Only 1 of 3 passes latest BCI qualifier exam for foreign LLB Indians

Exam: Only for PIOs, NR/OC-Indians
Exam: Only for PIOs, NR/OC-Indians
Three persons of Indian origin holding foreign undergraduate degrees in law registered for this year’s Bar Council of India (BCI) qualifying exam to practice in India, but only one – an LLB degree holder from Cambridge University - passed.

The fourth edition of the exam was held in August and the result was declared in October, days before the 25 October deadline to submit the 9 December bar exam application form. Candidates who are of Indian origin and graduate with an LLB from a foreign university that is recognised by the BCI, still need to pass the bar exam to earn their right to practice law in India.

According to the notification published by the BCI, only Swati Sood passed the exam this year. Another candidate failed to score likely pass marks in two papers and was absent for two others, while a third candidate did not turn up for any of the papers.

The BCI, since 2008, has been allowing law graduates from foreign universities that are recognised by the BCI to practice in India, subject to qualifying the exam that consists of six papers. Subjects include the Indian constitution, law of contract, company law, civil and criminal procedure codes and ethics and professional standards.

The registration fee for the exam is Rs 15,000 for the first attempt, regardless of how many of the six papers the candidate appears for. For subsequent attempts the fee is Rs 3,000 per paper, with no cap on the number of attempts a candidate can make.

A candidate should secure 430 marks out of a total of 600, and an average of 50 marks in every paper, to qualify.

Each year, the BCI holds a main exam and several supplementary exams in which candidates can attempt papers that they did not attempt or clear in the main exam. The main exam this year was held in January and the first supplementary exam for May was notified in April at the same time of the January results.

It is understood that due to the rarity of test takers as well as the fact that the exam was only recently developed, the BCI does not provide any model test papers, book recommendations, or scope and guidelines of the syllabus to be studied, requiring wide-ranging preparation.

Unlike the All India Bar Exam (AIBE), this exam does not allow test takers to take text books or materials into the exam room. Because the syllabus is so wide, many test-takers therefore break down the exam into fewer than six papers at a time.

Photo by US Navy

Comments

le 9 Nov 2012, 10:33
+0 -0
why restrict the test to PIOs/NRIs, let anyone who has a degree from a recognised overseas college sit for the degree equivalence/conversion test and be at par with the indian llb graduate and then if s/he likes can further sit for the AIBE if s/he wants to practice in court.
Globalisation 9 Nov 2012, 11:56
+2 -1
[quote name="le"]why restrict the test to PIOs/NRIs, let anyone who has a degree from a recognised overseas college sit for the degree equivalence/conversion test and be at par with the indian llb graduate and then if s/he likes can further sit for the AIBE if s/he wants to practice in court.[/quote]

You want Bangladeshi law holders to practice Indian Law with just decent knowledge of law?
Error? 9 Nov 2012, 11:17
+2 -0
A person of Indian origin is a person who was or whose ancestors were born in India but is not a citizen of India.

Swati and Srinjay are both Indian citizens.They only studied abroad.Please correct the article.
kianganz 9 Nov 2012, 11:26
+1 -0
I am not sure - isn't person of Indian origin (as opposed to the legal term of "Person of Indian Origin (PIO)"), a legitimate umbrella term for Indian nationals, Indian citizens, PIOs, NRIs, OCIs, etc?

And as far as I understand the rules, a person not of Indian origin would not be allowed to take the exam even if an Indian citizen (I.e., a foreigner who is naturalised as an Indian via marriage, etc).
Indian Citizen 12 Nov 2012, 09:40
+0 -0
So by your warped logic, by virtue of my being an Indian citizen, I am not of Indian Origin despite :

a) Me being born in India
b) My Parents being born in india and being Indian Citizens

If this is accepted what is my origin ?

Did you ever take a logic class in law school?
Jai ho! 9 Nov 2012, 12:13
+3 -0
Congrats Swati - for ranking first!
How 9 Nov 2012, 15:30
+2 -0
Tried to look up Swati's profile online and there is no trace. How did you know she is from Cambridge?
Lawyer 14 Nov 2012, 09:57
+0 -0
Because she sits right next to me at work!
FYI 10 Nov 2012, 07:21
+1 -0
AIBE is unconstitutional and should be scrapped. I am going to expose BCI's scam and file a PIL over the this.
aa 10 Nov 2012, 16:27
+0 -0
Hey Kian why has LI gone quiet on the liberalisation issue?
natanya 12 Nov 2012, 04:08
+2 -0
One person passed out of three.. That too passed one of the easiest exams in India.. I really don't know why this is such a big deal. The other two didn't ever complete the papers.

The article as a speed read could read - one cambridge llb student wrote bar exam and passed it. woo hoo?
101 12 Nov 2012, 06:20
+1 -1
[quote name="natanya"]One person passed out of three.. That too passed one of the easiest exams in India.. I really don't know why this is such a big deal. The other two didn't ever complete the papers.

The article as a speed read could read - one cambridge llb student wrote bar exam and passed it. woo hoo?[/quote]

Totally agree. No wonder Katju said 90% of journalists are fools. This website is giving less and less coverage of big stories that matter and has become a haven for "paid news" by law firms.
DBS 16 Nov 2012, 06:41
+0 -0
Is this exam held only in Delhi or in Mumbai also??

Also Kian can you post a list of Foreign Universities which the BCI recognizes?
scooter 20 Nov 2012, 15:37
+0 -0
header for the story is not clear. Makes it seem as if you mean it as a percentage result..
kianganz 20 Nov 2012, 16:15
+0 -0
Thanks for your comments - I'm not sure why there's such outrage over this post... :)

Scooter, nope, no percentage was meant, we LITERALLY meant 1 out of 3.

I thought it was a very interesting story actually - this is an exam that has never been written about, as far as I can tell, and about which very little information is available online.

Surely it must also cost the Bar Council quite a bit of time and money, unless they recycle the test every year. One could also wonder, if it is a half-decent test, why it wasn't adapted for the AIBE, rather than reinventing the wheel twice or three times every year?

Finally, I was also surprised by how few actually apply to this route. 3 test takers, of whom only 2 turned up?

Do please share your thoughts.

Thanks
Kian