We want LI to be one of the friendliest places on the internet, where lawyers and law students help each other with their career related queries and occasionally discuss other stuff that might affect their lives too. In other words:
1. Be kind, respectful and helpful to each other.
2. Be bona fide, truthful, genuine and curious.
3. Assume the best intention of others.
Therefore, in using the site, you must agree to do your best to uphold these community guidelines.
Note that what you find here is written and moderated by anonymous people on the internet.
Therefore everything you read here is very likely unverified, rumour, speculation and/or downright false.
In continuing to read anything here, you must therefore agree not to take anything you read here as factual and that you will exercise due caution, diligence and common sense before acting on any information you may come across here.
You also agree to report any inaccurate or malicious comments with the buttons. Moderators take action within 24 hours, as required and appropriate under law.
Our full terms and conditions apply too.
Do you solemnly agree to all of the above?
Then again if Mahua M had to drink bitter Mahua when Babul Supriyo switched or Kalyan B is allowed to get away or BJP leaders invent juvenile reasons to evict Mahua from the LS, then we shouldn't cry over the bar getting lower everyday.
Demolitions too are for show. Didn't the new govt know that there will be resistance and Courts will step in. Now it's fumbling. The public isn't stupid.
And the icing is the infamous BDO now out on bail because the IO for the murder case was missing and the requisite papes didn't reach the judge who kept waiting till 8pm!
These need proper audits because funds from MLA LAD and state finances were involved. Also like to know which inspired lot were the beneficiaries of this largesse beyond the smokescreen called PWD, WEBEL and ilk
Also what about the Fire and Emergency Dept scam perpetrated ▮▮▮ and later ▮▮▮?
All the regime friendly police officers at all levels and their ilk in the state administration, prosecution and even judiciary should be exposed. No persecution but definitely prosecuted wherever evidence is strong. Departmental proceedings at least to begin with and not the meandering variety.
Also the eager beavers, chameleons are in talks with Congress. Green may implode and a significant faction may join up or "return" to Congress. That's a headache for BJP
But yes we shouldn't just have a regular audit. But a forensic audit.
I remember that The Statesman then still fighting strong had done a series on how the Left was refused loans by PSBs for purchasing state transport buses. Then a big lot was bought via various WB based cooperative banks, which were led by Left apparatchiks. It was a scam but no one did much because everyone was involved. Greens furthered this trend when they took over
It is true that a lot of illegal encroachments and constructions happened during the Let regime. But Green just accelerated it. Now we are saddled with an accumulated mess and I suspect that eventually like always, regularisation politics will happen. So the wheel would get reinvented again.
If the new govt is serious then it should just clear out all the concrete jungle built on EKW. Let's see how it goes after Urbana and ilk.
Ideally the new govt should appoint a full time team of expert investigators and lawyers to pursue and dismantle the organised loot that took place.
We all know how Sovan Chatterjee, the ex Mayor of Kolkata got his moniker Jal Sovan. Former IAS officer and TMC insider, Dipak Ghosh details it all.
I wonder why the new CM hasn't directed an audit of KMC finances, esp ADB, World Bank and GoI funded projects. Too late to do anything about DFID and those bfr 2011.
But now the new govt is silent about reviewing what happened to these inquiries and how much got spent etc. Why? This is such a low hanging fruit.
Also why isn't the govt doing a forensic review of monies spent on contested matters such as the edu scam etc. Was the govt also passing off personal litigation costs of the chosen as litigation expenses with our tax monies?
The govt doesn't and shouldn't need Delhi to pick up a team to investigate all this. More so when it is scared to even query CBI and ED inactions and sabotage of critical cases.
Also why isn't a forensic audit of the health dept and RGK getting done? The list of why is long but it appears no one wants to undo the culture of getting away without responding.
Both these actors are well known chameleons. But this isn't the case to undo them. Played a weak hand.
Why is the new govt going soft on so many others, such as Soham C ( Chinar Park incident among others), Dev (returning money and doing films with Mithun C shouldn't mean forgiveness), Sayoni G, Nusrat, Ankush and the list goes on.
If serious pursuit (as opposed to persecution) is made then Hisab will be done. Otherwise it is just painting pictures on the wall with something similar sounding with P.
But why do the Greens remain mum that it is the Unnao and Hathras case veterans who have ensured that RGK is likely to remain yet another case of "we know but cannot prove beyond reasonable doubt".
Today the Cal HC DB hearing the RGK matter ordered CBI to constitute a SIT to look into the alleged lapses of the CBI investigation.
I find the silence of the Saffron brigade stunning. No reaction to the points raised in the HC nor the expose by Justice Abhijit Ganguly.
I also find it extremely telling that a certain Green affiliated lawyer confidently taunted Saffron bros to pursue call records etc of CBI investigators Pahuja and Meena.
Why is the media quiet about all this? Just mere reporting no probing?
I know for a fact that one of the reasons the HC appointed Bag Committee that was also led by a retired judge could make swift and inconvenient progress was due to the presence of certain senior lawyers in the committee who had both domain expertise and spine thus nullifying the misleading attempts of the govt appointees inside the committee.
I think something similar should have been done here as well. Lawyers or retired investigators who are known for spine and having intimate knowledge of the system should have been brought in.
But why is the new CM holding back on taking action against erring IPS officers for actively sheltering Green apparatchiks and their masters who slandered Justices Mantha, Biswajit Basu and Abhijit Ganguly (separate incidents)?
Not just EKW restoration but also rapacity of the erstwhile govt in rural areas across Bengal, esp Darjeeling and North Bengal must be addressed. Pretty soon we will see UTK and HP like man made disasters being passed off as Acts of God
It looks like the govt is in a tearing hurry to tell and show but not actually do the grunge work reqd to permanently demolish an entrenched ecosystem of corruption that involved every layer and level of the system.
I don't understand. Sudipto Sen, the Sarada boss and his ex-gf and Sarada honcho are out on bail without bells and whistles but Kunal G needs to pack in heavy beyond what is potentially available to MLAs! Pray why?
And why has the new govt not called in Kunal G on the edu scam issue after his explosive disclosure in an ABP Ananda interview? Also what is the Bengal govt now doing about Kunal G and Rajiv Kumar in the Sarada case after gently letting him retire?
Why no action on Rajiv Kumar on Sandeshkhali, Sheikh Shah Jahan and Anubrata Mondol issues? Just because he had retired and is in the RS rt now? Or a much deeper setting?
It is like RGK and other scans wherein "setting" was definitely involved. But the Genie is now out and cannot be fully buried like Sarada etc.
The new govt tasked the DMs to start salary recoveries from teaching and non teaching staff who were identified by the SSC and CBI as having got appointments via illegal means. But what's the progress and why isn't the govt ensuring that SSC etc publish the names with relevant details. The recoveries if done right will be substantial. And why aren't these 5000 or so individuals being pursued to name those who took cash for jobs?
If the Centre can pull in paramilitary forces from all over the country for security during and after elections, why can't they bring in additional officers including retd officials for surge support?
Under the camouflage of access given to locals, a local club fronted TMC egress who built permanent structures including gym and various other facilities. When the old couple protested, threats followed including forceful takeover and eventual eviction from their own house. The couple then took refuge with a relative in Park Street. Eventually then won reprieve from the Cal HC because local police did zilch.
The club with tacit TMC support even contended that the old couple had given them access for their own protection and the takeover was in public interest since the old couple had no children nor could they properly exploit the property to full potential.
The HC ordered Surajit K Purkayastha IPS who was likely the CP then or something senior (later the first state security advisor to Unkind) that he must personally restore the full property to the old couple and demolish all unauthorised structures. But that remained unfulfilled citing local law and order problem including threat of suicide by local men and women who later got unmasked as local Unkind goons.
Two prominent ministers, Partha Chatterjee and Arup Biswas were the ringmasters and used their ministerial position to abuse govt finances to forcefully acquire the land using central funds under Ganga Action Plan. The then KMC mayor (likely the now discarded Sovan Chatterjee) enthusiastically got involved as well. Invoking special powers that property was "acquired" for a measly amount that was declined by the old couple.
This was spun by the wretched Unkind that the old couple did all the drama for money. Except it was later revealed that the old couple had previously desired to donate the land during Red admin if that helped the cause of Adi Ganga rejuvenation. That standing offer had remained with Unkind govt as well.
The Cal HC was exasperated. But judiciary has its share of ahem too. So a certain judicial restraint crept in when the state govt through its venerable AG (not the usual suspect KD) made its intent abundantly clear. The case was allowed to meander in the judicial jungles. Surajit kept getting promotions. And the old couple stayed away knowing that they wouldn't survive the local goons.
I don't know what happened eventually. But the state did acquire the land but it was not used for the pumping project. Maybe it came up eons later. But the gym and club remained.
Why isn't anyone looking into this? After all now we get to hear wonderful details if how Unkind acquired multiple lucrative plots, organised loot via police, KMC and worthies like Sona Pappu. Why is saffron so quiet about shady deals by Merlin Group and other real estate majors of Kolkata? What about the illegal Wow Momo factory fire? Are we getting warm?
Just three IPS officers getting suspended. For the cited reasons, heads of IAS, WBPS, WBCS,
Ei Samay has an interesting history. It was started by a former ABP editor (who also started Kolkata TV with Aparna Sen et al) with alleged slush funding from Sarada or some other ponzi fund. Later the founder got arrested (alleged persecution by both frenemy Unkind and Saffron Brothers) and abandonment by Reds. Aparna scooter expectedly. Soon Ei Samay gets taken over by TOI and then subsequently becomes a vanity purchase of its present owner.
But the actual case in the court gets lost in the process just like Sarada, Rose Valley, ICore, Pailan, Tower group and other Ponzis
Jai Ho. The Great Indian/Bengal Circus continues and the band plays on.
Unkind and her apparatchiks must face penal action for initiating malicious prosecution against Prof Ambikesh Mahapatra, Kamduni protestors etc.
The new CM is only making sarcastic threats like his predecessor and launching photogenic police action.
I am also stunned by Saffron silence on the bombshell dropped by their own MP, Justice Ganguly concerning RG Kar case. CBI is literally getting a blank cheque to murder the case. Compare that with the conviction it obtained in TN for custodial murder perpetrated by the policemen on father and son.
This clearly shows that RG Kar definitely involved some Princeling and hence sabotage from the highest levels involving all the parties and even questionable action by the DYC Court.
https://www.linkedin.com/posts/sucharita-basu-2a93b8107_𝐁𝐞𝐧𝐠𝐚𝐥-𝐬𝐭𝐚𝐫𝐭𝐬-𝐚-𝐧𝐞𝐰-𝐜𝐡𝐚𝐩𝐭𝐞𝐫-activity-7458804003217264640-JJba
https://www.linkedin.com/posts/sucharita-basu-2a93b8107_𝗜𝗻𝗱𝘂𝘀𝘁𝗿𝘆-𝗚𝗼𝘃𝗲𝗿𝗻𝗮𝗻𝗰𝗲-𝗮-activity-7461017162451697665-fNLt
Now Saffron has a chance to do Right. Restore the wetlands if not to its original state then at least to what it was when Ramsar recognition came through although I am pretty sure satellite imagery from 1992 onwards is also available.
Also what about restoring water bodies that flanked both sides of the EM Bypass, Kasba and PAS connectors, the route to Airport starting from Ultadanga and inside Topsia, Tangra, Tiljala (the names say it all), Picnic Garden etc.
There is even a recent Cal HC order dt Feb 2026. Do it bfr we suffer the fate of Chennai, Bangalore and Mumbai. And also be ready to suffer real estate lobby and so called "janta" who complain and sermonize but also profit from these illegal and disastrous encroachments.
Stop cherry picking low hanging fruits. Follow through with your promises.
CAG should also audit all universities and colleges, public, autonomous and private ones. Something is very off about their finances. There is a strong whisper that many serve(d) as laundering fronts. But just like CBI, the ED too looked away.
Hisab seriously? It sounds more like the man mockingly meant something sounding with P that has been showered on us in the name of Ache Din and Chowkidari
Wonder why? Blame Kindness for all drama, optics but what explains the kind treatment by Great Leader and his acolytes? Nor any real action by the raging Reds?
Pahuja recently got promoted by CBI, which was castigated by parents of the victim of RG Kar case. Interestingly, the BJP panelists were deeply inconvenienced by this expose. TMC ofc kept repeating that they did a good job which was buttressed by CBI.
Pahuja is from Chandigarh and worked closely with a senior IPS from JHK cadre whose dad was a senior IPS from JHK and husband is a senior IAS officer in JHK. Interestingly, this Addl Dir of CBI (Sampat Meena) had previously "solved" Unnao and Hathras cases and Pahuja was her junior then. Sampat is from IPS 1994 and so is Vineet Goyal, who was the CP of Kolkata Police when RG Kar took place. Goyal has recently been suspended by the new WB govt along with two other IPS officers.
I get a feeling that Justice Ganguly is getting inconvenient for BJP and will likely get more isolated and eventually shunted by the next elections.
Why isn't the Double Engine reviewing the role of CBI officers, their call records etc? Also what explains the intense interest of DYC Court to swoop in and after killing time, return the matter to Cal HC when the main case was literally buried for good? Did CJ TVS pay the price for taking the right but inconvenient call on this case?
If the govt were truly serious then just these 3 IPS officers wouldn't have been suspended. So many health, forensic, municipal etc officials were involved. CBI was clearly complicit in hushing up the RG Kar case. Why this token, piecemeal (non) action?
But is this all hogwash? Remember how the Rizwanur murder case got buried and almost all the IPS officers esp the senior ones not only got off the hook but even got rewarded with plum postings? Kindness even promoted and made Ministers out of IAS and IPS folks who killed off inquiries in the much discussed and weaponized Bantala, IPS Mehta, Singur, Nandigram etc cases.
Go back further. The Left did zilch to police folks who committed atrocious excesses in the name of anti Naxal operations and Marichjhapi massacres.
Hence will the histories of gimmick and hollow promises repeat (esp when the role CBI in RG Kar is not being scrutinized) or is the wheel getting broken this time?