•  •  Dark Mode

Your Interests & Preferences

I am a...

law firm lawyer
in-house company lawyer
litigation lawyer
law student
aspiring student
other

Website Look & Feel

 •  •  Dark Mode
Blog Layout

Save preferences

Nalsar Vis Vienna winners on how institutions win & lose as India underperforms; NUJS, ILS, MS Ramaiah gain

Following Legally India’s initial report of Nalsar Hyderabad’s victory at the Willem C. Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot, Vienna, the final results have now been announced giving a total of 110 MPL points to participating teams. The Nalsar winners told Legally India the secret to winning and losing in Vienna.

Apart from winners Nalsar, honourable mentions were awarded to NUJS Kolkata, ILS Pune and M. S. Ramaiah College of Law Bangalore.

Nalsar Hyerabad took home 40 MPL points for defeating University College, London in the final rounds of this Tier 1 global championship moot. Nalsar speaker Ishita Bhardwaj won an honorable mention citation for the Martin Domke Award for individual oralists.

Both the ILS Pune speakers, Madhupreetha Elango and Ravi Raghunath and M. S. Ramaiah speaker Monica Patil bagged similar honorable mention citations for their oralist performances.

NUJS Kolkata won the honourable mention citation for the best respondent memorandum. Both ILS Pune and NUJS Kolkata also won honorable mentions for their team orals performance.

Nalsar winners with Vis Prof: Ridhi Kabra, Prof. Eric Bergsten, Ishita Bhardwaj and Jagdish Menezes (From L to R)
Nalsar winners with Vis Prof: Ridhi Kabra, Prof. Eric Bergsten, Ishita Bhardwaj and Jagdish Menezes (From L to R)
The Nalsar team consisted of speakers Jagdish Menezes and Ishita Bhardwaj and researcher Ridhi Kabra.

Menezes said: “We worked really hard for a good eight months for the moot. Before that, we worked on the 16th Vis moot problem and cleared the challengers at Nalsar. This time the moot problem was great. It was very well drafted. However, unlike the other Vis problems, this problem was biased in favour claimants. Most other Vis problems are usually balanced.”

Menezes praised the quality of judging during the moot as “first class”. “I earlier thought that the judging could be subjective. But, I was wrong. These judges come year after year to judge Vis Vienna. There were judges who have been coming for the last 13 years. They are very experienced. The moot is not tiring if you enjoy it. I enjoy arbitration.”

Menezes said that the only reason why Indian teams do not break is because the moot has not been institutionalised in Indian law schools. “Out of the 19 Vis moots, the University of Hamburg has won the moot 5 times. NUJS Kolkata is the only other Indian team that has performed really well at the Vis. This is because they began to institutionalise the Vis mooting culture.

“Mooters every year pass down what they have learnt at Vis. Vis is more of a simulation than any other moot. Other international moots are more like an academic exercise – you need to have knowledge, appropriate court manners, etc. At Vis, you have practitioners who are looking for a commercial solution – you need to be reasonable, you need concede points at times and suggest suitable alternatives. Vis is not like an international moot before the ICJ where you just quote leading precedents. At Vis, you need to present illustrations rather than precedents and you have to use both common law and civil law authorities.”

“Indian teams go to Vis with a very domestic moot mindset or an international law moot mindset. At Vis, you need not argue based on your memo, you can just argue about anything. It is so real world. You just need to have a holistic understanding of the subject in the context of the business involved. Unlike any other domestic or international moot where 20 good precedents can win you a moot, you need to focus on the commercial part of your arguments at Vis.”

Menezes also said that another important challenge was to understand the bench quickly. “Understanding your bench is very important. Civil law judges do not care about cases or precedents. You have to show them some convention or statute and reason out your arguments.”

Menezes also extensively praised their team researcher Ridhi Kabra. “She played a key role in our win. I knew three arguments; Ishita knew three arguments, but Ridhi knew all the six arguments. This is a testament to her hard work.”

Menezes also thanked their team coach Manish for his guidance. “We practiced extensively and we were not tired after doing 4 rounds in a day.” Menezes also mentioned that Nalsar won every single round of the moot by a unanimous decision. “The people who judged us in the semis took us out for lunch before the finals and rooted for us during the finals.”

Mooting Premier League 3 season standings

Pos Law school Pts Details
1 NLSIU Bangalore 288 [Jessup Intl rounds] (hon men for team orals, hon men for 3rd best memo); ISRO Man Lachs (gold); NLS Arb (organisers); Oxford Media Intl rounds (best memo); DMH (best speaker); Surana Corp (silver, best memo); GIMC (gold); KLA (best memo); Rizvi (gold); Jessup South (gold, best memo); Oxford Media India rounds (silver, best memo); Stetson South (gold, best memo); NLIU-Juris Corp (gold, best speaker, best memo); Palkhivala (gold); Dunant (silver); B.R. Sawhney (gold); Trial Adv South (silver); Raj Anand Moot (semis); Maritime Arbitration (semis, best memo, hon men for best resp memo);
2 NLU Jodhpur 200 NLS Arb (best memo); Stetson Intl rounds (gold, 5th best oralist, 9th best oralist); Vis (East) (hon men for respondent memo); Raisoni (gold, best speaker); NLU Antitrust (organiser); Amity moot (silver, best speaker, best researcher); Surana Tech (semis); GIMC (silver); Jessup North (best speaker); Stetson North (gold); Hidayatullah (gold, best speaker, best memo); Dunant (best memo); Trial Adv North (silver, best speaker, best memo); IICLAM (gold);
3 Nalsar Hyderabad 186 [Vis Vienna] (gold, hon men for oralist); [ISRO Man Lachs] (silver); NLS Arb (silver); Oxford Media Intl rounds (gold); Leiden - Sarin (best speaker); BCI - NLU Delhi (semis); NLU Antitrust (silver, best memo); BCI-Nirma (gold, best female speaker); DMH (semis); Jessup South (semis); Oxford Media India rounds (semis);Dunant (gold); B.R. Sawhney (organiser);
4 NLU Delhi 156 [Jessup Intl rounds] (hon men for team orals, hon men for 38th best oralist and 11th best memo); Oxford Media Intl rounds (semis); BCI - NLU Delhi (organisers); ULC moot (best male speaker, best female speaker); BCI-Nirma (semis); Surana Tech (semis); DMH (semis); KLA (semis); Jessup North (gold); KK Luthra (gold); SLCU-LKS-CCI Antitrust (best researcher, semis); Oxford Media India rounds (gold, best speaker); (Law Asia (semis); Dunant (semis); IICLAM (organiser);
5 NUJS Kolkata 119 [Vis Vienna] (hon men for team orals, hon men for best resp memo); Vis (East) (hon men for claimant memo, hon men for respondent memo); NLU Antitrust (gold, best researcher); NUJS-HS (organiser); KLA (silver); SLCU-LKS-CCI Antitrust (gold, best memo); Oxford Media India rounds (semis); NLIU-Juris Corp (semis); Hidayatullah (silver, best researcher); B.R. Sawhney (semis); SLCU Moot (silver, best speaker, best memo); Trial Adv North (semis);
6 GLC Mumbai 106 Amity moot (gold); DMH (best memo); NUJS-HS (gold, best speaker, best memo); SLCU-LKS-CCI Antitrust (best speaker); NLIU-Juris Corp (semis); Trial Adv South (gold, best speaker); IICLAM (Best Memo); Raj Anand Moot (silver);
7 ILS Pune 97 [Vis Vienna] (hon men for oralist, hon men for team orals, hon men for oralist); Pro Bono Enviro (best speaker); BCI - NLU Delhi (best female speaker); Surana Tech (silver); GIMC (best memo, best speaker, semis); KK Luthra (silver); Stetson South (best speaker); B.R. Sawhney (best speaker, semis); Trial Adv South (semis);
8 RMLNLU Lucknow 85 ISRO Man Lachs (best speaker, semis); Stetson Intl rounds (8th best oralist); Leiden - Sarin (gold, best applicant memo); DMH (best reseracher); Surana Corp (semis);KK Luthra (best memo); Stetson North (silver); Palkhivala (silver); Trial Adv North (semis);
9 NLIU Bhopal 77 NLS Arb (best speaker); Pro Bono Enviro (silver, best memo); NLU Antitrust (best speaker, semis); BCI-Nirma (semis); NUJS-HS (silver); GIMC (semis); Rizvi (silver, best speaker); NLIU-Juris Corp (organiser); SLCU Moot (gold); Raj Anand Moot (semis, best memo);
10 Campus Law Centre Delhi 60 BCI - NLU Delhi (silver, best male speaker); Amity moot (semis); ULC moot (semis); KLA (gold); Raj Anand Moot (gold, best speaker);
11 GNLU Gandhinagar 60 Raisoni (silver); Frankfurt (hon men for best team in the Asian regional group); ELSA Asian rounds (best speaker); NLU Antitrust (semis); GIMC (organiser); Jessup North (best memo, semis); Palkhivala (best researcher, semis); B.R. Sawhney (silver); Trial Adv North (gold);
12 RGNUL Patiala 57 Raisoni (semis); Pro Bono Enviro (semis); Amity moot (best memo, semis); ULC moot (silver); Surana Tech (best memo); Jessup North (semis); SLCU-LKS-CCI Antitrust (semis); Stetson North (best speaker); Hidayatullah (semis); B.R. Sawhney (best memo);
13 Jindal Global Law School 57 NLS Arb (semis); ELSA Asian rounds (gold, best memo); [Pro Bono Enviro] (best researcher); ULC moot (gold); NUJS-HS (semis); KK Luthra (semis); Dunant (best speaker, semis);
14 School of Law, Christ University, Bangalore 52 Pro Bono Enviro (semis); Surana Corp (gold, best speaker); KLA (best speaker); SLCU-LKS-CCI Antitrust (organiser); IICLAM (silver, best speaker); SLCU Moot (organiser);
15 SOEL Chennai 46 Pro Bono Enviro (organisers); BCI-Nirma (silver, best male speaker); Jessup South (silver, best speaker); Stetson South (semis);Trial Adv South (best memo);
16 Symbiosis Law School, Pune 40 NLS Arb (semis); BCI - NLU Delhi (semis); ULC moot (best memo); Surana Tech (organisers); NUJS-HS (semis); Rizvi (best memo, semis); Palkhivala (best memo); IICLAM (semis);
17 HNLU Raipur 39 Jessup North (silver);Stetson North (semis); NLIU-Juris Corp (best researcher); Palkhivala (best speaker, semis); [Hidayatullah (organiser); SLCU Moot (semis);
18 CNLU Patna 25 BCI - NLU Delhi (gold); Stetson North (semis);
19 School of Legal Studies, CUSAT Kochi 23 Surana Tech (gold, best speaker);
20 Symbiosis Law School, Noida 14 Pro Bono Enviro (gold); Surana Corp (semis);
21 M. S. Ramaiah College of Law, Bangalore 10 [Vis Vienna] (hon men for oralist);
22 V M Salgaocar Law College, Goa 10 Stetson South (silver);
23 Army Institute of Law, Mohali 10 Stetson North (best memo);
24 Amity Law School IP University Delhi 10 Amity (oraganisers); NLIU-Juris Corp (silver);
25 NUALS Kochi 10 Raisoni (best memo); SLCU-LKS-CCI Antitrust (silver);
26 KLE Bangalore 9 ULC moot (best researcher); IICLAM (semis);
27 New Law College, Bharti Vidayapeeth University, Pune 8 Raisoni (semis); Stetson South (semis);
28 School of Law, Sastra University, Thanjavur 6 ULC moot (semis); Trial Adv South (semis);
29 Dr. Ambedkar Law College, Chennai 5 Jessup South (semis);
30 MATS Law School, Raipur 5 Raisoni (best researcher);
31 Seedling School of Law and Governance, Jaipur 4 ISRO Man Lachs (semis);
31 AKK New Law Academy, Pune 4 KLA (semis);
33 ULC Bangalore 4 ULC moot (organisers); SLCU Moot (semis);
34 SVKM’s Pravin Gandhi College of Law 3 Hidayatullah (semis);
34 Guru Gobind University 3 Rizvi (semis);
36 J S S Law College, Mysore 2 Surana Corp (organiser);
36 Nirma University 2 BCI-Nirma (organisers);
For more information please refer to the MPL 3 rulebook.
Click to show 7 comments
at your own risk
(alt+c)
By reading the comments you agree that they are the (often anonymous) personal views and opinions of readers, which may be biased and unreliable, and for which Legally India therefore has no liability. If you believe a comment is inappropriate, please click 'Report to LI' below the comment and we will review it as soon as practicable.

Latest comments