The must-read email
- OSS Legal Expert(Growthsolution)
- Corporate M&A Director or Executive Director (8+ yrs pqe) Mumbai(Hughes-Castell (Hong Kong) Ltd.)
- India Director or Executive Director (8-10 yrs pqe) Mumbai(Hughes-Castell (Hong Kong) Ltd.)
- India Legal Counsel (5-7 yrs pqe) Mumbai(Hughes-Castell (Hong Kong) Ltd.)
- Sr. Associate(Confiar Global)
- Litigation Partner(Confiar Global)
- Legal Counsel (8-10 yrs pqe) India(Hughes-Castell (Hong Kong) Ltd.)
- Commercial director(LegallyIndia.com)
Top tags
amarchand mangaldas azb partners bangalore bar council of india bci bar exam best friends campus recruitment capital markets clifford chance crawford bayley desai diwanji foreign firms foxmandal little humour j sagar associates jsa job moves jones day khaitan co kochhar co kolkata law firms law schools legal education legal process outsourcing lpo legally drawn cartoon liberalisation linklaters luthra luthra ma mooting premier league mumbai nalsar hyderabad newsletter nlsiu bangalore nujs kolkata partner hires society of indian law firms silf sr associates trilegal veerappa moily
Written by Kian Ganz Tuesday, 12 January 2010 00:00
KR Chawla & Co partner Sumes Dewan and former Patni Computer Systems executive vice president and general counsel Ajit Yadav have both joined FoxMandal as partners.
Dewan has joined the firm with two associates to boost the capital markets practice with international expertise.
He said that he had moved with the entire corporate division and corporate clients of KR Chawla to join FoxMandal's existing corporate and capital markets practice.
"I will build up the corporate practice and their cap markets practice because personally and in my team we do a lot of global listings, ICM [international capital markets] and Luxembourg Stock Exchange work," he added. "We are building and coming up with a more specific capital markets division."
Dewan had been a partner at KR Chawla since 2000 and headed the firm's corporate practice, according to an international legal directory.
KR Chawla partner Harvansh Chawla made a statement that Dewan's "services were terminated" and that the firm still had a corporate practice of 22 lawyers. He declined to elaborate further.
Dewan and FoxMandal managing partner Som Mandal strongly denied that Dewan's "services were terminated" and Mandal added: "Sumesh has come with his entire team."
The second partner hire Yadav was the executive vice president and general counsel of Patni Computer Systems for almost three years.
Mandal said: "He's a corporate commercial partner and he's one of the most experienced GCs in India."
Yadav was previously also the executive director of PepsiCo India between 2000 and 2006 and the company secretary of Hindustan Lever between 1981 and 1994.
Yadav was unavailable for comment at the time of going to press and Patni Computer declined to comment. Patni Computer also operates the legal process outsourcing joint venture Bodhi Global with AZB & Partners co-founding Zia Mody and Bahram Vakil.
A number of FoxMandal partners had left in the past months, with four partners most recently starting up SRGR Law Offices.
However, Mandal noted that last year's cash-flow crisis of FoxMandal Delhi was now settled. "Every firm has its ups and downs," he said. "We had a difficult time last year and have all put it behind us now and are very aggressive this year."
Dewan said that last year's late payment of salaries was not an issue in his joining: "That was a thing of the past - it's been completely solved."
Mandal also confirmed that he and several senior partners who owned the firm's Noida office property had entered into a sale and leaseback transaction with private third parties late last year.
"We just restructured," he explained. "[The office is] not part of the firm's investment – it is part of a private company which is owned by me and some partners.
"In any case, FoxMandal was a tenant [and] as a firm did not own [the property]."
Comments (17)

NB: The comments below are the personal views and opinions expressed by readers and are not those of Legally India. If you believe a comment is inappropriate, please send us a message with your objection and contact details and we will review it as soon as practicable.
written by Anonymous, 12 January 2010 17:34
So, the unique business model is really working! The 3 years cycle of changing partners' batch at FML is at works. Firm has saved [...] Crs by not paying its outgoing partners - while pocketing all billings done by them. [...] BTW, who are the senior partners who own the assets - managing partner's wife, father and brothers ! How does Somesh knows that the partners have been paid off? Has he spoken with them? OR he has seen the receipts issued by them?
#3Property
written by kianganz, 13 January 2010 15:23
written by kianganz, 13 January 2010 15:23
@1: FYI, I understand from sources that a number of other senior equity partners also owned minority stakes in the office property.
written by Anonymous, 13 January 2010 16:01
[...] Its very clear to all that [the firm] has not paid all the dues of the past partners and associates and even the present in the firm. [...]
#1; You are right this is a recycling which is happened over again.
[...]
#3 Your facts seem to be wrong. Som himself has said that the property was not in the name of the firm and was in the name of companies owned by him. Thus no partner has any equity interest. [...]
[In response to 3: I do not think your statement is correct. Sources outside but close to FML have independently confirmed that several other equity partners except the Mandal family also held a stake, although the Som Mandal was the majority equity holder in the property. -Ed]
#1; You are right this is a recycling which is happened over again.
[...]
#3 Your facts seem to be wrong. Som himself has said that the property was not in the name of the firm and was in the name of companies owned by him. Thus no partner has any equity interest. [...]
[In response to 3: I do not think your statement is correct. Sources outside but close to FML have independently confirmed that several other equity partners except the Mandal family also held a stake, although the Som Mandal was the majority equity holder in the property. -Ed]
written by Anonymous, 13 January 2010 16:16
Anybody can go to ROC website and check the shareholding pattern of FMIT Pvt Ltd and Fox Mandal Consulting Pvt Ltd. These are public documents. Only paltry shareholding is held by few oldies of the firm. It could have happened at the time of incorporation of shell companies.
written by Anonymous, 13 January 2010 22:23
What has happened to the comments. Anyway. Kian I will soon be in touch with you for some breaking news.
#7We love news!
written by kianganz, 13 January 2010 22:28
written by kianganz, 13 January 2010 22:28
Thanks, I look forward to hearing from you!
As far as I know, othing happened to the comments but maybe much of what can be said has been said on the subject? Or maybe not. Who knows...
As far as I know, othing happened to the comments but maybe much of what can be said has been said on the subject? Or maybe not. Who knows...
written by Anonymous, 14 January 2010 09:36
Kian, maybe a lot has been said but it has in any case fallen on deaf ears. Its just as if it doesnt make any difference [...]. The policy is not to pay and that pretty much remains unchanged. That said, there is still lots of things and news which have been said or come to light. I think its going to time soon for that.
written by Anonymous, 14 January 2010 20:44
i see Mr Anonymous to be highly pained by what is going on in FML. Mr Anonymous please understand that this very firm has given a platform in terms of experience and learning to many advocates who have used this experience to their benefit (including the partners..who have now chosen to leave). Every organisation goes through a period of turmoil.....and it is during this period that those who stay back to show loyalty towards the organisation benefit when the tide turns. Mr Anonymous , do give it a thought.
written by Anonymous, 15 January 2010 14:33
Mr/Ms Tweet
Why do you keep forgetting that it is because of the people (including those partners who left) that the firm earned what it earned. Its very easy to say that the firm has given the experience and learning but the firm also charged a big fee for the same. The firm and neither Mr. Mandal gave anything for free. No good can happen unless the firm and Mr. mandal realise that the actual asset of a firm is the people and not houses and buildings and cars. Luckily the payments are coming in right now but what if this happens again. What are the people supposed to do.
Why do you keep forgetting that it is because of the people (including those partners who left) that the firm earned what it earned. Its very easy to say that the firm has given the experience and learning but the firm also charged a big fee for the same. The firm and neither Mr. Mandal gave anything for free. No good can happen unless the firm and Mr. mandal realise that the actual asset of a firm is the people and not houses and buildings and cars. Luckily the payments are coming in right now but what if this happens again. What are the people supposed to do.
written by Anonymous, 15 January 2010 14:45
What is one required to do to ensure timely payment for the work done. If the work is required to be done in a timely manner then why dont the payments happen in time. I just hope that the situation which happened is not repeated. Thank you.
written by Anonymous, 15 January 2010 16:35
It’s shocking to see K.R. Chawla partner Harvansh Chawla making a statement that Dewan’s "services were terminated”, the desperation of Harvansh Chawla is evident. It’s evident that such statements are being made out of sheer frustration and show lack of grace and maturity
written by Anonymous, 15 January 2010 18:19
I agree with tMr/Ms Tweet! In fact, instead of asking for their salaries/dues, all these outsiders must have paid huge fees to the managing partner [...] for providing them such excellent experiences, learnings and, of course, sight of such nice offices and luxury cars [...]! These people of small minds will never understand!
written by Anonymous, 19 January 2010 01:23
the scenario of holding on to the dues for the reason that the person is leaving d firm is no good deed......who knows rather it could be vice versa!! its true that such comments made by Mr. Chawla is nothing but Vengence but such ppl forget that there is a long way to go in life ahead n much above all this... n goes unsaid such things rather compel to take such a lifetime decision....FML aint that little anyways, its jus doesnt ponder over lil things....Best wishes to Mr. Dewan, Mr. Yadav and Mr. Mandal!
written by Anonymous, 19 January 2010 11:56
Dear #14, you seem to be very desparate to leave the firm! You really do not have any business sense though you are a lawyer! Pl understand - this is the trick - this how a person becomes a big personality - you should know how to use others' money and efforts/capabilities to your own advantage and that too with your leg up - and best of it is that you will think that nobody can do any harm to you (but only time will tell). It is like changing rules after the game is finished! Understood Now !
written by Anonymous, 19 January 2010 13:06
Best wishes to all, the ones who are in FM and the ones who have left and more than that best luck to the ones who have just joined. 2005, 2009. Next ? 2012?? It has happened in the past, it just happened and it will happen again. Really, where does all the money go. Its really surprising.
Write comment

Related Articles
- India Today/Outlook law school rankings 2010: NLIU gains, NUJS drops most
- FoxMandal Delhi break-away SRGR parts with co-founder over strategy
- Pangea3 hires 18 from campus, will pump Rs 48 crore into Delhi to outgrow Mumbai
- Bar Council to crack down on law firm websites and advertisement
- Amarchand turnover near $40m, law firms bill $350m, says report
- Little & Co partner joins Majmudar as firm moves to Bandra
- London FoxMandal-Sir Gavin tie-up ends; Firm hires UK minister
- FoxMandal brings environment law firm on board
- IP start-up gets Swiss-connection with senior joiner
- UAE-based law firm to open Kerala offices
- Breaking news: Bombay High Court rules against foreign firms in Lawyers Collective case
- Four FoxMandal partners go it alone to create new 'top-10 Delhi firm'
- Amity tops IICLAM moot; Bhopal targets pole position (CORRECTION)
- Luthra & Luthra takes on 50% more space in Delhi
Follow Legally India updates via Facebook.
Follow us on Twitter
Join our Linked-in group
RSS newsfeed
