Senior advocate Dushyant Dave wrote to the Chief Justice of India questioning the propriety of a Supreme Court two-judge bench headed by justice CK Prasad which took away a matter listed before a three-judge bench, and decided the matter itself, reported the Times of India yesterday.
Prasad and justice Pinaki Ghose’s bench had in January passed suo motu orders tagging a Cidco golf course tender case to, allegedly, an unrelated criminal appeal it was hearing.
He said the it was “disturbing” how the hearing was “inexplicably snatched from a three-judge bench authorized to hear it”.
Dave, in his letter, said the issue raised a number of questions:
“Why was the bench headed by Justice Prasad so keen to hear the land matter in such unnatural haste in violation of judicial propriety and decorum? How did it learn of it? Could it have, suo motu, with any lawyer or party requesting its tagging, tag it? In any case, the matters were unrelated, as senior counsel C U Singh who appeared in the criminal case had informed Justice Prasad who agreed, but said the common factor was Cidco.”
The letter added, “What was the SC registry doing? Couldn't it have checked the matters were unconnected? After accepting and de-tagging it, ought not the matter to have been sent to the regular bench?”
threads most popular
thread most upvoted
comment newest
first oldest
first
Kejri's conduct has been as interventionist as the Prasad Bench's alleged conduct, caring two hoots for "Rule of Law"
Besides, don't call for RaGa or NaMo either. One man is not a solution to corruption, however a "good man" (role Kejri) a "young man" (role RaGa) or an "able man" (role NaMo) he/she appears as.
If "Registry fixing" happened it should be probed. Dave's query "how did the bench learn about it ?" holds the key to what went on. This must be probed fully to restore faith in the judicial system. Any Judge going against it holds Justice in contempt. I hope the CJI will do the right thing. Let me caution that watching out for "brother judges" (if that comes to pass) will be corrosive for Justice.
threads most popular
thread most upvoted
comment newest
first oldest
first