Revision as of 17:05, 20 September 2010

Version 2.03: This is the third list of Moots and Scoring Criteria for MPL 2. In all likelihood, this is going to be the final List. We have been receiving suggestions from our readers regularly and we thank all of you for sparing time and helping us finalize the List.

This version has incorporated very few changes. We have added three Moots in the fifth tier. Also, we have promoted two Moots from the fifth tier to the fourth tier. The new Moots that have a place in this List are in bold and the Moots that have been promoted up are in italics.

We were asked to rethink the funda of keeping Vis Hong Kong in the first tier. Also, many suggested that Stetson North and Red Cross Finals be promoted to the first tier. After much deliberation, we have decided not to make any changes in those Tiers. The moots in the first Tier have international participation of at least more than 60 Teams (Vienna and Jessup unjustifiably have huge participation, Hong Kong has around 80 Teams and in Manfred Lachs, the winners of the three regional rounds compete in the Finals (each regional round sees participation from around 20 teams). On the other hand, one does not see such huge international participation in the Stetson World Finals or the Red Cross Moot. Hence, they have been retained in the second tier.

Tier 1 - Global Championships

These include the world finals most prestigious moot court competitions in the world and other world contests involving rigorous competition and wide participation.

Tier 2 - World Class

These are the widely recognised international mooting events where a substantial number of Indian teams participate. These moots enjoy worldwide reputation among law students.

Tier 3 - Elite Class

These mooting events are the best of the elite national contests and some of them are the gateway to the Global Championships/World-class moots in the above tiers.

Tier 4 - National Challengers

Most of the contests in this Tier see participation from the top Indian Law Schools. A large number of them have also carved a niche for themselves in the national mooting scene.

Tier 5 - Best of the Rest

A varied tier that includes good domestic competitions that a range of Indian law schools take part, as well as prestigious international competitions that see only little Indian law school participation.

Domestic Moots

International Moots

These moots are internationally prestigious but only currently see limited participation, and are therefore counted on par with Tier 5 moots. This recognises that winning such a competition is noteworthy but that it would not be fair to disadvantage colleges that could not afford to attend these. For example, only three Indian teams participated in ELSA Asian rounds last year, ICC Mediation Paris saw only 4 Indian teams, Frankfurt International Arbitration only three Indian teams, Maritime International Arbitration in Sydney only two Indian teams, and Oxford IPR saw only two to three Indian teams last year.

Note: In future, if any other Moot is found to be satisfying the criteria of a given Tier, the Moot shall be included in that Tier. Also, if any of the Moots in the List warrant a change in the Tier due valid reasons, the changes shall be made.

Scoring criteria

Category/Tiers	Tier 1 - Global Championships	Tier 2 - World Class	Tier 3 - Elite Class	Tier 4 - National Challengers	Tier 5 - Best of the Rest
Best team	40 points	30 points	20 points	15 points	10 points
Runners-up	35 points	25 points	15 points	10 points	7 points
Best Orator / Memorial / Researcher	30 points each	20 points each	10 points each	7 points each	5 points each
Semi finalists	25 points	15 points	10 points	7 points	5 points
Quarter Finalists	20 points*	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A
Octa Finalists	15 points*	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A
Honourable Mention/Other equivalent awards	10 points	5 points	N/A	N/A	Int'l Moots: 3 points
Stats
Number of competitions	4	4	8	13	20
Total possible points for winners	160	120	160	195	200
Total points for runners-up	140	100	120	130	140

- *Points for Quarter Finalists and Octa Finalists shall not apply to the Manfred Lachs Space Law Moot- World Finals

Now, we need your help:

Look through the list and decide whether you agree with the rankings.
Do you agree with the scoring criteria? Should more points be given for a tier, or less points?
Think of some catchy names to call each tier and let us know!

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-''Version 2.02'': This new list of Moots for [[MPL 2]] contains considerable changes in the Tier System and the Scoring Criteria. A new fifth tier has been included to balance the moots in the other tiers. Also, some exceptional International Mooting Competitions (like ELSA WTO Moot, Frankfurt Arbitration, etc) see abysmal Indian participation, which is unfair to other participants in the [[MPL 2]]. Therefore, instead of excluding them from the [[MPL 2]], we have demoted them to lower tiers to ensure fairness.
+''Version 2.03'': This is the third list of Moots and Scoring Criteria for [[MPL 2]]. In all likelihood, this is going to be the final List. We have been receiving suggestions from our readers regularly and we thank all of you for sparing time and helping us finalize the List.
+This version has incorporated very few changes. We have added three Moots in the fifth tier. Also, we have promoted two Moots from the fifth tier to the fourth tier. The new Moots that have a place in this List are in bold and the Moots that have been promoted up are in italics.
+We were asked to rethink the funda of keeping Vis Hong Kong in the first tier. Also, many suggested that Stetson North and Red Cross Finals be promoted to the first tier. After much deliberation, we have decided not to make any changes in those Tiers. The moots in the first Tier have international participation of at least more than 60 Teams (Vienna and Jessup unjustifiably have huge participation, Hong Kong has around 80 Teams and in Manfred Lachs, the winners of the three regional rounds compete in the Finals (each regional round sees participation from around 20 teams). On the other hand, one does not see such huge international participation in the Stetson World Finals or the Red Cross Moot. Hence, they have been retained in the second tier.
+Total number of Moots – 52 | Tier 1 – 4 Moots | Tier 2- 4 Moots | Tier 3- 8 Moots | Tier 4- 15 Moots | Tier 5- 21 Moots|
-Total number of Moots - 49 | Tier 1 - 4 Moots | Tier 2 - 4 Moots | Tier 3 - 8 Moots | Tier 4 - 13 Moots | Tier 5 - 20 Moots
 === Tier 1 - Global Championships ===
@@ Line 38: / Line 43: @@
 '''Most of the contests in this Tier see participation from the top Indian Law Schools. A large number of them have also carved a niche for themselves in the national mooting scene.'''
+* ''[[Amity Moot Court Competition]]''
 * [[Commonwealth Moot Court Competition|Commonwealth Moot]]
 * [[ELSA Moot Court Competition on WTO Law|ELSA WTO Moot]]
 * [[GNLU International Moot Court Competition|GNLU International Moot]]
+* ''[[International Infrastructure and Construction Law Arbitration Moot (IICLAM)|IICLAM Competition]]''
 * [[ISRO National Funding Round to Manfred Lachs Space Moot|ISRO Manfred Lachs funding rounds]]
 * [[KK Luthra Memorial Moot Court Competition, CLC New Delhi|KK Luthra Criminal Law Moot, Delhi]]
@@ Line 58: / Line 65: @@
 === Domestic Moots ===
-* [[Amity Moot Court Competition]]
 * [[GH Raisoni Law School Moot Court Competition|GH Raisoni Moot]]
 * [[Justice Hidayatullah Memorial National Moot Court Competition|Justice Hidayatullah Memorial Moot]]
 * [[NFCG-Nalsar Moot Court Competition on Corporate Governance|NFCG-Nalsar Moot on Corporate Governance]]
 * [[Nalsar Justice Bodh Raj Sawhney Moot Court Competition|Nalsar BR Sawhney Moot]]
+* '''[[NLIU Tankha Moot Court Competition|NLIU Tankha Moot]]'''
 * [[NLU Antitrust Moot Court Competition, NLU Jodhpur|NLU Antitrust Moot]]
 * [[All India Corporate Law Moot Court Competition, NLU Delhi|NLU Delhi All India Corporate Moot]]
@@ Line 77: / Line 84: @@
 * [[ELSA Moot Court Competition on WTO Law, Asian rounds|ELSA WTO Asian rounds]]
-* [[ICC International Commercial Mediation Moot Court Competition, Paris|ICC Moot, Paris]]
+* '''[[Foreign Direct Investment International Moot Competition, California]]'''
-* [[International Infrastructure and Construction Law Arbitration Moot (IICLAM)|IICLAM Competition]]
+* [[ICC International Commercial Mediation Moot Court Competition, Paris|ICC Moot, Paris]]
+* '''[[John Marshall Law School International Moot Court Competition in Information Technology and Privacy Law, Chicago]]'''
 * [[Frankfurt International Arbitration Moot Court Competition|Frankfurt International Arbitration Moot]]
 * [[Maritime International Arbitration Moot Court Competition, Sydney|Maritime International Arbitration Moot, Sydney]]
 * [[Oxford International IPR Moot Court Competition|Oxford IPR Moot]]
+Note: In future, if any other Moot is found to be satisfying the criteria of a given Tier, the Moot shall be included in that Tier. Also, if any of the Moots in the List warrant a change in the Tier due valid reasons, the changes shall be made.
 ==Scoring criteria==

Difference between revisions of "Mooting Premier League 2010-11 moot court competitions"