Read 3 comments as:
Filter By
Is that how you write response papers to mandatory readings in your law school buddy? Because god you wouldn't have passed in my law school with those reasoning skills.

There may be better critiques of that article. Come back with those.
The authors of both the pieces are at least brave enough to declare their views openly. Until you shed the garb of anonymity, it is unlikely that your opinion on this matter will ever be accorded any importance.