‘Singular stories but shared destinies’: If you’re at an NLU this is really worth reading, because it could be the start of something truly amazing‘Singular stories but shared destinies’: If you’re at an NLU this is really worth reading, because it could be the start of something truly amazing

The student bar associations of NLSIU Bangalore, Nalsar Hyderabad and NUJS Kolkata have released an unprecedented joint statement in solidarity with the recently-successful student protestors at NUSRL Ranchi, and issued a call for all national law school students to work together towards jointly fixing what they feel is a root cause of many NLUs’ problems: a distinct lack of funding.

Explaining the coordination between the student bar associations at three of the four oldest national law schools - which are also the “only organised student unions among all NLUs” - NLSIU Student Bar Association (SBA) president Aman Saxena said that a consensus was reached by them over the NUSRL issue, while also expressing their “intent to work together towards” the end of securing for NLUs Institute of National Importance (INI) status and accompanying central government funding, as enjoyed by elite institutions such as IITs or IIMs.

The students’ three-page manifesto, of sorts, explains what INI status for NLUs would mean and why they hope it would solve many of the problems faced by NLUs.

“Together, we will be charting our course of action over the coming days by attempting to get all students of all the NLUs, VCs, BCI and HRD Ministry on board,” said Saxena. “It is a daunting and prolonged task to build consensus but we are committed to it as we see a lot of tangible benefit accruing to the law school fraternity at the end of it.”

NUJS Student Juridical Association (SJA) vice president Samarth Sharma added: “We understand that every NLU has its own culture and specific set of grievances. However, regardless of the multiplicity of our perspectives, we firmly believe that granting the status of Institutes of National Importance to these islands of excellence is not only warranted but also will go a long way in solving the common problems faced by all of these institutions.

"We hope this demand will transcend our valuable cultural differences and garner support from all stakeholders in the fraternity. Our stories might be singular, but our destinies are definitely shared,” added Sharma.

Nalsar Student Bar Council (SBC) president Yugal Jain added: “The situation at Ranchi is really unfortunate and I am very proud that the students have been able to put up a brave and succesful fight against the mighty administration.

“I am glad that students from various law schools are coming together on this issue. I am very optimistic that this collaboration will serve as a medium to voice common concerns and design progressive solutions.”

On NUSRL: Kudos

The joint statement commends “the courage and determination of our counterparts at NUSRL” - whose 4-day protest ended on a mostly successful note yesterday - and applauds the “heartening... constructive dialogue among the students and representatives from the judiciary and the state”.

It adds that the "compromises thus reached, that is annual publication of audit reports, appointment of a financial officer, setting up of a school review commission and most importantly, permission of formation of a student union would go a long way in ensuring effective checks and balances between the administration and the administered”.

“Lack of accountability of those appointed at the helm of these universities and minimal transparency in the use of allocated funds lead to dismal state of affairs of the public institutions,” noted the statement, adding: “Kudos to these students for having attained that and we hope the resolutions passed in the meeting are abided by.”

Also read:

The big picture and an ambitious solution

But the joint statement also points out a compelling and much wider problem facing nearly all NLUs, and a possible way of solving it.

"The National Law Universities (NLUs) have been struggling due to lack of funds,” notes the statement, relying entirely on meagre University Grants Commission (UGC) budgets, while “the dissolution of the erstwhile Planning Commission” has left “no clarity on if, when and how NLUs will be provided further grants by the UGC”.

Moreover, funding through NLUs’ “home states’” budgets, have been “often very erratic and largely depends on realization of importance of NLUs by individual states”,

While some of the states like Delhi and Gujarat are generous in funding their NLUs, most other states are not so kind. NLSIU, for instance receives only Rs 2 Crores as an annual grant from Karnataka Government. It hardly meets 3 months’ worth of salaries of its staff. It needs to be mentioned that seventh pay commission recommendations will be applicable to these universities in the coming months, thereby increasing the cost of salaries by another 30%. On the other hand, barring a few instances here and there, NUJS does not have any steady support from the West Bengal State Government.

A possible solution proposed in the joint statement would be to recognise national law schools as “Institutes of National Importance (INI)”, on par with other universities, that have been less neglected, and that receive considerable funding via the Ministry of Human Resource Development’s budget, which provides annual Rs 7800 crore funding to IITs, Rs 3500 crore funding to NITs, Rs 1000 crore funding to IIMs, Rs 650 crores to IISERs:

An Institute of National Importance is defined as an institute ‘which serves as a pivotal player in developing highly skilled personnel within the specified region of the country/state’. While there exists no guideline for the same, we believe that on such evaluation, as may be prescribed, the NLUs will squarely fall within the criteria of contributing highly skilled personnel to the legal profession, judiciary, bureaucracy, policy think tanks, academia and various other avenues.

An unprecedented joint statement & initiative

As far as we are aware, this is the first time that three national law schools student bar associations have got together to release a joint statement in support of another law school and vowed such close future cooperation.

Explaining how the project got started, NLSIU’s Saxena said: “Over the past few days, especially after the NUSRL debacle, I have been working on the idea of seeking Institutes of National Importance (INI) status for the National Law Universities. The idea is to ensure that national law universities, recognized as the prominent institutions in the country to impart legal education and which contribute highly qualified personnel to the legal profession, should not solely depend on their respective state support which is more often than not non-existent.”

“Heartfelt gratitude needs to be expressed to Arjun [Agarwal, president] & Samarth [Sharma] (SJA, NUJS) and Yugal [Jain] & Renuka [Bhukya, general secretary] (SBC, NALSAR) for the cooperation extended and their inspiring commitment to work together towards this cause,” Saxena added.

In its conclusion the students’ statement - which is worth reading in full below - states:

The root of the problem needs to be fixed. We are in the process of contacting student bodies of all the NLUs to endorse our claim. We also request all the Vice Chancellors of the National Law Universities and the Bar Council of India to recognize and appreciate this problem so that we can work together to garner appropriate funding from the Government.

NLSIU Nalsar NUJS joint statement on working together for the greater NLU good (PDF)

experts & views

Click to show 22 comments
at your own risk
(alt+shift+c)
By reading the comments you agree that they are the (often anonymous) personal views and opinions of readers, which may be biased and unreliable, and for which Legally India therefore has no liability. If you believe a comment is inappropriate, please click 'Report to LI' below the comment and we will review it as soon as practicable.
refresh Filter out low-rated comments. Show all comments. Sort chronologically
1
Like +20 Object -1 X2 14 Apr 17, 19:03  interesting  top rated
Long overdue! Kudos to the SBAs. 2 crore per annum is paltry. Financial assistance given to students for tuition and competitions abroad must cost that much! Law schools like Jindal prove that money does matter in hiring good faculty and developing resources which ultimately affect the student body.
Reply Report to LI
2
Show?
Like +3 Object -0 Saxenalove 14 Apr 17, 22:05
The President of the NLS SBA seems to be very competent. I hope he becomes president for #onemoreyear.
Reply Report to LI
3
Show?
Like +0 Object -4 Reader 15 Apr 17, 00:33
I believe there has been a typo in Samarth Sharma's statement.
It must be Institute of National Importance.
Reply Report to LI
4
Like +11 Object -0 Proud NALSARite 15 Apr 17, 00:35  interesting
Well done guys! Glad to see the law schools come together overcoming the traditional rivalry (and sometimes animosity).

Really proud of Yugal and Renuka!
Reply Report to LI
5
Like +8 Object -0 Guest 15 Apr 17, 00:59  interesting
Long overdue but great move. Hope Legally India supports this as well.

Next step should be to submit a memorandum to different central ministers and opposition MPs. SibAl, Ramjet etc should raise it in parliament.
Reply Report to LI
6
Like +11 Object -4 Chacko 15 Apr 17, 01:08  interesting
One additional point should be made: NLU faculty salaries are much poorer than IIT and IIM so alumni are not joining as faculty, only ppl from rubbish institutes are. Alumni are joining jindal instead.
Reply Report to LI
6.1
Like +5 Object -0 Guest 16 Apr 17, 14:05  interesting
The two down votes to the comment are by Venki and his pal Ishwar Bhat.
Reply Report to LI
6.2
Show?
Like +4 Object -2 Darkseid 16 Apr 17, 20:01
Actually, while I agree about the salary disparity, there are still plenty of NLU grads (I mean the LL.B. ones, not LL.M.), who are working in the top flight NLUs now. NUJS, NALSAR, NLUD all have several NLU alumni working there. While salary is no doubt important, what these people would prefer more is a rational administration, and freedom to overhaul the ailing system more than anything else. Otherwise, a fresher joining an NLU these days gets a starting salary of about 7 lakhs p.a., which is not too shabby given the workload, even though it can certainly be better.
Reply Report to LI
6.2.1
Show?
Like +2 Object -1 Guest 17 Apr 17, 16:54
Sorry, but the number of LLB alumni teaching at the NLUs is too few and not "several" as u claim.
Reply Report to LI
6.2.1.1
Show?
Like +4 Object -1 Darkseid 17 Apr 17, 22:43
Only at NUJS at present, at least 8 NLU grads are offering regular courses, some permanent and others contractual. That accounts for more than 25% of the total faculty strength there I believe. NLUD too has at least 6 if not more. Not sure about the exact number at NALSAR, but there are at least some. Granted the number can and should increase though, no arguments there. But before making comments, maybe you should verify the statistics first. Mind you, being an NLU grad does not make someone a good teacher automatically. Only students can say how good/bad these people are.
Reply Report to LI
7
Show?
Like +4 Object -1 Constructive 15 Apr 17, 10:23
As a former President from one of these SBA's, please take the VCs along as there some who can really help fast track this. In fact this gives them ammunition.

Otherwise, the academic year is over and the terms of these people will be over. Hence it is important for them to hand over the baton properly so that this goes forward constructively. Please rise above petty law school policitics and do something to make your college better.
Reply Report to LI
7.1
Like +4 Object -0 Guest 15 Apr 17, 13:04
Most of the sitting VCs of NLUs are the root of the problem, therefore, taking them along will it work
Reply Report to LI
8
Show?
Like +1 Object -2 Guest 15 Apr 17, 16:18
Bar and Bench is reporting that NUJS recruitment was a flop and college is hiding figures. Kiam please confirm.
Reply Report to LI
8.1
Show?
Like +3 Object -0 kianganz 15 Apr 17, 16:23
Hehe, not sure it's fair to call it a flop, though their decision to keep Day Zero figures confidential again this year is certainly regretful in my book.

For those not sure what this is about, the NUJS RCC has just released the following statement:

http://sja.nujs.edu/newsroom/2017/04/15/nujs-rpc-batch-of-2018-official-statement-on-day-zero-figures

Anyway, it's a pretty long story, we'll probably tell it in a little while... :)
Reply Report to LI
8.1.1
Like +5 Object -1 Tweety 15 Apr 17, 22:05
At least 47 offers including PPOs is what the grapevine has revealed so far. So sure, it flopped and very soon the students will be seeking guidance from other NLUs as to how to conduct DZs.
Reply Report to LI
9
Show?
Like +0 Object -5 Guest 15 Apr 17, 18:29
The NUJS SJA is useless. They can'take even get the college to update it's pathetic website.
Reply Report to LI
10
Like +4 Object -0 Really? 15 Apr 17, 22:02
This is bizzare. The NLSIU SBA needs to take a closer look at accounts. Funds aren't really the problem; the decision makers are.

Has the SBA been duped?
Reply Report to LI
11
Show?
Like +2 Object -1 Guest 16 Apr 17, 02:27
Please do stories relevant for CLAT aspirants!! We especially need guidance on choosing the right law school and non-NLU ones like Symbol, Amity and Jindal.
Reply Report to LI
11.1
Show?
Like +1 Object -0 CLAT Aspirants!! 17 Apr 17, 06:52
You cannot enter the law schools you mentioned through CLAT - there are separate exams for them.

If you are writing CLAT, there is less than a month to go. About time you started studying.
Reply Report to LI
12
Show?
Like +1 Object -0 Guest 19 Apr 17, 02:20
I agree that the issue of poor faculty is critical and should have been addressed into petition. Some NLUs may have a few alumni teaching (mostly part-time), but the need is to have at least 50 to 60 % full-time faculty in each NLU who are LLB alumni of NLUs (preferably the leading NLUs) and have LLM/PhDs from reputed universities abroad, as well as good work ex.
Reply Report to LI
13
Show?
Like +0 Object -2 AA 20 Apr 17, 12:02
I think NLUD should also join these three law schools considering the fact that it also considers itself as one of the top law schools in the country.
Reply Report to LI
13.1
Show?
Like +0 Object -0 CLAT Aspirants!! 20 Apr 17, 14:51
Yeah, right. Top Law School - Lol
Reply Report to LI

refreshSort chronologically Filter out low-rated comments. Show all comments.