Read 13 comments as:
Filter By
He was not confirmed because he dared to go against Indira Gandhi and allowed numerous bail and Habeas Corpus petitions during emergency. He was a man of rock solid integrity, his son not so much.
Please at least get your facts right. Justice Lalit's father resigned from the Bombay High Court to resume practice - it was not that he was not confirmed.
Nariman was one. At least he seems to be a jurist.
Just analyze the number of SCI Judges whose parents were judges, lawyers, or politicians. Take just two judges of the SCI -- DYC (father YVC, former CJI) and UUL (father judge of the Bombay High Court who was not confirmed).
6. Daddy must have solid judicial contacts. Or maybe belong to a judicial dynasty. Or best yet, be a RW Legal Intellectual
Never. Baxi was considered in the 80s when Bhagwati was CJI.
When is the last time in Indian history that SC has had an 'eminent jurist'?
One possible pathway:

1. NLS undergrad
2. Oxford postgrad
3. Private college teaching
4. NLS VC
5. Eminent jurist route to SC
No. No. And very little yet, but that may change over the next decade. To answer your three questions.