Difference between revisions of "Mooting Premier League 2010-11 moot court competitions"

From Legallypedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Tier 4 - National Contenders)
Line 78: Line 78:
 
{|  border="2" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="2" width="674"<tbody>  
 
{|  border="2" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="2" width="674"<tbody>  
 
|  valign="top" | <strong>Category/Tiers</strong>
 
|  valign="top" | <strong>Category/Tiers</strong>
|  valign="top" | <strong>Tier 1 - global championships</strong>
+
|  valign="top" | <strong>Tier 1 - Global Championships</strong>
|  valign="top" | <strong>Tier 2 - world class</strong>
+
|  valign="top" | <strong>Tier 2 - World Class</strong>
|  valign="top" | <strong>Tier 3 - national elite</strong>
+
|  valign="top" | <strong>Tier 3 - Elite Class</strong>
|  valign="top" | <strong>Tier 4 - national contenders</strong>
+
|  valign="top" | <strong>Tier 4 - National Challengers</strong>
 +
|  valign="top" | <strong>Tier 5 - Best of the Rest</strong>
 
|-  
 
|-  
 
|  valign="top" | <strong>Best team</strong>
 
|  valign="top" | <strong>Best team</strong>
 +
|  valign="top" | 40 points
 +
|  valign="top" | 30 points
 
|  valign="top" | 20 points
 
|  valign="top" | 20 points
 
|  valign="top" | 15 points
 
|  valign="top" | 15 points
 
|  valign="top" | 10 points
 
|  valign="top" | 10 points
|  valign="top" | 7 points
 
 
|-  
 
|-  
 
|  valign="top" | <strong>Runners-up</strong>
 
|  valign="top" | <strong>Runners-up</strong>
 +
|  valign="top" | 35 points
 +
|  valign="top" | 25 points
 
|  valign="top" | 15 points
 
|  valign="top" | 15 points
 
|  valign="top" | 10 points
 
|  valign="top" | 10 points
 
|  valign="top" | 7 points
 
|  valign="top" | 7 points
|  valign="top" | 4 points
 
 
|-  
 
|-  
 
|  valign="top" | <strong>Best Orator / Memorial / Researcher</strong>
 
|  valign="top" | <strong>Best Orator / Memorial / Researcher</strong>
|  valign="top" | 12 points each
+
|  valign="top" | 30 points each
 +
|  valign="top" | 20 points each
 
|  valign="top" | 10 points each
 
|  valign="top" | 10 points each
 
|  valign="top" | 7 points each
 
|  valign="top" | 7 points each
|  valign="top" | 4 points each
+
|  valign="top" | 5 points each
 
|-  
 
|-  
 
|  valign="top" | <strong>Semi finalists</strong>
 
|  valign="top" | <strong>Semi finalists</strong>
 +
|  valign="top" | 25 points
 +
|  valign="top" | 15 points
 
|  valign="top" | 10 points
 
|  valign="top" | 10 points
 
|  valign="top" | 7 points
 
|  valign="top" | 7 points
|  valign="top" | 4 points
+
|  valign="top" | 5 points
|  valign="top" | 2 points
+
|-
 +
|  valign="top" | <strong>Quarter Finalists*</strong>
 +
|  valign="top" | 20 points
 +
|  valign="top" | N/A
 +
|  valign="top" | N/A
 +
|  valign="top" | N/A
 +
|  valign="top" | N/A
 +
|-
 +
|  valign="top" | <strong>Octa Finalists*</strong>
 +
|  valign="top" | 15 points
 +
|  valign="top" | N/A
 +
|  valign="top" | N/A
 +
|  valign="top" | N/A
 +
|  valign="top" | N/A
 
|-  
 
|-  
|  valign="top" | <strong>Honourable mention</strong>
+
|  valign="top" | <strong>Honourable Mention/Other equivalent awards</strong>
 
|  valign="top" | 10 points
 
|  valign="top" | 10 points
|  valign="top" | 7 points
+
|  valign="top" | 5 points
 
|  valign="top" | N/A
 
|  valign="top" | N/A
 
|  valign="top" | N/A
 
|  valign="top" | N/A
 +
|  valign="top" | 3 points+
 
|-  
 
|-  
 
|  valign="top" | <em>Stats</em>
 
|  valign="top" | <em>Stats</em>
Line 120: Line 140:
 
|-  
 
|-  
 
|  valign="top" | Number of competitions
 
|  valign="top" | Number of competitions
|  valign="top" | 6
+
|  valign="top" | 4
|  valign="top" | 5
+
|  valign="top" | 4
|  valign="top" | 16
+
|  valign="top" | 9
 +
|  valign="top" | 13
 
|  valign="top" | 20
 
|  valign="top" | 20
 
|-  
 
|-  
 
|  valign="top" | Total possible points for winners
 
|  valign="top" | Total possible points for winners
 +
|  valign="top" | 160
 
|  valign="top" | 120
 
|  valign="top" | 120
|  valign="top" | 75
 
 
|  valign="top" | 160
 
|  valign="top" | 160
|  valign="top" | 140
+
|  valign="top" | 195
 +
|  valign="top" | 200
 
|-  
 
|-  
 
|  valign="top" | Total points for runners-up
 
|  valign="top" | Total points for runners-up
|  valign="top" | 90
+
|  valign="top" | 140
|  valign="top" | 50
+
|  valign="top" | 100
|  valign="top" | 112
+
|  valign="top" | 120
|  valign="top" | 80
+
|  valign="top" | 130
 +
|  valign="top" | 140
 
|}
 
|}
  

Revision as of 19:05, 12 September 2010

Provisionally the following competitions will be included in the MPL 2.

Total- 47 Moots. Tier 1- 6 Moots | Tier 2- 5 Moots | Tier 3- 16 Moots | Tier 4- 20 Moots

Tier 1 - Global Championships

These are the world finals of the most prestigious moot court competitions in the world and includes Vis Vienna, which is the world's single biggest moot by the numbers of teams

Tier 2 - World Class

These are the widely-recognised international mooting events where a substantial number of Indian teams participate or outstanding competitive Indian national moots such as the Bar Council of India Moot

Tier 3 - National Elite

These mooting events include a mix of national qualifiers to Tier 1 events and other national and international competitions that see a good level of participation from Indian law schools but are slightly less competitive or well-known than the higher tier moots.

Tier 4 - National Contenders

A majority of these top national mooting events see participation from varying ranges of Indian law schools. Some moots, such as GNLU International Moot and NLS International Arbitration, even see international participation.

Proposed addition to Tier 4

Scoring criteria

Category/Tiers Tier 1 - Global Championships Tier 2 - World Class Tier 3 - Elite Class Tier 4 - National Challengers Tier 5 - Best of the Rest
Best team 40 points 30 points 20 points 15 points 10 points
Runners-up 35 points 25 points 15 points 10 points 7 points
Best Orator / Memorial / Researcher 30 points each 20 points each 10 points each 7 points each 5 points each
Semi finalists 25 points 15 points 10 points 7 points 5 points
Quarter Finalists* 20 points N/A N/A N/A N/A
Octa Finalists* 15 points N/A N/A N/A N/A
Honourable Mention/Other equivalent awards 10 points 5 points N/A N/A 3 points+
Stats        
Number of competitions 4 4 9 13 20
Total possible points for winners 160 120 160 195 200
Total points for runners-up 140 100 120 130 140

Now, we need your help:

  1. Look through the list and decide whether you agree with the rankings.
  2. Do you agree with the scoring criteria? Should more points be given for a tier, or less points?
  3. Think of some catchy names to call each tier and let us know!