education at their door step.
Reply Report to LI
Like +0 Object -1 Baburao 03 Aug 17, 02:35
Go read about NLUD"s death penalty project, don't come and rant here because smart hard working kids go there and do well for themselves. DU is a place for political scions, thugs, and children of lawyers propagating nepotism.
Reply Report to LI
Like +1 Object -1 Guest 14 Jul 17, 05:40
Some details missed in the LI report:

1) The guy's full name is Satender Awana Gujjar and he used to be DUSU president (Jat-Gujjar caste politics).

2) He is in the law course .

3) He is a member of ABVP and part of the gang that attacked leftist students at JNU. The police are not acting against him because of BJP pressure.

4) He is a known thug. There are many videos of him on YouTube.
Reply Report to LI

refreshSort chronologically Filter out low-rated comments. Show all comments.