We want LI to be one of the friendliest places on the internet, where lawyers and law students help each other with their career related queries and occasionally discuss other stuff that might affect their lives too. In other words:
1. Be kind, respectful and helpful to each other.
2. Be bona fide, truthful, genuine and curious.
3. Assume the best intention of others.
Therefore, in using the site, you must agree to do your best to uphold these community guidelines.
Note that what you find here is written and moderated by anonymous people on the internet.
Therefore everything you read here is very likely unverified, rumour, speculation and/or downright false.
In continuing to read anything here, you must therefore agree not to take anything you read here as factual and that you will exercise due caution, diligence and common sense before acting on any information you may come across here.
You also agree to report any inaccurate or malicious comments with the buttons. Moderators take action within 24 hours, as required and appropriate under law.
Our full terms and conditions apply too.
Do you solemnly agree to all of the above?
A moderator checks every review before it appears. Reviews stick to teaching, meaning clarity, marking, feedback, materials and workload, with no personal remarks, rumours or allegations. Any trimester from T1 2022–23 onward can be reviewed, and a separate anonymous board covers everything that isn’t a course review. The site is student-run and is not affiliated with or endorsed by NLSIU
What’s good for geese is good for gander no?
If we really want to push for meritocracy and efficiency in both directions - the reviews should be weighted by the students GPA. Cause what you’ll see very often is unmotivated lazy students punishing teachers who haven’t bowed to pressure and reduced standards. This is actually a pressure tactic for students so they can avoid fair valuation in the market place.
You sure do charge them the same fee, I see no discount for lower learning imparted?
Like it or not, the world is not your oyster, and all students are equal, your likes and dislikes notwithstanding.
> the reviews should be weighted by the students GPA.
Bold reforms should be at both sides of the transaction. How about weighing your compensation by your students' achievements relative to their achievements under other instructors? Or weighing it by your success in publications vis-a-vis your peer faculty? No?
> This is actually a pressure tactic for students
I'd like to see you make some real arguments, not castles in the sand or other such fugazis. Cite a single such review on that site right now and I'll accept this limb of your argument. This is mere fear mongering; you have not seen a single review. The moderation-first approach taken by the site is there for a reason. In any case, if anything, academics have perhaps the least pressure to do anything. Are you too special to be the only ones who are isolated from your stakeholders?
What do you think happens if my salary is weighted by how well my students perform in examinations I create and evaluate ? Are you this dumb ? Do you think they’ll get a fair assessment of their progress ? Or will they get more because I might fancy a new watch?
Faculty pay does depend on student feedback and on publications among your peers - it’s sad that you don’t know that. You’re embarrassing yourself.
My stakeholders aren’t some snot nosed brats who don’t care about the law and wait for papa to fix everything. My stakeholders are the future leaders of his country. I know quite well how to educate them and I do. You’re a sad anonymous troll.
If you had real courage of conviction - you’d tell faculty how you felt about them to their face. And had the courage to have them refute your nonsense. Instead you lob reputation bombs from the Internet. It’s really really pathetic.
I wasn’t a great student, but I was never this. I always told professors to their face when I had a problem.
Your understanding of power dynamics is at the bottom of the toilet, or you are the "sad, anonymous troll", making disingenuous arguments. We know exactly what you'd do - trash our reputations to all the other faculty, even the good ones, so that we'd never be able to ask for recommendation letters, even from faculty we don't have problems with. You know you'd do it, so don't even try to make some argument about professionalism. We as students really aren't stupid, you know. If you really have so many problems with the potential impacts of a scheme like this, why not sue the website for defamation if you think false claims are being spread? A law firm partner did that against Legally India and LI was forced into a humiliating climbdown. Or why not get off your high horse and actually protest against the government's way of funding universities? Why not protest that students have to pay money for their degrees? If government funds universities, students anyway don't get a say, and you and every other colleague can get away with your mediocrity. It would be an excellent scheme. Like the former British prime minister Starmer said in an analogous context (critiquing the entire civil service of his country) (but didn't have enough balls to stand by) - as de facto civil servants, you could comfortably wallow in "the tepid bath of managed decline". Here, we have the worst of both worlds: we pay fees and you get your "tepid bath of managed decline". This website is one small attempt to try and mitigate the damage caused by this status quo. If the government funded the universities, nobody would care if the faculty was bad or good - nobody among the general public, that is. Like they say in Yes Minister, the taxpayer certainly wouldn't care under such a scheme, because they don't have the time to care about whether or not their money is being misused. They only care if, in what time and headspace they have, they get to see that their hard-earned dollars are being misused. So your ideal scheme would be government funding with no meaningful oversight of what the students are experiencing from forces who are not necessarily a priori pro-faculty. Why not stand up for that position? Why not actually develop some "courage of conviction"?
"Faculty pay does depend on student feedback and on publications among your peers"
That is how it should be and theoretically how it is, but then why are there bad faculty at even the best universities of the world? Why is even the best law school in the country struggling in international teaching and research rankings? Clearly, these forces aren't anywhere close to being strong enough to cut out the trash from the good? Why is that? Because the universities choose to throw the bad feedback in the bin and selectively choose to pay regard to the good?
"What do you think happens if my salary is weighted by how well my students perform in examinations I create and evaluate ?"
The exact problem with how evaluation at Indian universities work - you've admitted it yourself. If there is so much peer review and the faculty are so wonderful, surely multiple faculty can get together to create an examination paper and multiple professors can view each student's answer? Also, why not have external examiner systems like they have in universities outside (even for undergraduate programmes)? Also, why not have any external/government quality assurance frameworks/inspection regimes that could mitigate the impacts of any unfairness caused by students with improper motivations? Or that could evaluate grade trends/distributions to make sure faculty aren't misusing? Why are you running scared from every possible means of scrutiny of what you are doing? This tactic of trying to invert the argument is the clearest indication of your real agenda. Sure, this may not be the best means of evaluating your teaching quality, but it certainly isn't the worst. Markets have previously stopped governments who are doing terrible things, they might just be able to help a uni save some money by cutting out a trashy course offering. If there was any true fairness in the world, then your suggestion about what would happen if faculty compensation was evaluated on student performance would be met by the policy measure of the faculty who misused such a scheme being required to feed the family of the student who was lied to and told they were good when actually they were bad.
As for who your "stakeholders" are, until you have control over who is admitted to whichever uni thinks they've made a clever decision by employing you, they are everyone who your uni admits and who is unfortunate enough to take up whatever course(s) you teach.
Teachers are not responsible for your lack of initiative. And only you are in the end responsible for what you make of yourself.
Thanks but no thanks - that would be helpful to a new student but not to current ones.
Do you know how to make a bank transfer so that I can get back what I have already paid? And can you calculate how much to give me (back) to ensure that I am in the same financial position in real terms as I was when I paid? Be careful what you wish for: Obiter might be the lesser of two evils. Somebody might actually demand their money back and restoration of financial position not from the university, but from you personally. You would be the ideal target for someone dissatisfied with their education and baying for blood like that. Your smugness and overconfidence makes the readers of your writing on here ill to read. After student protests at NLSIU in recent times, I am surprised how you have the balls to keep coming on here and writing this sort of nonsense.
You being an arse to a 'bad' student does not justify your behaviour.
A 'bad' student still has the voice to call you out on your behaviour.
Teaching ungrateful students feels worse than talking to a wall, yes. Been there, done that. But you are not entitled to their respect, while they are entitled to your time. They are the ones paying the fees, and you are the one receiving the money. If you want moral principles to trump economic principles, then try teaching without compensation for it. Otherwise, dont feel entitled cause you, sir, have already taken the money. You are costing them loans. The least you can do is turn 'bad' to 'good', or admit your failure to do it. But to try to silence their voice (especially when you have turned their life for the worse, most likely) is pathetic.
I’m not an arse to any students. I refuse to give out free points and commit academic fraud and 17-18 year old petty tyrants tell me that I’ve taken their papas money so I should do as they say. Which is what you’re suggesting. That’s corruption.
No one can turn good into bad. I cannot appear in the dreams of these guys to teach them procedural law. I cannot make them like something they do not like. I don’t have the production values of Netflix nor the liberty to make up stuff to be interesting.
It’s honestly disgusting how little responsibility you think the students have in their own education. Pay money, throw tantrums, get grown adults who are trying to do their jobs with integrity fired and humiliated.
A bad student isn’t typically doing poorly for reasons of lack of intellect in NLS. He’s doing poorly because he doesn’t attend, doesn’t read, doesn’t pay attention, and resists education at every turn. What can I do about any of that ? Am I supposed to now wake him up in the morning and read to him every night and dance in class so he’s not bored ? I’m an expert in my area of law, and I’ve been hired to educate some of the best young people in this country- why the heck should my performance be assessed on the worst most unmotivated smoked up absentee student in my class ? Why does that student have the same “voice “ to call me out ? What freaking standing do they even have when they’ve put zero effort in ?
You want to play these games - please go to Jindal. Private university behaviour. They’ll print you a degree in exchange for money. Leave India’s premier institution for people who actually like the law and take responsibility for their own gd actions.
Do you really think NLS admin cares what is said on a student-created website and if people have a hissy fit on there? If they do, maybe your portrayal of NLS is too generous? It's a student echo chamber. If they want to rant on it, let them rant. After all, there is a distorted logic to it: they get admitted to the institute, they take its courses, yes they pay its fees, therefore they join the tribe of other people who do the same thing, therefore among fellows of that tribe, they can express whatever opinion they have about these things. Why do you have to make it your problem? If they rate your elective courses badly and that results in numbers going down, doesn't that give you more time for research? Not everything needs to be or should be a critical thinking exercise or teachable moment. Just let it go. The mixture of anger and effort to get the students to think better of their actions and themselves is becoming increasingly evident in your responses, and is not helpful either to you, or to the students (frankly), or to the public perception of higher education. And if you're seriously concerned, this kind of a website shouldn't have any impact on you, as I said before. If it does, that says far more about your institution than it does about you. This is just the online equivalent of a student being rude about a faculty member in a student cafe.
There’s a difference between venting to classmates and systematically allowing students to bully professors and pave the path for grade inflation .
You can decide what you’ll get worked up about and I’ll decide for myself.
'systematically bully' grow a spine dude. you're a grown adult. you can't get 'bullied'. slippery slope fallacy much? jesus. wonder which nls faculty this is that nls has hired.
I’m confident in my abilities to find a job anywhere in the world. The question is whether I should have to because of some anonymous troll with a grudge .
P.S. Those instances of the kind of things even students don't feel they should touch? All given by way of example - clarification more for the sake of the LI moderators than of your peace of mind. The running out of the shower naked to change the music one was made up to send a message: somebody needs to convey to you a "reality check" (your own words) - what impressions of your character are gained from your aggressive and rude comments on this thread.
- Why necessarily be so loyal to NLS? If they make a mistake in the future like caring about dissatisfied students who don't try, faculty can consider other options, such as moving to a different university, maybe? (Sorry if this is a naive question and I haven't appreciated certain other difficulties, I am not an academic.) After all, universities' fortunes vary at different times.
- I don't think these arguments are going to make this site go away. After all, it's not like you have the ability to block students' access to any sites, the conversation here so far at least seems to indicate that they aren't persuaded and they will argue that the points about professional behaviour do not set in until after they graduate and start working. So all I can do is to say that the task you have taken up is one which poses formidable difficulties, and that you should be lorded for taking it up and I hope your gloomy prediction of what this site will become do not come to pass.
I can’t compel people not to say something - I can point out when a project is miguided and harmful.
Second biggest red flag: Your construction of straw man arguments.
Result: You are a bad law teacher who deserves everything Obiter can throw at him.
Confident in my abilities because I am not helpless without AI. When you know the law, you know it.
What shift in goal posts ? You’re being incoherent. Stop blubbering and say something coherent.
I’ve been fairly successful in my career outside of academia - I’ve done research that you’ll find in Supreme Court judgements you’ve read, I’ve worked with some of the best law firm partners in the country, I’ve published well and held my own in international settings. But really none of that matters - the thing that differentiates me from you - is that I know the law and I don’t have to use AI to wipe my own ass.
That’s why you folks will do nothing but complain and why I’ll swim along just fine.
1. The easiest - your grammar problems: Best example "papas money". Why should anybody connected to a student give money to a so-called "law teacher"/"expert" who does not know how to use apostrophes! Or commas for that matter! That description of the students who should not have "standing" from your perspective was exhausting to read because of its lack of commas so I won't even quote it here. For your information, it would be "papas' money" or if you were doing singular - that is one student instead of multiple, "papa's money".
2. The sexism: Where do you get the information that it is the father's money and why cannot be the mother's or aunt's!? And please don't give me "figure of speech". You can use "figure of speech" to equate "white" with "good" as many people in western countries have done. Also how come the "petty tyrants" all seem to be male - how convenient. Very specific view of higher ed.
3. Also very conveniently, you have ignored that people have mentioned loans. Someone has clearly said that your decisions are costing them loans. Before you even dare to open your mouth about how poor kids are more hungry for knowledge and success and will take any and all bullshit you throw at them - consider the possibility that kids from humbler backgrounds may have just stopped being as "humble" as you in your classist tower think they should be - and have become, like their more affluent peers, less willing to tolerate being made to go through nonsense and bullshit. Maybe some day, your expertise will have to be used to pay off the bank loan of a kid whose life you spoiled. Then we'll see which high horse you can still be steady on...
If you’re on loans you should spend your time studying ! Not bullying teachers ! Hope that helps!
Do you think paying fees can make someone change your character ? Do you think giving bad students - who don’t study, don’t work, don’t pay attention , don’t care, and maybe even cheat - the same “voice” as a good student aligns the teachers incentives to be fair in evaluation ? Or will the teacher simply think - eh - my job is worth more to me than whether some shithead has learned - and just give everyone good grades and make them do no work ? If you know anything about human behaviour - most people are going to take the path of least resistance.
And everyone is entitled to professionalism. Cancel campaigns are unprofessional.
I know you feel like you’re standing up to the man by bullying faculty and deflecting blame on them for you not studying. But you’re really not the rebel you think you are. You’re the bad guy. You’re just a bully. You’re just every rich kid who threatens working faculty because his parents didn’t teach him responsibility. You suck.
You know what? People have said beautifully in the past that law teachers at the universities are the most incompetent lawyers. They became law teachers because they couldn't become anything else. Don't know how it is in other countries, but that certainly is the case in India, and NLSIU is no exception. You do not make "barely more than an A0 at a law firm" because you can't, frankly, and don't deserve to. You know why? Because getting into faculty positions isn't based on the same criteria as being practising lawyers. How does checking if you have passed some exam called UGCNET and/or have a PhD work in law? Law is a practical discipline. Only those who have done the hard graft - have worked the 14 hour days at the law firm office, surviving on only coffee and sandwiches or run from court to court for 25 years - are eligible and fit to teach others this subject. All those fancy degrees - LLMs, MPhils, PhDs - regardless of where they are from, if they are in law, are worthless.
And even if you voluntarily chose to waste the taxpayer's money by getting on a pretty nice job which largely seems to involve coming on an anon message board to abuse people who are exercising their constitutional right of free speech to use another anon message board, you need to develop a sense of realistic expectations. Just like you tell students to have realistic expectations about grades etc when the first word comes out of their mouth about wanting to go to Oxbridge, so should you develop a sense of realistic expectations about what happens in your job. The lawyers who do the real hard graft of legal practice don't go crying on anon message boards when their clients post shitty reviews about them online, nor should you. If you can't, don't ask for money from students - as somebody else has already said.
I don't know if, sitting in your ivory tower, you have ever heard of a law firm called Paul Hastings - look them up if you haven't, that skill should be possible for you to use, as a researcher? One of their associates once beautifully presented on realistic expectations. That person said that the client was god. If the client wanted to move mountains, it was the lawyer's job to make that happen, one way or the other. The moment you take our time, money and energy away by telling us that this is the academic requirement you need to satisfy first to get into law school and then to succeed in law school, that's your job as well and that is the expectation you have to realistically satisfy. If you can't do it, don't do it.
It is true that law is, by and large, a practical discipline, but it is equally untrue that legal academia, theory, thought and teaching is of no value. Sure, teachers at every NLU suck and a vast majority of them are washed up lawyers, but petulant students like you discourage even the talented, highly educated (ie. foreign educated) ones from entering academia or staying in India.
I hope you do know that a large number of new profs in NLS, and most Jindal profs, who are "foreign return", studied at the very law schools you are bitching about, had worse, traditional college lecturers than you, didn't have AI to cook up assignments at 2330 hours on the submission deadline, and still worked hard to excel at top universities. They had excellent grades at their undergrad schools and could have easily made it to any of your lala law firms (it's honestly not that hard; I say this as someone who worked in a "T1" myself) or even the best chambers. And yet they left, partly because they are genuinely too smart and talented to waste away their life working on rehashing the same fucking DDs and WSs. They are also doing you a favour teaching you something, if you'd bother to listen.
2. Wow - "And yet they left, partly because they are genuinely too smart and talented to waste away their life working on rehashing the same fucking DDs and WSs". Where are the Yale Law Journal, Harvard Law Review and Law Quarterly Review articles, OUP, Hart Publishing, Harvard University Press and CUP books, and evidence to UN bodies and parliamentary committees as proof of this? Where is India's Ronald Dworkin? According to your version of the picture, we should have a dozen of those by now!?
Please do get back urgently with whatever it is you are smoking. I can't wait to take it, then at least I can join you in your bliss of falsehoods. I can also maybe join academia and forget that students have to pay bills once they graduate.
And no, if you look at Jindal, NLS teachers are paid little + YOU PAY LITTLE. That's the way a public institution works, and whoever is offering to teach there instead of fucking Jindal, or SNU, or BITS, or the next Mr Whatizname McBillionaire entering this space, IS DOING YOU A FAVOUR. If you hadn't filled in a couple of OMRs correctly in some idiotic assessment (by your own admission) when you were a teenager you wouldn't have been here. Do you think law students in the US / UK (who do have better profs, because their unis attract global talent) don't have to work hard and achieve everything they do just by having good profs?
Do you not realise that so much random admin work, and yes TEACHING WORK, is given to profs here (unlike tenured profs abroad who may teach very few courses, and that too is for JD / LLM students where class hours are fewer) that they CAN'T focus on research and publications? If you think they're all duds how did they make it to Oxbridge to which you sadly can't get the grades to go?
Like what is the argument here? Many profs at NLS and every NLU suck (agree). Those who don't are largely brilliant and could have been anywhere. Develop some humility
Faculty at nls have better publication records than at any other place in the country.
You have a right to speech. I have a right to call it bullying and misguided and insane. Maybe try attending constitutional law. Only really dumb students mistake a right to free speech with a right not to be criticised.
I don’t ask for money from students. Nobody is forced to come to law school. You can and should quit and do something you’re better suited for. Become a thug in loan collection or a movement leader. I get paid because I do a job and provide value for students who do well in my courses year after year cause they give a shit and work hard and pay attention and do the readings. My top students never speak badly of me as my worst ones do. That says something, especially because most grading is blind.
Your attitude in the law school holds back your peers who actually want to try. You make us dumb down our teaching and then our best students are left feeling like their time is not better used. I am actively encouraging you to leave. Do any other course - do business administration - you don’t have to study for that.
Clients are not god. That’s dumb- there are limits to your professional obligations if you studied in that class. Lawyers are officers of the court, they owe obligations to the bar and the court and their client.
Similarly - teachers aren’t contractors who live and die by whether the 10 year old client is in a mood. They owe obligations to the education system, the university, future students, and in this case the legal profession that goes beyond making you happy with your mediocrity.
You seem to be very unstable. Seek help. Go to therapy. Maybe find some adult who is willing to parent you properly.
The moment you can't make a substantive argument, you use the "go to therapy" and "you are unstable" card. I'd advise you not to waste your time (and more importantly, the taxpayer's money), students in Indian law schools have seen our faculty and admins do this for far too long. You don't seem to care that language like this might do significant harm to people whose mental distress might require actual medical intervention. And if we are speaking about obligations, how come you get an exemption from behaving in a way that upholds the public's confidence in your profession? As you were so scared of "cancel culture", somebody should actually bring this up now: somebody should tell your employers about your harmful and discriminatory language against people with mental health difficulties. They did it to Michael Foran (at Glasgow, was it?) when he spread harmful rhetoric against trans people (by apparently "doing his job" according to the Committee for Academic Freedom by giving an interpretation of UK law that would make trans people's lives a living hell). We should take inspiration.
As for not being smart, your comment is riddled with assumptions:
(a) How do you know it is your bad students who speak badly about you and not your good ones? How would you know that if course evaluations and grading was blind?
(b) How do you know your good students don't speak badly about you behind your back?
(c) You do ask for money from students. Otherwise, tuition fees would be lower or zero. If you are so mindful of your obligations, do a salary sacrifice and volunteer as a teacher at NLS for three years for free. As for your obligations themselves, the only part you are right about is that they do require you to grade students fairly and strictly. But the part you have forgotten is that it requires you to give all possible inputs to help the students achieve, not just to throw a reading list at them.
(d) Nobody is asking for an exemption from being criticised. You have every right to show how thin-skinned you are and be a highly amusing little crybaby and destroy the meaning of the word "bullying". The irony that you are spending your time here arguing with those you anyway see as your intellectual inferiors when the taxpayer, your students and your employer pay you to engage in allegedly more helpful activities to society is being pointed out.
It’s interesting that instead of arguing merits yall just jump to “that’s some kind of ist” is more proof that anonymous student comments mean jack shit.
How do I know good students don’t talk badly about me ? Cause they’re more often frustrated with their fellow students ! I have happy relationships with most of my high performers because we built a relationship in the classroom - they knew what I was talking about because they’d done the reading and so had I - we were making a connection that went over your head.
My obligations don’t include having Netflix production values to my classes or catering to the least motivated least interested student. I teach to a standard all my students should be at.
I don’t ask for money from students - if you don’t stay at nls - any one of a million law students in the country will happily take your spot. I get paid for work I do. I know the concept of work is foreign to you - but try and expand your mind.
You’re wasting your time here too - and I actually don’t think it’s a waste of time - better you engage in discourse rather than persist in your own ignorant ideas. Shooting off replies to you guys doesn’t cut into my day substantively.
Maybe im thin skinned - maybe im just tired of mob like behaviour being treated as if it’s fair criticism. We don’t make these demands of any other professional in the work place. Teachers are a unique punching bag in society where your private life and your affect day in and day out is subject to the most awful humiliating public outrage- and you can’t say anything about students being bullies because that is “punching down.” I’m the child of working class people doing a job, and I’m the one with power against students who are obscenely wealthy and obscenely entitled. Sure.
Just one small matter - give me a date when you, personally, can return all the money I paid for my law studies so far. Also my CLAT fees. Please additionally give an email ID to which I can send bank details for the money to be sent to - no admin shared emails with autoreplies which won't be followed up on for 10 months, but your personal email as the responsible person for reaching this conclusion. As you care so much about the students and as the university would allegedly experience financial harm in catering to any and all refund demands, you, to protect your students, should be the one having to foot the bill.
Don't forget, as we are being realistic, that you will need to make appropriate adjustments for inflation when sending the amount so that I am restored to the exact financial position in real terms in today's date as what I was before I made financial sacrifices to study law. As you are so ready to put yourself on the line for this, why not deal with the consequences as well yourself? No? I know very well that you won't do this because apparently you don't have deep enough pockets. Hard to believe as nobody without parental deep pockets and/or massive savings from a high paying law firm kind of job would be dumb enough to go in for an academic career anywhere in the world, how many ever research ideas they had. Oh but of course, I am forgetting academics' passion for unrealistic expectations. We are supposed to believe the assertion that you aren't dumb, even if you aren't willing to go out on the other extreme limb and claim you are smart.
You (or the processes you don't question) decided that I was suitable for law school when I came in. Now you are saying I am unsuitable, give me my money back, as you are admitting that a mistake was made. And let's not have any of that "information we now have which we didn't have before" nonsense or any other kind of caveat. It's your fault you didn't find other ways than the joke of an exam that you use for admissions to check my (or anybody else's) suitability.
It’s surprising to me that your response isn’t “ oh no I love the law, you can’t run me out of this town”. It’s give me my money back. The most Karen response ever.
I know this might be a new idea for you - but there are things money can’t buy. There are things in the world you can only earn- like an education, like the love and admiration of your colleagues and like success in your professional life. Degrees you can buy - but not that other thing.
You arguably made a graver mistake if you joined law school thinking you’re paying to lie on a bed of roses every night and be handed a job and a career at the end of it. And there are millions of students who will give an arm and a leg to take your place.
And yes, some poor people will choose academic life despite not coming from wealth or privilege - because they just like learning and knowing things and know that there are things you can’t buy. Sorry your world view is so narrow. Hope you feel better ! Seek help babe!
1. So much abusive language: "bully", "rich kid whose parents didn't teach him responsibility", person who "sucks". If we are talking about "responsibility" and parents, it's your parents who need a hitjob done on them as well - just like you did a hitjob on mine. They haven't taught you how to talk with basic respect to people without whose money you would be unemployed and more importantly, unemployable. If I were your dad, I'd wash your mouth with soap until the back of your throat had blistered from gagging. Before you ever say anything about my parents again, you should know that for one use of abusive language at school, that's what my dad (with justification) did to me. That was an effective enough lesson to teach me that I don't need to compromise my dignity and sense of self by even typing out one word of the invective that whoever was irresponsible enough to bring you up to be what you are deserves.
2. misogyny and sexist assumptions baked into every single word of this post. Why can't women be possessed of the horrible character attributes you claim I have? Why am I supposed to be a man? Why not a woman? For that matter, how do you know I am not a woman? What are women in your life: sweet, submissive dogsbodies who type out correspondence at your dictation to foreign faculty where you sloganeer about how morally virtuous and woke a person you are? Cleaners who you get away with not paying for months at a time because they are too submissive and frightened to tell you where you get off to your face?
3. Please make a substantive argument for once in this pointless conversation. This is no better than a Jason Arday writing. Show me one review where anyone has said anything unfair and/or objectionable. Explain how it is unfair and/or objectionable. You haven't been able to do this. And I suspect that you know you can't. You just want to escape scrutiny at any cost, that's all. What you need is a government inspector sitting in every class of yours for a year and seeing if 94% of the students whom you supposedly teach so well have achieved a job that pays them well or a further study place at a world top-100-ranked university (with a scholarship) within six months of graduation. And also checking that you are behaving in your private and professional life in a way that upholds your stakeholders' (and the public's) confidence in the profession of academia. A test on which you would score a 0 out of 10.
You don’t listen or understand what other people are saying. Until you get better at reading comprehension - you won’t do better at law school. It’s not a a good argumentative strategy to just exhaust your opponent by asking them the same questions over and over again and not listen to their answer.
I haven’t used abusive language at all. I’ve merely said what I thought. You don’t like it - but that doesn’t mean it’s abusive. Telling students they need to take an active role and take responsibility for their own education and professional achievements is not abuse. It’s common sense.
The best teacher in the world - cannot guarantee you a job or a place in the best foreign university. That one is up to how much work you can put in. All the best teacher in world can do is prepare well for class, communicate information that is important for students to know , and hope they’re wise enough to take advantage of the opportunity they’ve been given. Your whole argument rests on the idea that you can buy a career instead of working for it. “I pay tuition and therefore the university should get me a job, should get me a foreign university spot” it’s a “papa can you buy me this” attitude that demonstrates a lack of good parenting. I’ve seen students in classes with teachers much better than I am be totally disengaged and irresponsible.
If a teacher is failing to teach - that you already have course feedback and university systems to address. But this isn’t that. This is just - we want to anonymously attack people we don’t like.
I’m not afraid of accountability - I am afraid of mob justice. If you want to send any teacher in the world into my classroom to evaluate , look at my question papers and grading, that’s all fine. I’m far from unemployable given I’ve turned down industry jobs to do this job. Most of your professors at nls have done the same thing. So that bit is just projection- you’re worried that hire unemployable- and my suggestion is - instead of blaming everyone else. Take some responsibility- go to an adult in your life who will tell you what responsibility is- and work harder.
Universities anywhere in the world don’t guarantee you a cushy life. Harvard doesn’t, you can and people do flunk out of Harvard - is that because Harvard has bad teachers ? Or is that because those students didn’t work hard ?
Education isn’t a consumable good. If you sign up for a gym but never hit the weights - you’re not gonna meet your goals. That’s not because the gym is bad or because the trainers are bad - that’s because you have a role to play that you aren’t playing.
An inspector to look into my private life ? This is what a law student at the best law school in the country thinks is appropriate ? Would the same inspector also look at your behaviour ? Or does papas money make you shielded from that ?
Your picture is incomplete, though. You are correct that it is the students' job to fight for those things. But it is the professors' job to assist them, and failing that, to at least not actively hinder them. That's maybe what has changed from your time.
On "patronising tone and ultimate condescension", your response gets: 10/10.
On actual substance you get: 0/10.
Thanks, at least, for one helpful lesson.
You’re not a child. Your teacher isn’t your mother/father. They don’t have to run after you to make sure you do well, do your homework, that you have fun in law school and learn. You need to run after them to make sure you do well.
This is what students who do well get that students who don’t do well don’t get- you’re responsible for your own lot in life and nothing is handed to you. The teacher has already worked hard to get their degrees and jobs. And their job is not to be your personal recruitment agent- their job is to come and teach, and make available to you everything you need to succeed/ but it is up to you to actually run the race and get the prize ! It won’t do to sit on your ass and make demands ! How are we in a world where this needs to be said !!!
Here’s a reality check - if you want those things - it’s better if you’re off working to get those things - than building a website to slander your teachers and get them cancelled for giving you honest grades- that’s a spectacular waste of time. I bet the toppers at nls who will get into Oxford and who will get foreign law firm jobs won’t be doing that.
Finally! We're getting somewhere substantive. Thanks for this.
Why don't I, the students who do well and the students who don't do well then get paid for doing that? Why do we have to pay as well as "run after" teachers, if the only thing we get in return is (allegedly) everything we need to succeed? Because here's the crux - the "reality check" (to use your framing) - you are missing, either deliberately or because of some other genuine reason, but most likely deliberately, because you might want to avoid the hard truth that you are not doing all you should be doing if you are operating in a system where students are asked to make financial sacrifices for such an uncertain return. This conversation is happening because students are feeling that they are not being given everything they need to succeed. Your response to that so far, as faculty, has been to sneer and to make caricatures of their arguments - i.e., to respond in bad faith. If you do that, what you'll get back in response is even more outlandish arguments. The only good faith response received so far is this one.
Students who feel exploited by higher education or by a particular university (NLS being no exception) feel this way because it's a business at the end of the day - and if the business cheats its customer, be it in selling groceries or anything else, they will complain. All the ideas of scary scenarios that have been suggested - faculty taking least resistance paths to game student satisfaction - are just other ways of saying that one way or the other, you would cheat the students. Here's an idea: instead of making up straw men arguments, saying that you can't do certain things or crying about the necessity of doing certain things because apparently students are no longer willing to work, why don't you do what you're doing now for free? Because that's what it's worth. Maybe if you do that for five years, you'll find that you are almost begging to do the things you said you couldn't do or shouldn't have to do.
Here’s what I suggest - weight the reviews by the GPA of the student. Or make students self assess how many hours a week they spent studying a subject before they can review the prof. If high performing students have an issue with a teacher- then there’s a reason to take the complaint seriously. But more often than not - it’s some back bencher who hates that the teacher called him on his bullshit and decides to write a nasty review.
There is a difference in maturity, but I don’t agree about indulging it to the point of allowing students to be petty tyrants who are cruel to the working people around them.
Spotted! Someone having wet dreams! I'd be willing to stake my reputation that you are a supporter of that faculty member involved in the scandal known as "shortsgate".
Therefore:
surely you're wise enough to know the difference between an 18-22 year old studying in a university versus an adult in a career centred on so-called research + teaching students
When we get our student feedback, these things are removed and then shared with us.
I also did not like how a few young faculty are rated and the review says it's more about the course than the teacher.
Various times, the complaints for profs are coupled with the courses they take. Would love to see more formats to drop a review which makes the reviewer actively think about what the problems (if any) are.
I am currently revamping the website such that it doesn't require Student ID at all but rather a series of questions (3 or 4) so that only those who know the campus can login and make a comment however, anyone can access the website to see the review and all.
The only reason I used the student ID was that so only the college kids can give reviews and all, and it doesnt store the student ID anywhere on the website or the server, the login creds are stored only in your browser which is lost when you close all the windows of the said browser.
Yes, teaching is very important. Yes, culture is important. Yes, you should encourage work ethic and make them into good officers of court.
But if you think students criticising you is hindering your ability to do that; or that a website where students can review their teachers can affect the way in which you impart education... wow.
Just take the feedback if it applies to you, ignore it if you feel it is unfounded. Some of the worst teachers I've had (and now, colleagues) are the ones who resist feedback to the point where they just no longer communicate well with the students.
jfc what a shitshow of a thread
Just repeating this, since you seem to have skipped it:
"Just take the feedback if it applies to you, ignore it if you feel it is unfounded. Some of the worst teachers I've had (and now, colleagues) are the ones who resist feedback to the point where they just no longer communicate well with the students."
Let us not conflate feedback with complaints. And let us not increase the threshold to "back it up with proof". It's not wrongdoing we are talking about, it's the inability to do your job well. There's a difference between the two.
Anyway, one of us clearly doesn't have enough work to keep them sufficiently busy. Bye.