We want LI to be one of the friendliest places on the internet, where lawyers and law students help each other with their career related queries and occasionally discuss other stuff that might affect their lives too. In other words:
1. Be kind, respectful and helpful to each other.
2. Be bona fide, truthful, genuine and curious.
3. Assume the best intention of others.
Therefore, in using the site, you must agree to do your best to uphold these community guidelines.
Note that what you find here is written and moderated by anonymous people on the internet.
Therefore everything you read here is very likely unverified, rumour, speculation and/or downright false.
In continuing to read anything here, you must therefore agree not to take anything you read here as factual and that you will exercise due caution, diligence and common sense before acting on any information you may come across here.
You also agree to report any inaccurate or malicious comments with the buttons. Moderators take action within 24 hours, as required and appropriate under law.
Our full terms and conditions apply too.
Do you solemnly agree to all of the above?
The Indian legal academy mourns the passing of Mahendra Pal Singh-widely known as Professor M.P. Singh one of the most distinguished constitutional scholars of modern India, a visionary institution builder, and a teacher whose influence will endure for generations. His life was a testament to intellectual rigor, humility of origin, and a relentless commitment to the advancement of legal thought.
Born in the historic city of Meerut in Uttar Pradesh, Professor Singh's journey from modest beginnings to the highest ranks of global legal scholarship represents the very spirit of Indian academia at its finest.
His early education in Uttar Pradesh instilled in him the discipline and intellectual curiosity that would later define his career. These formative years shaped a scholar who would go on to leave an indelible mark on constitutional law, comparative jurisprudence, and legal education across continents.
Trained in law at Agra and Lucknow and later earning an LL.M. from Columbia University, Professor Singh combined rigorous Indian legal training with global academic exposure early in his career. He began teaching in Meerut in 1964 before moving to the University of Delhi in 1970, where he would spend more than three decades shaping legal education and constitutional scholarship in India.
The Scholar and Thinker
Professor Singh's first and perhaps most enduring contribution was as a scholar of constitutional law and comparative jurisprudence. At the University of Delhi, particularly at its Campus Law Centre, he emerged as one of the leading voices in constitutional discourse in India. His scholarship combined doctrinal precision with a deep philosophical engagement with the Constitution as a living instrument.
His editorial stewardship of the celebrated treatise "V.N. Shukla's Constitution of India" transformed the work into one of the most authoritative commentaries on Indian constitutional law. Under his guidance, the book evolved into an indispensable reference for scholars, judges, and practitioners alike.
His intellectual output was both wide-ranging and profound. Over the course of his career, Professor Singh authored more than a hundred research papers in leading national and international journals and wrote or edited several influential books, including German Administrative Law in Common Law Perspective, Freedom of Trade and Commerce in India, Comparative Constitutional Law, Legal Dimensions of Market Economy, and Human Rights and Basic Needs.
His work consistently explored the intersection of constitutionalism, administrative law, human rights, and evolving legal systems.
Equally monumental was his comparative scholarship on German administrative law. His work examined the German system through the lens of common law traditions, creating a bridge between legal cultures and demonstrating how comparative study can deepen constitutional understanding.
The Teacher
Beyond his scholarship, Professor Singh will be remembered as an extraordinary teacher. For decades, his lectures at the Faculty of Law at the University of Delhi were legendary. His classes werenot merely about statutes and judgments; they were conversations about constitutional values, democracy, and the responsibility of lawyers to society.
Students recall his rare ability to combine intellectual depth with clarity, humility, and warmth. His teaching was not performative but transformative-
guiding students to think critically about law as an
instrument of justice ratherthan merely a profession.
His influence in the classroom extended far beyond formal teaching.
Through seminars, discussions, and mentorship, he nurtured a culture of intellectual curiosity that shaped generations of legal thinkers.
The Mentor of Generations
Perhaps no measure of Professor Singh's legacy is greater than the generations of students he mentored. Many of his former students went on to become leading lawyers, judges, academics, and public intellectuals in India and abroad.
He took mentorship seriously, guiding students not only academically but ethically-encouraging them to pursue excellence with integrity.
His office doorwas always open, and countless careers were shaped by his patient advice and intellectual generosity.
The Institution Builder
Professor Singh also played a defining role as an institution builder and academic leader. As Dean and Head of the Faculty of Law at the University of Delhi from 1994 to 1997, he strengthened the academic culture of one of India's most influential legal institutions. His leadership combined administrative foresight with an unwavering commitmentto academic excellence.
His contributions to institutional development extended well beyond Delhi. He served as Vice Chancellor of the West Bengal National University of Juridical Sciences, Kolkata, where he helped consolidate the academic foundations of one of India's premier national law universities. Earlier, he also served as Director of the Indian Law Institute in New Delhi, contributing to its growth as a centre of advanced legal research.
In later years, he continued to play important leadership roles in the legal and academic community, serving as Chancellor of the Central University of Haryana and as Chairperson of the Delhi Judicial Academy in New Delhi. Through these positions, he continued to influence legal education, judicial training, and academic policy in meaningful ways.
A Global Scholar
Professor Singh's scholarship was never confined by national boundaries. His academic journey took him to some of the world's most respected research institutions and universities.
He was twice awarded the prestigious Alexander von Humboldt Fellowship and spent time at the University of Heidelberg in Germany, where he served as Visiting Professor and Head of the Law Division at the South Asia Institute and later as Visiting Professor at the Faculty of Law. He was also a Fellow at the Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law in Heidelberg.
His international academic engagements extended across Asia and Europe. He served as visiting professor at institutions including the University of Hong Kong, the City University of Hong Kong, Kansai University in Osaka, and the National University of Singapore. He was also associated with the Institute for Advanced Study in Berlin and held visiting positions at institutions such as Jawaharlal Nehru University and the Indian Institute of Science in Bangalore. In recognition of his scholarly contributions, Renmin University of China in Beijing honoured him as a Visiting Professorforthree years.
Through these global engagements, Professor Singh built intellectual bridges between India and the wider world, enriching comparative public law and contributing to international conversations on constitutional governance and administrative law.
Five Enduring Contributions
Professor M.P. Singh's legacy may be understood through five enduring contributions:
1. A towering scholar and thinker in constitutional and comparative law whose writings shaped legal discourse in India and beyond.
2. An extraordinary teacher whose lectures inspired generations of law students to pursue rigorous and ethical legal practice.
3. A mentor and guide whose intellectual generosity helped shape the careers of countless students who later became judges, lawyers, and scholars.
4. A visionary institution builder, whose leadership strengthened major legal institutions including the Faculty of Law at the University of Delhi and the West Bengal National University of Juridical Sciences, Kolkata.
5. A relentless researcher with a transnational intellectual vision, whose comparative work-particularly on German administrative law—remains a landmark in cross-jurisdictional legal scholarship.
A Personal Reflection
On a personal note, Professor Singh has been a profound source of inspiration in my own intellectual journey. His scholarship, clarity of thought, and commitment to constitutional values have shaped how I understand law and its role in society.
For many of us associated with Jindal Global Law School at O.P. Jindal Global University, Professor Singh's work has served as both a foundation and a guiding light. His intellectual legacy continues to inspire our efforts to cultivate rigorous scholarship and meaningful engagement with constitutional questions.
A Life Well Lived
Professor M.P. Singh belonged to that rare generation of scholars who saw law not merely as a discipline but as a moral and intellectual vocation. His life's work-spanning scholarship, teaching, mentorship, and institution building-has left an enduring imprint on the landscape of legal education in India and the world.
His passing marks the end of an era. Yet his ideas, his writings, and the countless students he shaped ensure that his legacy will continue to illuminate the path of legal scholarship for generations to come.
May his memory remain a guiding force for all who believe in the transformative power of law.
At an event in ILI, someone called Prof MP Singh the Bodhi Tree of Indian academia, especially public law. It's hard to think of a better metaphor. Few will ever match his kindness & compassion. Today, a giant fell and left Indian academia poorer
https://x.com/shubhankardam/status/2030277605539119558
1. Madhava Menon: Opening batsman. An institution builder and great administrator. Set up the inning beautifully.
2. BS Chimni: Middle order. One of India's greatest legal scholars and someone with global standing. Continued Menon's tradition of having solid visitors and excellent people on the governing bodies. Not a hands-on administrator like Menon, but administrative skills are secondary when your opening batsman has got you off to an excellent start.
3. MP Singh: Middle order: Excellent administrator and a very respected scholar. Alum of Columbia University, many years of experience at DU. Hired Shamnad Basheer, Sudhir Krishnaswamy and many young scholars at the rank of Professor. Poached Sudhir (an Assistant Prof at NLSIU) and directly made him a professor, saving him 10 years of service. Same with Shamnad, who was still a PhD student. Many other good faculty hired: Sourav Bhattacharya (NALSAR-Michigan alum), Chinmayi Arun (NALSAR-LSE alum) etc etc. Encouraged tons of credit courses by alumni and guest faculty from law firms and industry. Gave full autonomy to SJA to decide these courses. The NUJS Law Review flourished under MP Singh and became India's top legal journal at the time. In the later years of his tenure, the TMC came to power. Mamata began by appointing her astrologer to the NUJS EC (see report below). MP Singh refused to accept this appointment and rejected all other types of interference from the TMC.
https://www.barandbench.com/news/mamata-banerjee-recommends-astrologist-nujs-executive-committee-nimai-banerjee-ready
Menon was like Gavaskar, Chimni was like Pujara or Dravid, Singh was like Tendulkar or Kohli.
After this, all VCs were appointed under the TMC: Ishwara Bhat, Amit Talukdar, NK Chakraborty and now Nandimath. Don't need to comment further. I will only encourage people to compare the composition of the NUJS governing bodies then and now. 🙏