We don't know what the Calcutta High Court is going to rule, but if it annuls the Panchayat election results because of mass violence and rigging, won't it amount to a solid ground for imposing President's rule under Article 356? In the history of India, we have seen courts annul elections of individual MLAs and MPs on technical grounds. For example, in 2019, the Madras High Court had quashed the election of an MP because of a false affidavit. But quashing an entire Panchayat election on grounds of voter intimidation would probably be unprecedented. I don't think it's ever happened before.
No responses or interest in post, and very tenuous legal argument / question that appears disingenuous, hence trollish (unless this thread proves otherwise).
Sorry but I am a person from Bengal who thinks that Bengal is slowly slipping into a dictatorship as election and voting rights lie at the heart of democracy which is unfortunately being denied by the state Govt!
Check out this video clip of the HC hearing today!!! Senior Advocate Bikash Bhattacharya (who is also a Left Rajya Sabha MP) argues before Justice Amrita Sinha that a certain area showed 95% polling according to the state, despite a large number of residents not being able to vote and some boycotting the vote. How is that possible?
Justice Sinha directs the DG of police and Returning Officer to submit a report by 3 August.
Pity the moderator is guided by bias instead of the merits of the petitions and automatically marks the topic as trollish. We could be on the cusp of one of the most significant cases in our modern constitutional history.
https://www.barandbench.com/news/litigation/west-bengal-panchayat-elections-violence-calcutta-high-court-sec
https://www.indiatoday.in/law/story/bengal-panchayat-poll-results-subject-to-final-orders-says-calcutta-high-court-2405896-2023-07-13
We don't know what the Calcutta High Court is going to rule, but if it annuls the Panchayat election results because of mass violence and rigging, won't it amount to a solid ground for imposing President's rule under Article 356? In the history of India, we have seen courts annul elections of individual MLAs and MPs on technical grounds. For example, in 2019, the Madras High Court had quashed the election of an MP because of a false affidavit. But quashing an entire Panchayat election on grounds of voter intimidation would probably be unprecedented. I don't think it's ever happened before.
What do you all think?
Justice Sinha directs the DG of police and Returning Officer to submit a report by 3 August.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VtoaxwVnm3I
Pity the moderator is guided by bias instead of the merits of the petitions and automatically marks the topic as trollish. We could be on the cusp of one of the most significant cases in our modern constitutional history.
2. However, what would make this case one of the most significant in our modern constitutional history?
PS: My only interest is as a constitutional history enthusiast. I couldn't care one way or the other about AITC, BJP or another political grouping.