SCOI Reports

SC takes over cases challenging sexist 12% GST on menstrual pads

The apex court will now hear the petitions against the “shocking” tax (according to a petitioner), which lies in contrast to a long list of items that a nil rated under the GST. Mint reported: SC stays proceedings against challenge to 12% GST on sanitary napkins across HCs New Delhi: The Supreme Cou...

Indira Jaising, in support of PIL to make SC live stream important cases, starts online petition

The petition has just under 500 signatures at this time, and states: “I am Indira Jaising, a Senior Advocate of the Supreme Court of India. I have filed a public interest petition in the Supreme Court to live stream and video record cases of national interest that impact each one of us. The Supreme ...

Question marks around Loya petitioners suggest false flag PIL

The petitioners’ alleged affiliations don’t bode well for the apex court inquiry into BH Loya’s death, which would affect other lower court petitions into the matter. The Caravan reported: The Backgrounds of the Loya Petitioners in the Supreme Court Raise Questions About the Legitimacy of Their Peti...

CJI Misra now to hear PIL into Loya death after junior bench bowed out

The reasassignment to a CJI-headed bench follows the recusal of the junior bench that had been assigned by Misra to look into the allegations of foulplay in Justice BH Loya’s death, which had led to the four-most senior apex court judges, other than the CJI, to hold a press conference about Misra’s ...

SC won’t re-open director Mahmood Farooqui ‘well-written' rape acquittal by HC

Farooqi had been convicted by the trial court of rape but acquitted by the Delhi high court.

Aadhaar faces its final SC test, as petitioners throw banyan's worth of shade

The final hearings in the challenges against the beleaguered Aadhaar scheme have begun before a five-judge Supreme Court constitution bench, with petitioners again commencing their attacks against the pseudo-compulsory ID card scheme. Attacks included charges that Aadhaar would “terrorise citizens”,...

After AG, BCI claimed all clear, KKV admits all’s not well in SC after all

Just yesterday, BCI chairman Manan Kumar Mishra and attorney general KK Venugopal claimed ‘all was well’ in the Supreme Court of India.

BCI chairman claims: Everything’s totally fine now at the SC

For what it’s worth, Bar Council of India (BCI) chairman Manan Kumar Mishra told media today that he and other BCI members met with junior judges and the Chief Justice of India (CJI) Dipak Misra in a “congenial atmosphere, everything will be sorted out. Bar council’s role is very limited, judges have assured it there will be no problem at all”.

Rebellion in the ranks: Seniormost SC judges turn against CJI and towards press as conjectures fly over MCI, Loya & more [READ LETTER]

The four most senior Supreme Court judges were, in an unprecedented move, “left with no other option” but to call a press conference after their private meeting with the Chief Justice of India (CJI) Dipak Misra earlier today apparently failed to yield desired results for them.

Collegium welcomes senior counsel Indu Malhotra, KM Joseph J to Supreme Court

Senior advocate Indu Malhotra and Uttrakhand High Court chief justice KM Joseph have been recommended as new judges of the Supreme Court.

SC to take yet another stab at fixing its earlier section 377 decision

The Supreme Court on Monday referred to a larger Bench a writ petition filed by five petitioners to quash Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code which criminalises homosexuality.

CJI meets legal hacks, hints that may allow journos to live tweet from SC courtrooms in future

Chief Justice of India (CJI) _Dipak Misra_ on Monday hinted at possibly allowing journalists to publish news straight from courtrooms on Twitter from their mobile phones, live during case proceedings in the Supreme Court.

SC collegium goes (much more) transparent, begins posting biz online: But will it last, unlike asset disclosures?

The Supreme Court’s collegium of Chief Justice of India (CJI) Dipak Misra and the next senior-most judges, justices J Chelameswar, Ranjan Gogoi, Madan B Lokur and Kurian Joseph, have begun to post recommendations for elevations and other business on a new ‘resolutions of the collegium’ section of its website according to minutes dated 3 October.

Legally Explained: SC challenge to Aadhaar so far, and how on Day 2 Shyam Divan infused new energy into the case that is NOT about privacy - or is it?

As the challenge to compulsory Aadhaar identification to file IT returns was heard by the Supreme Court for the second day today (27 April), the mood among the anti-Aadhaar activists has been upbeat.

Legally Explained: Can I get my neighbour’s cell phone tower removed now, after SC applied ‘precautionary principle’

In a first of its kind, the Supreme Court on 30 March directed the Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL) to deactivate one of its cell phone towers, located in a residential area in Gwalior since 2003, on the mere suspicion by a petitioner that it might have caused the cancer of a resident, working in its vicinity, as first reported by the Times of India.

SCBA condemns BCI, vows to ‘provide strong leadership’ to profession over reform after ‘pernicious... u-turning... BCI let us down’

The Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) has passed a resolution slamming the Bar Council of India (BCI) and that it opposed the Law Commission’s reforms of the profession and that it’s members should wear white arm bands in solidarity with striking lawyers tomorrow.

SC agrees to courtroom video recording in 24 HCs (sans audio, RTI rights)

It’s perhaps not enough of the transparency that the systems needs, but it’s an important step in that direction: once judges get used to a camera staring at them without adverse repercussions (and possibly even benefits, in stop the worst of lawyer theatrics and occasional riot-like behaviour in court rooms), we may even get audio recording, and, eventually maybe, full access to live feeds from courts…

Contrary to earlier reports, collegium maybe never agreed to Gov’t ‘national security’ veto • So, let’s wildly speculate what’s going on

And here’s one of the problems with the opaque collegium and judiciary, which rarely if ever officially confirms anything to journalists, leaving reporting on the bench to often be sourced on hints and whispers.

Parliamentarians should give up law practice, argues SC petition (sure, it’ll never happen, but if it did, it might be a good thing for young lawyers)

A petition filed by advocate Ashwini Kumar Upadhyay in the apex court is arguing that legislators should cease practising law because it gives rise to conflict between their duty to client and to the constitution, seeking to extend the restriction that exists on public servants and judges to carry out professions to elected parliamentarians, reported The Hindu:

The collegium has already been compromised by executive power (and opacity), argues Dushyant Dave

Senior counsel Dushyant Dave, writing in The Wire, has criticised a number of recent decisions of the Supreme Court regarding judicial elevations and transfers, for having been as opaque (as ever) and having missed out on obvious candidates, suggesting that executive pressure scuppered the elevations of several judges who’d handed down decisions the government wouldn’t have liked.