Exclusive: NLSIU Bangalore graduate and 2010 Rhodes scholar V Niranjan has bagged the prestigious Vinerian Scholarship after topping 140 students in Oxford University’s Bachelor of Civil Law (BCL) – a “simply outstanding” course, in his words.
Niranjan, who told Legally India he would now go on to pursue a career in litigation at the Madras High Court, scored a distinction in all four subjects (70 in restitution, 71 in personal taxation, 72 in conflict of laws and 73 in evidence). He was awarded the John Morris Prize for Best Performance in the Conflict of Laws, Rupert Cross Prize for Best Performance in Evidence and the Gray's Inn Tax Chambers Prize for Best Performance in Personal Taxation.
The Vinerian Scholarship is valued at £2,400 and is awarded at the discretion of the examiner.
The scholarship was named and instituted after legal writer and benefactor Charles Viner in 1755 and recipients include Oxford dons such as John Gardner, as well as legal luminaries such as appeals judge Lord Hoffmann and South African Supreme Court judge Edwin Cameron.
Niranjan along with Aditya Swarup of Nalsar Hyderabad had won the Rhodes scholarship in 2010 and Legally India caught up with him to quiz him on his experiences.
Legally India: What was the Rhodes experience like?
V Niranjan: It was fantastic. It adds a new dimension to studying at Oxford. I am extremely grateful to the Rhodes Trust.
Tell us more about your course selection?
Many students who intend to be barristers take all or some of these courses, although I don't know of too many Indian students with that combination. I took these courses for three reasons. The first is that I very much enjoy hard law and technical subjects in general (especially in English law) and private law in particular. These were natural picks from that point of view.
Secondly, these are widely regarded as among the very best courses in the BCL - and now I can see why. The faculty members teaching these are simply brilliant, and the subjects themselves very demanding - it is therefore a great experience. For example, I can't imagine a better place in the world to study Conflict of Laws and Restitution.
Thirdly, I always intended to litigate, and I plan to focus on commercial law and taxation, which again meant that these very useful subjects to study. What is remarkable about these courses is the depth expected of a student, and the very advanced level at which the Faculty teaches.
What was the level of difficulty compared to NLSIU?
The level expected of a candidate is naturally considerably higher. [see link] In short, good papers, especially in technical subjects like the ones I took, must demonstrate comprehensive knowledge of the case law and literature on the subject, and also develop arguments of one's own. But the courses are taught so exceptionally well by the Law Faculty that it is possible for a candidate to reach that level, and more importantly, to understand the law very well.
How about the quality of teaching compared to Indian undergrad courses?
Simply outstanding. I can't find words to describe how good the teaching is - most often, the faculty members are among the world's leading authorities on the subject, and know it like the back of their hand. The teaching consists principally of seminars, lectures and tutorials. The tutorial system not only makes it impossible for a student to hide, but provides an invaluable opportunity to submit and get feedback on written work, and explore particular issues in greater depth.
The seminars are exhilarating because of the cutting-edge legal issues one ends up discussing, as are the lectures. What is most rewarding is that at the end of the year, one has improved considerably as a lawyer, in important ways - reading cases more carefully and comprehensively, becoming more comfortable with technical private law, learning how to write better, speak better, etc.
And there is also a strong academic tradition beyond the formal seminars - for example, listening to Lord Hoffmann and Laurence Rabinowitz QC speak was an exciting and unforgettable experience (organised by the Oxford Obligations Discussion Group).
Any other Indian students on the BCL?
Quite a few. I can't remember exactly how many, but there must have been around 10.
You were quite the avid mooter in college - any opportunities for mooting at Oxford?
Quite a few. There was so much coursework to do that I had no time - all I could do was judge one moot.
threads most popular
thread most upvoted
comment newest
first oldest
first
Sorry for going off topic- but your insane comment about "greedy" corporate lawyers deserves a response
(i) Whats greedy about corporate law? Do senior counsels work for free? Do they not represent corporate clients? In fact senior counsels in India charge much higher than their "greedy corporate" counterparts- some of their rates even in dollar terms is astronomical. The only thing they lack is the professionalism of their law firm counterparts, not turning up for important hearings being a case in point.
(ii) Perhaps the "greedy" comment comes from the fact that corporate lawyers earn sizeable sums of money, whereas litigators have to work ("struggle") for a pittance... that is supposed to be glorious and unselfish for some reason- I dont know why choosing the dignity and the security a well paying job designates you as greedy- why would you spend your parent's money getting an education from a national law school and then let your intelligence and talent not be adequately compensated... I know another Rhodes Scholar- he works for one of India's most well known litigators in the Supreme Court and gets paid nothing- does he deserve it? I think not.
(iii) Niranjan writes regularly for the Indian "corporate law blog" (yes greedy corporate)- most of his articles are on commercial law, on contract, arbitration, FDI... even his Rhodes subjects include conflict of laws, restitution, personal taxation, all of them very "corporate" subjects... I am sure he will be glad to be called a corporate litigator
Stop this glorification of litigation as a career choice, we know how Indian courts works, we know how orders are obtained...
Niranjan is a supremely talented guy, he would do well wherever he goes... the Madras Bar should be proud to have him, as will corporate law in India
If the quality of litigation lawyers is bad in India, do you wish to wear bangles and sit down when this further deteriorates as MNCs are ready to pay a huge price for their legal work. Niranjan is at least not joining a so called 'desk job' but trying to improve the way the Bar works, even if it is commercial litigation. Senior Counsels may be paid a fortune, but at least they have the balls to go to the bar where they will know that they are likely to excel because of their intelligence.
Between something that offers the security of a stable pay and spending years licking a senior's boots there is really no choice
Kian can we dislike this?
Dude, learn to give credit when its due instead of butting in.
No one cares.
a) Niranjan went on a Rhodes Scholarship;
b) He topped BCL
c) Next time, don't identify yourself as a Noojie.
As far as I know he's the first Indian ever to get a Vinerian Scholarship. That certainly deserves plaudits. By dragging NUJS into it, you just come across as petty and insecure. Next time, show some grace and give credit where it is due.
Dude! what is wrong with you...you lack the basic comprehension skill. Did you even read the article?if you are still wondering, it's not about making into BCL. Are noojies this dumb?
Please do not haul the entire nujs community for some snake like him. We are not at all jealous, in fact we are overwhelmed given the fact that he is an Indian first.
Abroad, it is never about nujs or nlsiu, it is always about Indians laying their mark in Oxford or any place whatsoever.
Thanks !
Noojies arent. This guy is just trying to pass off as a noojie and malign nujs with his comments. Congrats niranjan
Please stop embarassing NUJS. I am sure you are from some other unheard of college and are trying to malign NUJS by passing yourself off as a Noojie. If you are to embarassed to use the name of your own college, just post anonymously, dont steal the name of my college
this is soooo not a nalsarite.
nice try though.
when did kian mention anything about the the noojie students?
Oh dear lord. Could you make it any more obvious that you're NOT a noojie? Nice try though. Bored, were you?
To all those who actually reply to such troll comments - are you guys really this dumb?
Congratulations Niranjan! You've made all of us, lawyers / law students alike, a proud lot!
Long time back I met another NLS guy who was the winner of Henry Dunant Moot in 2005 ...later on, he too went to Oxford as Rhodes Scholar. His name was Arghya Sengupta. Can anybody tell me where is he now ?
Kian I really think you should emphasise he is coming back home instead of his marks. Also, can you please ban NUJS students from this site? At least have a "dislike" button
Mithunda, actually Montek did work abroad with the World Bank. If you are going to make sweeping generalisations of the kind above, please could you at least ensure that both of the two random examples which you use make sense in the context in which you use them?
thanks..
threads most popular
thread most upvoted
comment newest
first oldest
first