We want LI to be one of the friendliest places on the internet, where lawyers and law students help each other with their career related queries and occasionally discuss other stuff that might affect their lives too. In other words:
1. Be kind, respectful and helpful to each other.
2. Be bona fide, truthful, genuine and curious.
3. Assume the best intention of others.
Therefore, in using the site, you must agree to do your best to uphold these community guidelines.
Note that what you find here is written and moderated by anonymous people on the internet.
Therefore everything you read here is very likely unverified, rumour, speculation and/or downright false.
In continuing to read anything here, you must therefore agree not to take anything you read here as factual and that you will exercise due caution, diligence and common sense before acting on any information you may come across here.
You also agree to report any inaccurate or malicious comments with the buttons. Moderators take action within 24 hours, as required and appropriate under law.
Our full terms and conditions apply too.
Do you solemnly agree to all of the above?
Undercutting by T1 firms is a pretty normal thing and itโs something Iโve seen happening for the last 10+ years. Itโs not just tier 1โs, it's everyone who falls in the second pool. What โthe second pool' means is something that should hopefully become clear at the end of this post.
More than locking in clients and securing relationships, undercutting is driven by the fact that there isnโt that much โaccessible' work going around thatโs up for grabs. And just to be clear, Iโm not talking about the overall M&A / PE market, Iโm talking about what work is available to bid for, there is a difference between the 2.
Letโs talk about pool number 1 first.
This comprises of the big ticket, news headline work that, in all frankness, is not up for bidding unless you form a part of a pre-determined pecking order of specific partners within an identified pool of law firms (usually the big T1s).
Not just in India, but the world over, including London and the US, the most visible and cover page PE and M&A mandates are usually allocated to a handful of firms and partners. That distribution of work โat the topโ itself is โnot fairโ to begin with. I have seen this myself in India and I have enough and more peers abroad in these markets who say exactly the same thing.
The reasons for this limited pool of allocation has several factors but one obvious one which all lawyers need to be aware of is that the big ticket M&A and PE market has only a handful of large institutions that command a sizeable portion of investment dry powder. So the guys sitting on the money themselves AND who are in the position of authority to determine which agencies to work with, are part of a โchosen fewโ. There is no โdemocracyโ or โfairnessโ in this process. It is basically familiarity and comfort, which, unfortunately, can never, in most cases, be extended overnight to a new and upcoming firm.
So unless you are a part of that well set pecking order of law firm partners and teams that they (the big PE / financial institutions) like working with, dont expect anything from the first pool. Even in each of Indiaโs tier 1 firms, the partners who work with the big PE funds are always a handful. These are the teams that usually take the most smoke breaks, suffer the worst WLB, endure the most savage burnout, โฆ you get the idea. If you can even devote half a days time to do this exercise, you can even plot on a piece of paper which PE firms operating in India prefer working with which partners. Heck in the AI world, that exercise would take just a few minutes now.
More than being by design, itโs a reflection of how the โbuyer of legal serviceโ (PE / institutional capital) want(s) the setup to be. They themselves have an outsized access to investment capital and it remains their consistent endeavor to keep competition (other investors including PE funds) out. If you happen to have friends in the PE / VC world (I mean real friends who will open up about the stuff they face), you will realize that fund raising (and fund closing) is a nightmarish process. The folks who can invest (SWFs, family wealth offices, HNIs, UHNIs, DFIs, etc) are a tough lot to work with, all over the world. So these โaccess routesโ to capital are usually โguarded' with a lot effort.
In other words, you are trying to break into a market that isnโt fair in the first place. So forget the sanctimonious comments like competition, driving down costs, efficiency, etc. Itโs all a fairly sophisticated racket that drives the distribution of work. Youโre either in this pool 1 or you arenโt. And like the pecking order of a good liquidation preference clause (which should also give you a hint of what actually gets distributed), if you arenโt in pool 1, you get relegated to pool 2.
Now letโs come to pool 2, which is where the rest of us live (or languish).
This pool comprises of the slightly smaller institutions or PE funds, usually the prolific mid market funds or the guys who have slightly more proven track records of exits as well as the smaller, more recently formed VC funds and all other categories of investors there are.
As diverse as this pool is, the common thing that unites all of them is the fact that they will never cut the big cheques for legal fees. This isnt out of greed (necessarily), it is more to do with the fact that their set up or activities do not always get them the outsized returns. Most of these investors (including the ones that make the 10-20x returns) are usually baffled themselves by such large returns and are consequently more determined in keeping every penny they can. So forget the big fee that covers the next month billing. In effect, irrespective of the competition you face, you are already dealing with a potential client that has pretty much decided a ceiling on what your fees can be. This is the important precursor of an undercutting market.
Now coming to your competition, because this second tier of work has a giant list of under-utilised corporate lawyers, you end up having to fight and elbow your way past a dozen, if not more lawyers, law firms and teams around you just to secure that half decent mid market (or really sub-par) mandate. You have to particularly remember here that the T1 partners and teams that didnโt crack Pool 1 are now your competition here. Now that itself is a massive tent of flunkies, newbies, chainsmokers, old veterans, factory rejects, Managing Partner sycophants. And dont even get me started on T2, T3, T4, other tier firms...
In other words, Pool 2 is literally you fighting for the crumbs that fall off the large dining table. You have the more established firms and teams who are now facing younger, hungrier and much more determined teams who are willing to drive down the costs in order to secure the mandate.
So think of pool 2 as the โgroup of deathโ stage in the qualifying rounds of a cricket or football World Cup. You have no control over who you are competing with, but you have to somehow stay alive and remain in the race. This is quite literally the mantra of every boutique firm partner there is. This is also the reason why base salary costs and bonuses in a smaller firm can never truly compete in a sustained way against what the bigger guys offer.
Hence you can also forget the sizable margins, building of large teams or acquiring expensive office real estate. All of that is fairly pointless without the margins (especially the pool 1 margins) to help you build towards it. So as a boutique firm lawyer, you naturally have to gravitate towards building smaller and more nimble teams, foster strong promoter/company relationships (& hope they turn into Unicorns AND remember you and your efforts). Look at any good T2, T3 firm in India over the last 15 - 20 years and see for yourself how many of them cracked into the big leagues, as far as headline mandates are concerned. Over time, they all realize that no matter how good they are, the allocation at the top is already decided. So good luck.
Now instead of talking about the long term viability of this undercutting and how itโs only going to screw all of us in the long run, let us ask ourselves why does undercutting happen? Its largely because of this lingering question of how exactly do firms distinguish themselves in this second pool, other than saying we arenโt idiots and we dont mess up deals (which isnt a scalable USP for any firm). Every firm says, we can do what xyz does and we are cheaper and we are looking for a long term relationship. Doesnโt that sound familiar?
Now as far as tactics are concerned on how to combat this, well once I have a good, working answer for it, Iโll be happy to share.
All this being said, I will also say that there are some massive benefits of being part of a boutique firm and that list of benefits would take a small booklet for sure. Since that is off topic, let me pause it here. ๐
Till then, stay alive folks.
This sounds just like street shopping tactics. Bhaiyya woh dukandaar ne toh 100 rupay me bech raha tha aap iskeliye 200 bol rahe he. Barabar daam bata dijiye. Varna me vaha he khareed loongi
Undercutting is just cheap tactics
The newly made/new book partners also drop rates to build a book and clients tout those rates to T2/Boutiques saying oh Tier 1 has given me this rate - can you match.
Note: There are other reasons too which are not our fault but that's not point of discussion
Curious whether others in the mid-market space are seeing the same pattern, and how you're responding