According to the Economic Times, citing an unnamed "senior law ministry official", senior counsel and former solicitor general Gopal Subramanium's nomination to the Supreme Court bench, which was announced by the collegium and then-new Chief Justice of India (CJI) RM Lodha last month, is currently on ice, with the new BJP government mulling sitting on the collegium's recommendation in Subramanium's case to effectively nix his nomination.

The ET reported the official saying that the "suitability" of Subramanium was being "discussed at the highest levels" and that the government had not responded to the collegium recommendation with its consent in his case, though no authoritative reasons for the reluctance were reported.

The government could effectively delay a Supreme Court judge's appointment indefinitely by never responding to the collegium's recommendation, explained senior counsel KTS Tulsi, while another law ministry official told the ET that the new government might fast track the Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) Bill in the meantime, which would in any case end the current collegium system.

experts & views

Click to show 4 comments
at your own risk

NB: By reading the comments you agree that they are the personal views and opinions of readers, for which Legally India has no liability whatsoever. Because anonymous comments may be biased or unreliable, you agree that you will not allow any comment(s) to affect your estimation of any person(s) or organisation(s). If you believe a comment is inappropriate, please click 'Report to administrator' below the comment with your objection and we will review it as soon as practicable.


Filter out low-rated comments. Show all comments. Sort comments chronologically

Like +9 No like -3 Chiefs Court 2014-06-11 09:57  interesting
No, Mr Law Minister, Please dont do this. Gopal is perhaps the only person who has original dynamic thinking. He would be an asset to the Supreme Court Bench and will also raise the standards for the future of the Bar.
Reply | Report to LI | #  link
Like +1 No like -2 Suyash 2014-06-11 18:58
The government has just delayed the appointment. Even if the name is recommended to the JAC, the JAC will also appoint him. In fact its good that the first person to be appointed by JAC would be an absolutely deserving person.
Reply | Report to LI | #  link
Like +5 No like -2 Guest 2014-06-11 12:12
The matter must be dealt with transparently. It should not happen that a deserving person is excluded only because of political reasons.
Reply | Report to LI | #  link
Like +0 No like -1 Guest 2014-06-12 08:45
"The government could effectively delay off a Supreme Court judge's appointment indefinitely by never responding to the collegium's recommendation"

Has this ever happened?
Reply | Report to LI | #  link

refreshSort comments chronologically

Filter out low-rated comments. Show all comments.

Add comment

Comments locked on old articles.