Read 73 comments as:
Filter By
Try to get 2 publications and focus on your phd. Also try looking for a Godfather/Godmother.
At least where I did, my state uni had much better reputation than Centrl University of the state.
Nobody cares about a PhD in law from the last three places. JNU's international law/relations department still has vestiges of reputation left. This central university superiority is only in your mind.
Err...plenty of NLU alumni work at the IIMs and IITs where law is taught. As for BHU etc., why would they go to teach at those places with hopelessly outdated syllabus and practices and which no longer engages in even basic research?
Your insistence on clinging to false info is astonishing. IIT KGPs law school has such faculty.
A BHU is much bigger than an NLU for the general public and people in power. Lolz. Except for the top NLUs like NLS, NLUD, NALSAR, no one is bothered about NLUs. Why do you think people still apply in lakhs to DU, JNU or BHU ?
There is no power associated with being a cog in a place like BHU. People apply there because people apply for everywhere. And how often do these places recruit anyway? These are dead places for law.
Try getting into a Central University with an NLU phd. Lolz
I can name at least five such people off the top of my head.
Name them, without searching. And tell me whether their last degree, i.e a PhD, is from an NLU or not. Because it won't be. Their UG is from NLU, not phd. Their PhD would be either from a foreign University or from a central university like IIT, IIM, BHU, JNU etc
Nope. Their PhDs are from top NLUs and I'm not doxxing them to compensate for your lack of research.
Which journals did you get your articles published in?
If I tell that, I'll be ghosting myself. One of them was Indian Law Review.
Don't know where you got that statistic from. In Indian universities, almost everyone who starts a PhD these days ends up finishing it, even if it takes longer than 5 years in some cases.
Nope. Majority are preparing for some sort of competitive exams and leave once it gets cleared. To the point that many universities are mulling over the fact whether they should impose a penalty on people who are taking a stipend and leave midway .
People not finishing because they opt for better opportunities don't indicate lack of success.
Improve your comprehension. The op was replying to the 50% dropout rate which is true. Majority don't or never finish their PhDs. When selected , the candidates are usually 20-25 per session, only about 4-5 complete it.
Where is the stats to back it up? Or is it source: Trust me bro? Most people pursuing their PhD from NLUs finish it.
Success ratio means completion. And drop out, for any reason is not success. So yes, the success ratio is only 50%<
Don't. PhD or academia is not worth it. It doesn't guarantee a job.
Both + publications seem to be minimum to get into a good academic job
Does it really matter where you do you PhD from ? Obviously I am not saying a massive difference like a Tier 1 NLU and a private university, but more like a decent known university.
Only if it's a Central University. Like JNU, DU or IITKgp. Rest all are not worth it.
Can publications and research beat experience? Or can they beat brand name of the phd institute?
Who writes their supervisor's name in the CV? It's not a common practice in India at least.
100%. I specialise in technology law, my LLM and my PhD thesis was in tech law. They gave me a environment law professor as advisor that doesn't even know the T of technology.
So there's no difference between a PhD from JNU, NLS, IITKgp and a private university like Shiv Nadar or Bennett? What a load of bs ! A CV with a NLU will always beat a CV with a private universities
There are good private universities for law in India? Which one?
You can't select your own advisor, 99% of institutions don't give you that option. You think this is a foreign phd ?
The employer will always choose an nlu PhD and some decent publications over a private university phd and great advisor. The advisor is only for your aligned interest not for the employer.
True. Every single PhD from any university in india is the same. In the end it's the degree, publications and connections you can make.
So is it fine to do a PhD from a private university?
I don't recommend pursuing a Ph.D. at a private university, as they require Scopus publications and make them a criterion for getting your degree. Makes no sense, and you end up in financial trouble and low academic quality.
But good private universities provide decent stipend even for non-net. Also if you're really interested in teaching/research, isn't it expected you publish in Scopus ? No one is saying it has to be Q1.
If you can't even publish once in Scopus in your 5 years as a PhD, do you really deserve the degree ? I think it should be mandatory to atleast have one publication in Scopus.
If your phd is genuinely done, even one chapter from your thesis can produce a good Scopus article.
Can someone please answer the things asked by op. Rather than only talking about Ph.d.
PhD is the pathway to assistant professor. Even if you get selected via a LLM and NET, you will still need a PhD for promotion from assistant to associate professor. So better to complete it asap. Thus more emphasis on PhD here
Absolutely. Also, a PhD doesn't guarantee you a job since the vacancies are so low that for cost cutting the university is willing to let 1 asst professor teach 5 subjects rather than recruit 5 expert for each. That's why even after the PhD be prepared to face unemployment.
Nothing guarantees selection other than connections. An LLM with connections gets you a job over a PhD with zero connections.
A 4-word comment posted 2 months ago was not published.
A 17-word comment posted 2 months ago was not published.
A 22-word comment posted 2 months ago was not published.
A 15-word comment posted 2 months ago was not published.
A 3-word comment posted 2 months ago was not published.