Experts & Views
I took some time out from a busy study schedule to pen this down. If you're amongst the blessed souls that are appearing for the inaugural AIBE, you might agree with some of my comments. If you're not, read on to find out why we're so disgruntled.
Here's the reasons, in no particular order; except maybe the reason appearing at number 1.
10. Because its called 'AIBE'. Roughly translated in a certain Indian language, it means 'come'. Anyone remember that song where Govinda goes - Gharma jo 'AIBE' to hame ka khilaibe?
9. Because the State Bar Councils think it's a bad idea. The Bar Council of India thinks otherwise. Message to BCI - A tree is only as strong as its roots want it to be.
8. Because three students from GLC - Mumbai found the courage to slap the BCI with a writ.
7. Because a lot of other people slapped the BCI with a writ too. Hopefully the BCI isn't funding the proceedings using the Advocates Welfare Fund.
6. Because the BCI thought to themselves - "Legal education is way too inexpensive. Let's rob these future millionaires a couple more quid. And while we're at it, let the poor buggers spend some more time before the books".
5. Because the BCI made us give undertakings to the State Bar Councils that we shall not practice in a Court of Law until we successfully pass the AIBE. Hey BCI, undertakings from students is a sure confidence booster eh?
4. Because they made us write down our addresses, in BLOCK letters, and yet ensured that no one gets an examination centre that is anywhere near HOME.
3. Because this is how they designed our admit cards - 1. Scan name, address, and photograph on the application form filled in by examinee. 2. Pick random examination centre substantially distant from the address on the application form. 3. Print scanned information onto a sheet of unused paper. 4. Mail via UCP.
2. Because they printed the study material in two very neat columns and numbered the lines. Ironically, we Indians are not trained to start again from the first line once we have reached the bottom of the page. But we can count, and YOU numbered incorrectly from 20 through 30 - on all pages - in the entire study material.
1. Because of the video that instructs applicants on how to fill up the application form. I burst out laughing when the guy said "A dark HB Pencil. This is a normal dark HB pencil...". Then the video went on to show us a Black Ink Ball Point Pen and an eraser. And to make the video all the more spooky, they decided to use the same shelf of books as a background for most of the scenes. It's no coincidence that the shelf contained a book called 'Ghost'.
threads most popular
thread most upvoted
comment newest
first oldest
first
1. It proves that you're fit to practice by clearing a standardized examination.
2. It allows you to pithily recollect all that you learnt in the five (or three) years of legal education.
3. If you're amongst opponents to the AIBE, it has ensured that you have read (or heard about) the Advocates Act and the BCI Rules.
4. Two words - quality check!
5. It brings about parity in the profession regardless of your alma mater.
6. It has increased page hits on LI.
7. As is the case with all countries with such entry level exams, there would be a favourable presumption as regards the quality of the Indian legal market.
8. It has encouraged law students to file cases and learn something about filing cases on their own.
9. It weeds out all those people who did law cos they couldn't get an engineering or medicine seat.
10. It gives an opportunity for 3 individuals to top and be known as the brightest legal prospects in the country.
And I the pencil video is indeed brilliant - there's a copy on the Legally India social network:
www.legallyindia.com/Community/General/5-All-India-Bar-Exam-How-to-fill-in-the-Application-Form?userid=83
Cheers,
Kian
Either ways, we live in a democracy. So voice your thoughts. I have no issues.
threads most popular
thread most upvoted
comment newest
first oldest
first